3 ms·
Surely there are safer places, such as those that aren’t hours away from medical care…
by saagarjha 3y ago
Surely there are safer places, such as those that aren’t hours away from medical care…
- justworkout 3y agoYou're correct. The other poster is thinking being one of the safest forms of transportation in terms of disastrous accidents == safest state of existence, which is a big misunderstanding.
- arcticbull 3y agoIt's a good thought exercise, but I suspect that's not the case. The plane will land and deposit you somewhere with nearby medical care, and except over the pacific or poles, you're not too far from an airport. There's also staff on hand that have more experience caring for most basic issues that might arise than the people around you ordinarily. There's also very good odds that a doctor is onboard, and of course, defibrillators will be onboard and at least in the US staff are trained to use them. Further the places you'd be that aren't a plane have plenty of their own safety risks, that people aren't checking for constantly as a matter of course. Whereas on a plane, there's very little that can hurt you, and your job is to, well, remain seated. A fairly safe activity, in moderation. Combined with the fact your risk of dying due to a fatal accident is about 500 in 9.4 billion, I stand by my rough assessment.
- worthless-trash 3y agoDoes your calculations account for the base-risk value of what happens to people that die on planes, not necessarily death by planes. Plane flight is an additional risk, it doesn't mitigate existing risks in place.
- arcticbull 3y agoI’ll be the first to admit it wasn’t properly calculated. I do think there’s some benefit to personal safety due to the selection bias and process for the people around you.
- d1sxeyes 3y agoProbably true, but you also have to account for the mitigation of 'opportunity risks', rather than just the inherent risk of being (there's probably a proper name for this, but I don't know what it is). For example, if you're on a plane, you're not scuba diving, base jumping, driving a car, etc.