I regularly use the git command line, and "git show (pasted SHA)" in my second terminal doesn't really feel like the road block to understanding the grandparent

I regularly use the git command line, and "git show (pasted SHA)" in my second terminal doesn't really feel like the road block to understanding the grandparent seems to make it out to be. It takes me many orders of magnitude more time understanding what is output rather than searching for it, and like you mentioned there are any number of UIs (third party, editor integration, or even shipped with git like gitk) that wire everything up into a nice UI. And I also disagree with the GP's complaint that "Most people only read the shortlog" being any kind of disadvantage. The commit message isn't for everyone, it's for the one time someone needs to figure out exactly what it did and why that commit was made, and why a change in X causes a behavior change in Y, and can save hours of work. It's like code comments, 99 times out of 100 you don't need them as you're just interacting with a documented API, but that 1 other time they are a godsend.