3 ms·
So, of the dozens of qbs drafted every year, 4 or 5 surprises popped up in a decade and that makes QB selection stochastic?
by mattmaroon 18y ago
So, of the dozens of qbs drafted every year, 4 or 5 surprises popped up in a decade and that makes QB selection stochastic?
- robg 18y agoNo, the fact that by the time they're eligible for the draft, and of the 10-15 taken every year, there's usually little to differentiate the top picks from the worst. What separates them is anyone's guess. That's Gladwell's point.
- mattmaroon 18y agoBut if you look at the top picks and the bottom picks, you find almost none of the bottom picks starting in the nfl (you named a few who did it in the last decade) and a ton of the top picks who are, or are at least second strings to superstars. I would say that means that what separates them is far from anyone's guess. There's certainly some variance there (see Tim Couch) but it's not unpredictable.
- robg 18y agoThe complicating factor, of course, is all those former first rounders but second stringers, have had significant money invested in them. It's a lot easier to cut the lower picked players but not necessarily because of their "talent". Matt Cassell = perfect example. Does he even get a chance on any other team? Ever?
- mattmaroon 18y agoA lot of great QBs got their starts when the superstar they were behind got injured. Steve Young for instance.