3 ms·
> If someone is creating millions of dollars worth of goods or services what moral justification is there for it to be confiscated, particularly at your arbitra
by naasking 3y ago
> If someone is creating millions of dollars worth of goods or services what moral justification is there for it to be confiscated, particularly at your arbitrary level?
I think there are good "system stability" arguments to set limits. Roughly, states are dynamic multivariate systems whose objective function should ideally track citizen well being and state security, and taxes are one of the feedback loops that prevent individual actors from dominating or otherwise destabilizing the system.
The mistake is thinking that the fictions we created to establish this system are fundamental moral imperatives in and of themselves.