So far yes it has been. But what he's saying is that in cases of so many people the risk of catching innocents in crossfire outweighs the likelihood that their

So far yes it has been. But what he's saying is that in cases of so many people the risk of catching innocents in crossfire outweighs the likelihood that their IP address is actually connected to someone doing the infringing. This is only in New York though, but the precedent is there now for lawyers around the US to make their cases. EDIT: likelihood wasn't spelled likely