6 ms·
For a policy that's ostensibly designed to fight air pollution and "reclaim streets for pedestrians and cyclists", penalizing vehicle tonnage seems like a weird
by gruez 3y ago
For a policy that's ostensibly designed to fight air pollution and "reclaim streets for pedestrians and cyclists", penalizing vehicle tonnage seems like a weird way of achieving it. If you want to fight air pollution, charging based on emissions like the ULEZ in London[1] seems like a much more effective way of doing so, especially since a 20 year old sedan can easily emit more air pollution than a recent SUV. As for "reclaim[ing] streets for pedestrians and cyclists", the bigger problem is arguably on-street parking itself and the space it occupies, rather than the of the cars occupying them. If you want to create more space for pedestrians and cyclists, replace on-street parking with cycling lanes or sidewalks, and the market (for parking spaces) will take care of the rest.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra_Low_Emission_Zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra_Low_Emission_Zone
- vosper 3y agoPerhaps it’s because getting hit by a SUV tends to be much worse for a passenger or cyclist than being hit by a smaller car?
- ustolemyname 3y ago1. Larger vehicles pose a much greater threat to pedestrians and cyclists, both from frequency and consequence of incidents. 2. Tire emissions are more toxic than exhaust [1] and tire wear is dramatically greater on heavier vehicles. This is about air pollution in the city, not climate change globally. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jun/03/car-tyres-produce-more-particle-pollution-than-exhausts-tests-show https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jun/03/car-tyre...
- blibble 3y agonot to mention the road damage caused is to the fourth power of the axle load
- gruez 3y agoThat also implies that trucks are much worse than cars OR suvs, and should be banned entirely as well.
- alamortsubite 3y ago[flagged]
- _ache_ 3y agoYes, out of the city ideally, you will use cargo train. In fact, in some (french) city lorry are forbidden, only local service are permitted. The most heavy one are already forbidden on the WE, day off and summer all over France.
- jacquesm 3y agoBut then you'd need to have a viable alternative and that's a bit of a problem for 'last miles' delivery of goods. But in-city SUV traffic is entirely optional.
- tzs 3y agoWhat range of weight is that fourth power rule valid for?
- ToucanLoucan 3y ago> 2. Tire emissions are more toxic than exhaust [1] and tire wear is dramatically greater on heavier vehicles. This is about air pollution in the city, not climate change globally. Is there any info on how this impacts the environmental benefits of EVs? Or is the lack of combustion still a net gain?
- pille 3y agoI found one write-up investigating this a few months ago: https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/electric-vehicles-air-pollution https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/electric-vehicles-... Trying to summarize: EVs still seem to be a net gain, but non-exhaust emissions are still a significant problem. We don't know how bad that problem really is because there's not enough research yet.
- _ache_ 3y agoWhat are you measuring ? CO2 emission or particles count in the air ? Worst for particles emission, better for CO2 emission, basically. Hope we will improve down tire emission.
- zihotki 3y agoThere is a simple solution - use a small electric car/microcar with small battery for driving in the city.
- jjtheblunt 3y agothe BMW i3 fits that, as did the Fiat 500e? (i had a 2014 BMW i3, and it was super weird and super useful for just such situations, including suburbia in my case)
- alamortsubite 3y agoA Renault Twizy would be better. Or much better, an electric bike. Paris bike infrastructure is getting very good.
- jacquesm 3y agoIn traffic the Twizy isn't all that much better than a motorcycle, I would go for a car chassis based EV before even considering a Twizy. I also think they are way too expensive for what they offer.
- alamortsubite 3y agoTo each his own. As a motorcyclist, I feel a motorcycle is better than a Twizy, but in Paris a Twizy is a lot better than a small car for navigating traffic and parking.
- jacquesm 3y agoAs a parent I wouldn't go near a motorcycle let alone ride one in traffic. When I was a kid that was different but the responsibility towards my family precludes me from taking excessive risk. The Twizy embodies excessive risk for me to a degree that I would not drive one.
- _ache_ 3y ago
- tokai 3y agoParticle pollution from car tires are much worse from heavy vehicles. Apparently recent research suggest that emissions tires are much larger and more dangerous than exhaust emissions. https://e360.yale.edu/features/tire-pollution-toxic-chemicals https://e360.yale.edu/features/tire-pollution-toxic-chemical...
- wepple 3y agoThis seems to be pretty wildly left out of the gas->electric push then? I’m not saying it makes electrification less valuable, but rather the push for electric has very much been sold as “solving” emissions (with some minor debate about the emissions of manufacturing & supply chain) I guess electrification is phase 1, tire compound science is going to have to be phase 2?
- lillecarl 3y agoIt solves emitting CO2, who h hurts the planet.
- 1over137 3y agowepple, it’s called greenwashing. It’s left out deliberately. Think how many new cars can be sold while telling people they are saviours too!
- alkonaut 3y agoNo EVs are to reduce CO2 emissions. Not particle emissions. Particles are tires (and to some extent diesels).
- bigbillheck 3y ago> penalizing vehicle tonnage seems like a weird way of achieving it There's probably not that much variation in automobile density, so regulating those that are heavier is a good proxy for those that are larger. And even if the number of parking spots is the same, a row of little cars people can see over and between is better than a row of big SUVs that they can't.
- tmnvix 3y ago> a row of little cars people can see over and between is better than a row of big SUVs that they can't An underappreciated criticism of modern vehicles. Diminishes the visibility of and for cyclists as well. I'm 5'11 and as a pedestrian SUVs and 'trucks' block my visibility. Not to mention that along with the 'ride height' you get a front bumper that looks designed to just flatten you (you'd be forgiven for thinking this was intentional given the fetish for 'aggressive' styling). In addition you get the added bonus of much higher headlights. Why can't we at least keep these closer to the road like on real trucks, buses, and vans? Regulators really dropped the ball on this one. Is there actually any limit to how large a personal vehicle can get? Seems like a massive oversight due to a fixation on safety of occupants to the detriment of everyone else. From a personal point of view, I think people who buy these bloated vehicles should consider how they would feel if their neighbours all decided minibuses were an acceptable means of personal conveyance.
- maxglute 3y agoI just don't like having large vehicles around as a pedestrian and cyclist, anything that looks like I would get crushed under the car instead of over the hood, and don't mind them being specifically targetted/penalized.
- lkdfjlkdfjlg 3y ago> penalizing vehicle tonnage seems like a weird way of achieving it It's not a "weird way", it's a good heuristic.
- gruez 3y agoYou say "good heuristic", I say "half-assing it", especially when you consider a system to determine which cars are eligible for the charge would involve some sort of vehicle model database, and it would be equally easy to have the system work off of emissions rather than tonnage.
- alkonaut 3y agoParticle emissions from tires is probably not available data by model, but it can be pretty reliably inferred from the weight of the vehicle. If you want exhaust emissions you can just take the emission values from the database by model. Also weight is a reasonable proxy for size and hazard to pedestrians. EVs get unfairly penalized for that though (for being dense)
- tgv 3y ago> the market (for parking spaces) will take care of the rest Where does this Aynesque belief in the invisible hand come from?
- toomuchtodo 3y agoReligious economic beliefs (some flavor of libertarianism).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gruez 3y agoIt's "Aynesque belief" to recognize that removing the supply of parking spots will disincentivize people from driving into the city?
- k_ 3y agoWell it's France.. when there's no parking spot sidewalks and bikelanes become parking spots..
- creer 3y agoHow strange! Removing spots was supposed to solve people's problems. /s
- tgv 3y agoNot only is it weird to argue against a price increase, then reframing the problem to something else, and then propose the market to solve that (which means more parking spaces or higher prices). But there is no market in the first place. How is it going to solve anything?
- CalRobert 3y agoTo be fair the market was so good at turning parking in to better land uses the US spent eighty years making it illegal to build... Anything, really, without oceans of parking.
- stefan_ 3y agoPeople interested in and passionate about transportation in cities have long been warning that it doesn't solve anything if you just replace every combustion engine car with a (likely bigger) electric car, and incentives for them are wholly absurd in urban spaces.
- gambiting 3y agoThe thing is that there are multiple things that are problems and which can have independent(and even contradictory) solutions. Like for instance - cars cause noise and pollution in cities where people live and breathe. Solution: give large incentives for people to buy EVs instead, so you solve the noise and pollution problems(not entirely, but in a large part). But obviously that does nothing to the lack of parking spaces, people using/not using public transit, cycling etc etc etc. It's just one of the sides of a very complex cube.
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoIt’s to get rid of SUV driving arseholes - not really emissions. If you are driving an SUV in a city, there’s a decent probability you are an arsehole.