4 ms·
Yes, but we have to consider what is politically feasible or plausible. The US is not going to switch to proportional representation at any point in the near t
by crazygringo 3y ago
Yes, but we have to consider what is politically feasible or plausible.
The US is not going to switch to proportional representation at any point in the near to medium future. It's just not going to happen. There's zero public awareness or desire -- right now we're having a hard enough time just making the much smaller incremental improvement of ranked voting.
On the other hand, there's no strong tradition of any kind behind drawing districts. If someone really can come up with a fair, objective way of doing it, it's far easier to see it getting adopted. Gradually at first (state by state), and then possibly nationally. Still difficult, but within the realm of possibility (unlike PR).
- peacefulhat 3y agoThey're not switching to a new apportionment formula that doesn't politically benefit the party in power either
- crazygringo 3y agoThat's why I said gradually and state-by-state. Honestly I think a main way it could be adopted is imposition by the courts -- we've seen increasing cases of "stalemates" where states can't seem to produce maps acceptable to the courts at all. So courts do have the ability to say, "if you can't produce a satisfactory map, we will, and this is it." I'm not saying it's easy or quick, I'm just saying it's in the realm of the possible, unlike PR.
- evanb 3y agoSome states used to have at-large seats in addition to districts. But the court basically killed that in the 60s. There might be a clever legislative solution that would still be in the bounds of the 'one person, one vote' requirements the court set. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At-large#U.S._House_of_Representatives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At-large#U.S._House_of_Represe...