3 ms·
All things Eno raise technical questions that rabbit hole into labyrinths, this documentary about Eno raises another: “Eno,” the portrait of Brian Eno that
by defrost 3y ago
All things Eno raise technical questions that rabbit hole into labyrinths, this documentary about Eno raises another:
“Eno,” the portrait of Brian Eno that opened the Sundance Film Festival today, is a documentary that mirrors the spirit of Eno’s music in its very form.
The director, Gary Hustwit (“Helvetica”), created it with generative software that allows the film to play in a different version every time you see it.
Sections of it will land in a different order, and some won’t appear at all (replaced by others); the movie is reshuffled each time with an element of the random.
How random? Well, it’s not as if the generative AI determines the order of everything.
How does the director acheive a bespoke per iteration viewing in a dedicated theatre (there are a number of means).
Can this be reliably transferred to some "take home" experience that reliably captures the essence of what the director has done?
Is this just a markov chain of "shuffle" operations with transitions, can this be emulated with a .MKV file full of tracks and a modified player that can read embedded "next track" probabilities?
No Pussyfooting.
- danwills 3y agoIt definitely sounds like hype not reproducibility! And although I'm a giant fan of Eno I really think the current cutting-edge is in the demoscene in terms of generative art..
- defrost 3y agoI'd have to see it to make any coherent comment .. but there is that word "Documentary". Demoscene generative art is not often mistaken or confused with documentary. Cutting edge is always interesting, this though is (or should be) a homage to what was once cutting edge .. literal tape loops and razors and the evolution forward. I'm imagining there's a lot of audio and or text and or video that relates to Eno's life (biography) and artistic output (some structured, some generative). To describe this experience as a generative documentary would imply cutting together pre existing "truthful" material along with some generated for the first time material with a healthy dash of reordering fragments while (ideally) preserving some notion of chronological tagging ( material from later in his life can appear first but ideally (IMHO) this is made apparent to the viewer ). Speculation aside I'm in the dark, of course, I can't dash off to the Sundance Festival to actually experience whatever this creation is .. several times in fact if I'm to get a sense of what is meant by "never the same experience twice".
- arketyp 3y agoOne can expect minimal generative content for reasons already mentioned in the article. It wouldn't be too surprising if in practice they only have the one reel playing at these festivals. I don't think experiencing the generative or the stochastic in a concrete comparative sense is necessarily the point. It's there to keep you cognizant of and become immersed in a creative process in line with Eno's philosophy. Kind of gimmicky, but passable as a conceptual art move.
- sleepybrett 3y agoit isn't. There are tons of artists that have been, for many years, working outside of the demoscene producing breathtaking work. Demoscene is more focused on realitime optimization.
- dfxm12 3y agoI would guess there's some web service where the projector (or some other person) clicks a button to generate a new version and outputs it into a format that is friendly to any current digital projector. I would be surprised if any special projection hardware or software is needed at the theater.
- sleepybrett 3y agodvd, as i recall, was very programmable and supported branching and random selection i suspect blu ray is the same. Unknown what digital projector systems contain.
- and0 3y agoClue (1985) had several different endings sent to different theaters, which as a comedy was a pretty funny and novel idea. The VHS release contained all of them at the end with title cards to explain why. If this doc is screening in theaters I'd imagining different reels/files are sent to different theaters, or maybe more than one so they can rotate them. As others have said DVDs are more than capable of this. A VLC plugin could work, and Netflix has some type of tech for their choose-your-own-adventure episode of Black Mirror for streaming.
- pests 3y agoThey used that for a lot more than just Bandersnatch.