4 ms·
They probably realize it is hopeless to try to lock motivated kids out of their devices. And it might be a nostalgic memory for them, maybe they aren’t too moti
by bee_rider 3y ago
They probably realize it is hopeless to try to lock motivated kids out of their devices. And it might be a nostalgic memory for them, maybe they aren’t too motivated to implement this stuff. Most of us had full control of our devices growing up, right?
- hunter2_ 3y agoNostalgia time. > Most of us had full control of our devices growing up, right? Devices, yes. Internet connection: not at first. With the AOL app (not a separate appliance or OS feature) responsible for establishing the dialup connection, it only bridged internet access to the OS when the current AOL user had no parental controls. As a 10-14 year old whose AOL account was set to "young teen" (DNS allow list) and then "mature teen" (DNS deny list), I was free to use non-AOL apps but they had no internet access. Solution: download a keylogger* and subsequently use a parent's AOL account for the next few years until they removed controls from mine, giving full Internet access to the whole computer, without being found out. *The free version had a "pay for this" nag popup every few minutes. I opened the exe in a hex editor, typed over that nag string, and managed to corrupt it just enough that it would crash (with a totally generic fatal error) instead of nag. Launched it right before finding mom or dad to help me do some safe but blocked activity, which they were always happy to do, with increased supervision.
- oldandboring 3y agoLocking kids out of a device is what Family Link excels at. You go in, you select the kid, you select the device, you click Lock. Here are things you cannot do: - Create a global screen time limit across all devices regardless of how that time is used. - Create a PIN for Google TV that prevents kids from switching to an adult account in order to access more apps. Right now it's the other way around, you can set a PIN that prevents a kid from accessing their own account (again, because supervision!) but that kid can easily switch over to the adult account if they want. - Require that when an idle Google TV exit to the 'user selection' screen after a timeout. Right now a kid can just walk up to the TV and start using my profile and apps because I was the last one to use it. As for nostalgia, I think that's overthinking it.
- monkpit 3y agoNo, parental controls don’t drive revenue so they get abandoned. No manager type is getting promoted for creating an amazing parental control product.
- int_19h 3y agoI don't see why they wouldn't, with the right marketing. Surely there's a large market of parents desiring locked-down devices for their children? It shouldn't be a hard sale.
- astrange 3y agoParental controls and enterprise management/MDM are the same product. That's important to the kind of people who'll buy hundreds of your devices. (Although they do have different fine grained features, like time limits and web site approval specifically aren't enterprise things.)
- paulddraper 3y ago> Most of us had full control of our devices growing up, right? Yes, but the devices could do a lot less. Like, I had full control over my bike too. But not an automobile.
- klyrs 3y ago> Most of us had full control of our devices growing up, right? I dunno about you but we had one computer, one TV, and one phone line. If by "full control" you mean "constant negotiations" then yeah we had that. By the time I was able to drive and earn enough coin to build my own computer, I was practically an adult.
- throw10920 3y ago> it is hopeless to try to lock motivated kids out of their devices What? Apple's successfully made it very hard for adults to get into their own devices. This claim is absurd.