4 ms·
I wish more people knew/appreciated the incrementalism of progress. A huge amount of constant "boring" percent-point improvement work or price-shifts are requi
by Terr_ 3y ago
I wish more people knew/appreciated the incrementalism of progress.
A huge amount of constant "boring" percent-point improvement work or price-shifts are required to unlock the interesting changes, and often the people and companies associated with those new discoveries and ways of doing things are not really the first at all, but rather the lucky or the ruthless.
- sschueller 3y agoPrime example is OpenAI. General public thinks they have open some sort of Pandora's box when it has been a long iterative process of which a lot was done by others.
- s_dev 3y agoOpenAI made the first AI chat bot product that didn't suck. There is a critical mass of innovation and Open AI got their 9kg of Uranium-235 together first as reflected in the market. The real question isn't why did OpenAI get there first but why Google didn't, they had every advantage.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago> OpenAI made the first AI chat bot product that didn't suck. And let people try it for free. Non-techies were using it and the news was reporting on it. They nailed their launch.
- wongarsu 3y agoAfter horrible launches for GPT2, GPT3 and GPT3.5 where most hype and momentum was smothered by a long waitlist. ChatGPT was a 180 degree reversal from their usual release process and an instant hit.
- booleandilemma 3y agoI think this is the thing people like the guy linking to Google's paper on arxiv.org don't get. OpenAI actually delivered something.
- andruby 3y agoMy armchair answer to that question is that Google isn’t a product company. They might have had similar or better technical AI capabilities, but they aren’t great at productizing it.
- sixothree 3y agoThe one thing that most defines Google products is that each one must collect data from the user in a way that is unique to their other products. If it doesn’t do that it doesn’t get to exist.
- s_dev 3y ago>Google isn’t a product company. I disagree. Google does have great products, Google Maps, Search, GMail etc.
- wongarsu 3y agoSurvivorship bias. Any company that launches as many products as Google has to have a couple good ones by pure chance. And all products you mentioned were created two decades ago, when Google was a very different company.
- osigurdson 3y agoGoogle products by launch date: Search: 1998 Gmail: 2004 Maps: 2005
- moritonal 3y agoIt has free Products. I would suggest that all three would struggle to act as individual paid products if they didn't cross-support each other.
- fragmede 3y agoBecause keeping the user on Google, so they don't need to visit the actual page, means that people won't make web pages anymore. that was a real concern.
- s_dev 3y agoSteve Jobs always said in Apple if we don't cannibalize our own products someone else will eat them for us. So the answer is Google isn't willing to take risks like it used to.
- wongarsu 3y ago> Google isn't willing to take risks like it used to Has Google ever taken a risk that endangered their ad business?
- c0n5pir4cy 3y agoHonestly it wasn't even having the first capable chat LLM. OpenAI released the first LLM that has interesting characteristics, based on an architecture they created to be good at this task (Generative Pre-trained Tranformers) and then iterated on improving those characteristics - It took them a while before they had a model capable of following instructions well. There was lots of interest in OpenAI when they released GPT-1 and much more when they released GPT-2. All the while this was going on Google slept - I think the reasons for this are varied and many, stretching into company culture, structure, processes etc. This was after researchers at Google created the Transformer architecture in the first place. Google seemed to panic suddenly when ChatGPT was released. I think this is when the people who could actually make change realised that ChatGPT could be a threat to Google in a number of ways - including for search market share.
- benob 3y agoGoogle had it in 2015 [1] [1] https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.05869 https://arxiv.org/abs/1506.05869
- dataviz1000 3y agoThere is a saying. How to make a lot of money? Be first, best, or cheat.
- noud 3y agoI think it's "only" a quote from a movie called Margin Call [1]. But my grandma could have said it. ;) [1] - https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1615147/quotes/?item=qt1531207&ref_=ext_shr_lnk https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1615147/quotes/?item=qt1531207&...
- maxbond 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ag14Ao_xO4c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ag14Ao_xO4c It's the first 30s of this clip, for the curious. (Movie is a bit dry but pretty good.)
- iamflimflam1 3y agoA lot of companies make money by being second or even third mover. There's a lot of benefit to having someone else create the market and then swoop in with a marginally better product (or even just better marketing).
- rob74 3y agoWell, in this case, stereoscopic photography had been a thing for a long time (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereoscopy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stereoscopy), and TVs were becoming widespread, so having the idea of combining the two is not some kind of stroke of genius. So I would give more credit to those who work on the incremental improvements that make the thing actually possible. Same as I would give more credit to the Wright brothers (and the other aviation pioneers) than to e.g. Leonardo da Vinci...
- vidarh 3y agoI worked on a tablet computer ca. '99. We were not first, nor did we have any illusions we were. There were novel parts about our business plan, but a tablet was "obvious". But it's an illustration of what you describe: When the iPhone and later iPad were launched, a lot of people thought they were new. Even though there had been a whole fad of touch devices in phone and tablet form that had come and gone before the iPhone came. A lot of us dismissed them at first because we'd seen that fad come and go, without realising that the genius of Apple with respect to those devices was not in the technical innovation, but in recognising when enough percent-point improvements had been made to unlock something that'd actually appeal to the general public. "Our" tablet was tethered to a custom DECT base station (wifi wasn't widespread yet), had about 2 hours of battery. The resistive touch was awful, the screen resolution was small, and I had to cram Linux and the GUI, with space left over for a port of Opera, in to 16MB of flash and 16MB RAM in the original prototype... In retrospect it had no chance in hell. But to a geek like me it was amazingly cool. Other tablets and pda's with or without network and phone of that era were either attempts at slimming down laptops (e.g. I had a laptop with a touch screen on a swivel back then) that were still way too big, or they were devices like ours, with all sorts of limitations that geeks were fine with, and regular people weren't. So when these devices disappeared one after the other, many of us dismissed the concept as a whole as tried and failed, rather than realise that the problem was one of enough percent-point improvements and not the concept. And for all of the many issues I have with Apple, while they were not first, they still deserve plenty of credit for simply being smart enough to recognise when the time was right for this category of devices. Because a whole lot of companies got that timing extremely wrong.
- fragmede 3y agoI remember the UMPC! That was a whole category of portable computers that didn't stand the test of time. Apple got a lot of things right, but I think it was less about timing and more about being usable, and affordable by the masses. Blackberry was great but it cost too much and didn't have a big enough battery.
- vidarh 3y agoBeing usable was largely about timing, though. None of the choices that compromised our device - or those of most of our competitors - were choices we made because we thought they were right, or best, but because we were forced to by timing and what was available at what cost, and failed to realize that the result was too compromised to stand a chance. Put another way: Had Apple launched an iPad in 2000, it would've had exactly the same hardware usability issues. There were no good, cheap enough touch screens, or displays, or cheap enough RAM, or cheap enough flash, to deliver what they did later at that time at any price, much less affordable enough. Timing it when the available components were good enough and cheap enough was how they got it usable and affordable. Trying too early and drawing the wrong conclusions was also why a lot of their competitors had moved onto a very different track in terms of design. If you e.g. look at Palm devices that started to get network connectivity etc., from ~2000, you'll see the grid of (user-installable) apps w/touch and no keyboard, and Blackberry-like devices w/keyboard "won" for a while because people took users rejection of crappy, limited resistive touch as a rejection of touch. (I walked around with a Palm device for several years from '98 or so, and couldn't understand why "normal people" rejected them - it felt like scifi) [EDIT: UMPC was from 2006; and not the type of devices I'm talking about - they're a couple of generations of hardware later; the UMPC if anything were part of that bastardization of the earlier touch focused devices as manufacturers declared the "cleaner" devices dead and buried in the market place without understanding why]