3 ms·
On the one hand -- I love this spirit, of trying to adapt the "I cut you choose" technique to something that might work for gerrymandering. We need as many idea
by crazygringo 3y ago
On the one hand -- I love this spirit, of trying to adapt the "I cut you choose" technique to something that might work for gerrymandering. We need as many ideas as we can get!
On the other -- unfortunately I don't see how it would actually help, because the first party which defines the half-districts is generally going to "win".
If party 1 is the Republican party which wants to maximize rural votes, they just split up every city like a pie, with each slice extending far into the countryside, halfway to the next city. Then it doesn't matter which slices party 2 (Democrats) combine, because they're always stuck with rural votes outweighing city votes.
While if party 1 is the Democratic party which wants to concentrate city votes, they do the opposite and surround the city with two halves of a ring that is half-urban half-rural, so the city can't be diluted. Party 2 (Republicans) can combine rural areas only with the ring, while the inside remains totally protected.
So one strategy is skinny pointed daggers to invade the cities, the other is about skinny ring shields to protect the cities. By controlling the initial shapes, you control nearly everything.
(Of course with real geography it becomes more complex, but the general principle of districts shaped as skinny daggers or shields is still going to be the primary strategy here -- you're not going to win all the districts, but it'll get you the extra 10% or 15% you need.)