4 ms·
New Super Secret Surveillance Court Covering Old Super Secret Surveillance Court
- instagib 3y agoThere’s always another secrecy group that oversees the other and then eventually is overseen by the joint chiefs, president, or some other un-named official.
- strangattractor 3y agoThis is why we need a Super Secret Journalism Organization to monitor and report on the other Super Secret groups.
- electric_mayhem 3y agoEd and Chelsea and Juilan probably have some thoughts on how that works out.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ciabattabread 3y agoThis sounds like an executive tribunal. What is the appeals process, and which real federal court does it end up in?
- zerocrates 3y agoI imagine that since this is an executive-branch "court," the theoretical recourse would be something like the Administrative Procedure Act's general provision for challenging "agency action." Or otherwise, directly filing suit as before. Regardless of the theoretical vehicle, you'd have the same problems in the way of success as prior attempts in the courts have had, where you can't get the information needed to have your claim survive in the first place.
- typeofhuman 3y agoLet's hope the Chevron doctrine gets overturned. It's being debated now before SCOTUS.
- zerocrates 3y agoI'd say Chevron deference is almost certainly dead this term, but I wouldn't expect it to make much if any difference to things like this "national security" stuff. Here especially, this court springs from an executive order so Chevron probably doesn't even apply to it (maybe in a more narrow sense like, is there authority to even have the court in the first place). Chevron's an interesting one... personally I'm for retaining it, but it's another of these cases where its outsized importance is just a symptom of the broken state of the government. Chevron deference only applies where Congress has delegated power and the statute is vague, so Congress has a simple and obvious route to overriding or correcting any undesired actions by the agencies that rely on Chevron to be upheld. But with substantive lawmaking so seemingly impossible now for such a long time, the executive and the courts have gained more and more practical power. Keeping or killing Chevron is all about just shifting the balance of power between the judicial and the executive, with the legislature standing idly by. Part of the problem is that Congress is happy to allow this to happen, to reduce their workload and their accountability.
- joedevon 3y agoYou have been on double secret probation
- marginallen 3y ago[dead]
- helpfulContrib 3y ago[dead]
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoCan we just use the source article instead of this tech..dirt: https://www.politico.com/news/2024/01/17/inside-bidens-secret-surveillance-court-00136175 https://www.politico.com/news/2024/01/17/inside-bidens-secre...
- GoodUser77 3y agoAs usually
- vjulian 3y agoIt irritates to no end when US presidents are not only falsely attributed to government actions but falsely portrayed, even thinly, as masterminding those related plans. Over the course of news cycles it paints the picture of a superman not unlike the absurd hyperbole in descriptions of North Korea’s Dear Leader. In the US, I am not sure whether it can be attributed to laziness or to the calculus of the news establishment, but regardless it is poor journalism.
- oooyay 3y agoIt's an election year. Party constituents eat polarizing rhetoric and outlandish takes like it's a breakfast bar. Journalists are happy to stock that bar. fwiw, it wasn't Biden that created the court it was Merrick Garland: https://www.justice.gov/opcl/redress-data-protection-review-court https://www.justice.gov/opcl/redress-data-protection-review-... Also, not exactly a secret given that it had a PR release and the judges are known. Maybe the secret part is getting in front of them.
- smcin 3y agoThe court's functioning is absolutely still a secret to its plaintiffs [EU residents]; its location is a secret, the DOJ refuses to say if it has taken a case yet, or when it will. [That implies it has not published any rulings, or maybe it will never publish rulings]. Its decisions will also be kept a secret, from both the EU residents petitioning the court and the federal agencies tasked with following the law. Plaintiffs [EU-residents] are not allowed to appear in person [not even remotely by Zoom, it sounds like?] and are represented by a special advocate, appointed by the U.S. Attorney General. I can't see US citizens being told to just trust a secret European court whose deliberations aren't known, yet affects their lives, visas, travels, finances etc. "Maybe the secret part is getting in front of them." No, they already stated that the EU plaintiffs don't have the right to appear before the court. So they don't get in front of them. On the "Animal House" taxonomy of double-secret, it's up there.
- oooyay 3y agoI think your points are fair and I largely agree with you, but I'd probably use the word "opaque" rather than secretive. Sometimes opaque systems do serve a purpose, other times they're an excuse to undermine rights and liberties. This court deals entirely in classified information (from its mandate) and only produces classified rulings. I linked both of the sources (.gov websites) in another comment. Whether or not that's good enough to remain opaque I don't know. I do know that I'm not a fan of any surveillance state and I'm not confident in the ability of intergovernment watchdogs to spot violations, even gross ones.
- claytongulick 3y agoQuis custodiet ipsos custodes? [1] Who watches the watchmen? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%...
- flipbrad 3y agoThe fact that Eric Holder is a judge on this new court - while also working at Covington & Burling [1], a law firm actively involved in helping large companies defend these very same transatlantic data flows [2] - tells you all you need to know about the new court. Ditto his fellow judge, Rajesh De, who used to be the NSA's top judge. [1] https://www.cov.com/en/professionals/h/eric-holder https://www.cov.com/en/professionals/h/eric-holder [2] https://www.cov.com/en/news-and-insights/news/2019/07/covington-represents-bsa-in-landmark-data-transfer-case https://www.cov.com/en/news-and-insights/news/2019/07/coving...
- AustinDev 3y agoSecret courts shouldn't even be a concept in a 'democracy'.
- jackfoxy 3y agoNor should it be in our republic. There is no national security override to our rights in the Constitution.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoSCOTUS has already decided that these courts and the things they "permit" do not violate your rights. So there's that.
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoJust FYI, the selector of the FISA Court Justices is the Chief Justice of SCOTUS. The SCOTUS Chief Justice is selected by the President [with Senate confirmation].
- qeternity 3y agoAnd the President is elected by the people…
- doublerabbit 3y agoCan we just get to the point and admit the world, all countries are corrupt and that evil is the entity that's in control? You can no longer trust anything or anyone. If you speak out your shot, reprimanded or gagged. Regardless to who owns who's data it will always be misused, abused or used for something. And as data is now a commodity that can be sold to anyone and the sci-fi dystopian future is already one. There is no freedom nor freedom to speech, with the ability that we can reach space on a commercial level with satellites, fear for the worse. The internet is a failure. It brings usefulness but sure isn't used for it; not anymore at least. Prove me wrong, but with the masses lapping up social media, you'll going to have a hard time proving it. My two cents.
- sirspacey 3y agoOk let’s say we agree with you. Now what?
- doublerabbit 3y agoFrom a political side of things, not much. So lets ignore that but move forward from an internet point of view. Take the concept that the data you own is when you own the devices where the data is held. A good example is cloud vs colocation. If your leasing services from a cloud provider, the data is not yours. You don't own the hardware, you don't own the storage. While you may store user data it's still not yours. You just have it in your possession; you own nothing within the Cloud. This is why I love co-location, heavily influenced by, keeps my sanity; as it allows me to keep control. So lets take simple data view: a web servers access.log. If you were to access my website, the data that is recorded is Web Browser, IP, and User Agent. It's not provisional, nor owned by another third-party company. The third-party service (evil: amazon, google or whoever) can demand you to hand over the data regardless or shut off your service. No one can request that from me unless you file a proper request which I can than fight. As I own the hardware, I own the hard-drives, I own the switches that are connected to my server and you could say that the data is in transit is not mine. True, it is only mine once it's processed and stored upon my server but that enables me to do what I wish, ethically, or non. In that scenario, your data is owned by two parties - Me and your ISP. So how do you break free from this? Encryption? Still a commodity, it may be secured by X cipher, but it's still data. Still a commodity. "Hey, got any encrypted data for sale?" .. sure you may never be able to decrypt but you've got the data which could potentially lead to a password or just pointless meta. Who knows, I still bought and now own a copy of your data. Mesh networking is the of the few ways forward. And that, one example I mean is connecting to your neighbours network. We can all pick up WiFi networks of our neighbours. Now imagine where if you could connect to your neighbours, neigbours-neighbours network free and that every single neighbour WiFi network hosted a service that you could host at home? From a laptop, to a super-computer in your jacuzzi -- Not only is data than yours, it's also theirs, isn't owned by your ISP's, evil entity I would call. However, there is a lot more to it than what I have posted but I hope it paints the viewpoint that I see. A theory at least. Overall, it's ironic really. We all pay for the same ISP, mass use the same router they provide and then we all segment them off so "no one else" can use it. Yet if everyone enabled each other network with QoS you could have an whole new internet hosting services owned only by yourself without ISP control. If you bought a WiFi router that's not leased by your ISP; your free. All because you own the hardware. WiFi is now so potent you wouldn't even need a ISP. Why do you think ISP's make it difficult host services at home?
- gjsman-1000 3y agoI think it should be a basic human right that any citizen of a country should be permitted to have a complete list of courts, their locations, their judges, and their claims to authority.
- declan_roberts 3y ago[flagged]
- graycat 3y agoApparently more generally, Virginia, here is some of reality: (1) Holes. We have a Constitution, laws, regulations, etc., but they do not cover every possible situation and, instead, there are holes. (2) New. In particular, things that are new in tech, science, math (even math, e.g., RSA encryption), etc. can create "situations" not covered by (1). That is, in principle the "holes" were already there and not being exploited or causing problems, but then something "new" comes along and, using "holes," creates new situations and new problems. (3) F'get about it. Typically a "new problem" has comparatively small effect with only a few people concerned about the effects. Then, usually the attitude is f'get about it. E.g., the "situation" may not have common sense, justice, equity, etc. (4) Squeaks and Grease. Yup, "The wheel that squeaks gets the grease." Or, when in some sense the problem is big enough, then it gets attention -- deals, lawsuits, Congress, the Executive Branch, elections, ..., the Constitution. (5) Point. Virginia, here is the point: The "attention" in (4) can take big time, money, and effort, e.g., for time, years, maybe decades. In particular, Virginia, if reality is like a boat, even if it is not leaking now, actually, unfortunately it is NOT fully water-tight and in some new weather, situations, can LEAK. What to do? Try to avoid situations where need to depend on justice, good common sense, no holes, no "leaks", lawyers, laws, Congress, elections (e.g., politics), the Constitution, etc.
- nl 3y ago> in July, European officials declared it adequate to the task, reopening a smoother transatlantic data trade. (From the Politico article) Isn't this the real problem? It's hard to understand why they approved this.
- jimbob45 3y agoSo the president gets to appoint eight judges, handpicked, to decide what is and isn’t an invasion of privacy? Couldn’t he choose judges that would let him spy on his political enemies without blowback? I’m genuinely asking. The Politico article is really fuzzy about the appointments. I’m wondering if they even know the process themselves.