3 ms·
'There is no such thing as a real picture,' says Samsung exec
- Rygian 3y agoI'd love to see this in a court of law. "Your honor, we move to dismiss that picture as unacceptable evidence. It was taken by a Samsung device, and therefore cannot be construed to represent the actual scene as seen by the witness."
- grotorea 3y ago> Kyle Rittenhouse’s Lawyers Claim Zooming-In on an iPad Fundamentally Alters a Digital Image > The lawyer argued Apple uses AI in its pinch-to-zoom feature to create "what it thinks is there, not what necessarily is there.” https://gizmodo.com/kyle-rittenhouse-s-lawyers-claim-zooming-in-on-an-ipad-1848040149 https://gizmodo.com/kyle-rittenhouse-s-lawyers-claim-zooming...
- hulitu 3y ago> 'There is no such thing as a real picture,' says Samsung exec So all of his pictures are fakes ? /s
- 97-109-107 3y agoMaybe the best move forward for Samsung is to come out as followers of the surrealism art movement, they could use Magritte's famous 1929 painting to accommodate this press release - [The Treachery of Images - Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Treachery_of_Images https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Treachery_of_Images)
- JSR_FDED 3y agoThis argument bothers me. Of course digital cameras do a lot of processing on the captured sensor data. But to superimpose a canned picture of the moon on a photo of a lightbulb taken in a room is in a different league. That image was never on the sensor to start with. I can’t quite put my finger on why this is so disturbing. What group of people sat around and decided that this moon trick would be a great feature to add to the phone? What was the thought process? Not bothered by the deceptive nature of this they shipped it. That’s just so far from my values - what other things will they add and only admit to when found out?
- rpastuszak 3y agoThis reminds me of an alcoholic who told me “everything can poison you, even water!” I mean, yeah, drinking 15l of water will probably kill me but this doesn’t make me wanna LARP being a gerbil. It just diverts my attention from the real issue by removing all nuance. To quote my other friend (an engineer): “technically correct is the best kind of correct!”
- retrac 3y ago> Of course digital cameras do a lot of processing on the captured sensor data. They don't, though. Oh, the awful camera in a smartphone does, because the sensor is so tiny and there's barely any lens. But classically speaking with a "real" digital camera? No, there is no further processing. The values for each pixel are a measurement of the intensity of the light falling on the sensor. It is true that further processing might be necessary anyway. Some sensors do not correlate easily to RGB displays and their raw data may not be displayable on any device without deinterlacing, dithering, and transformations where one sensor pixel does not translate directly to one display pixel. But even doing that sort of conversion automatically is controversial, which is why most dedicated digital cameras provide access to the raw sensor data.
- foldr 3y ago>there's barely any lens Smartphone lenses are very sophisticated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30557578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30557578 "Phones do an enormous amount of image processing today of course, but as far as I can tell, not much of that is actual optical correction because the lens, while tiny, is already optically pretty sharp and good thanks to the highly exotic design."
- dagmx 3y agoYou’re over simplifying. All sensors will do some amount of signal processing before the photosite readouts are written to memory. Lots of people assume RAW means just that, but raw usually just means pre-debayering. There may still be some amount of noise reduction applied prior to this step. This was a huge deal for Sony sensors and astrophotography for a hot minute.
- eviks 3y agoSure there isn't, but that's a silly excuse to conflate some minor distortions from sensor imperfections etc to your moon-sized fails
- mediumsmart 3y agoYou can always take real pictures by carrying a camera on your back pointing backwards at an angle taking pictures in intervals as long as you don’t look at them later.
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y agoThere is something with old photos from the early 1900's that capture light and detail in a way i would describe as a real picture, except for the missing color of course
- nitwit005 3y agoIt'd be fine if they had been upfront about it, and you had a way to turn it off. People showed you can easily make it produce bad results. Presumably, we'll start to see AI hallucinations in camera photography more often if they continue down this route.
- rubatuga 3y agoThis is a feature that totally removes any sense of professional work, imagine trying to use pictures captured by a Samsung with a AI generated moon in it for a legal scenario.
- wildrhythms 3y agoI think about that Reddit thread where a user's Samsung's night vision feature 'helpfully' added a ghost man standing in their kitchen. I will never buy a Samsung phone. https://old.reddit.com/r/Ghosts/comments/11jvwy4/after_years_of_hearing_noises_from_the_kitchen_i/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Ghosts/comments/11jvwy4/after_years...
- noisem4ker 3y agoA quick search reveals I'm not the only one suspecting it's made up (i.e. a hoax). https://www.reddit.com/r/Ghosts/comments/11lvyxd/in_regards_to_the_pantry_keanu_ghost_did_anyone/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Ghosts/comments/11lvyxd/in_regards_...