2 ms·
> Most peoples pictures are not a statement of record - we just want to remember the good times with loved ones Maybe so, but personally if I'm taking a pictur
by JohnFen 3y ago
> Most peoples pictures are not a statement of record - we just want to remember the good times with loved ones
Maybe so, but personally if I'm taking a picture, I want that picture to be of real things. I don't want it to be altered or to have artificial things added. That just adds an additional layer of separation between my and reality.
If I want a picture to be artificially enhanced, I'd be using photoshop or similar.
But I understand that's just me. One of the things I worry about with how generative AI seems to be going is that it's being used for things that further blur what is real from what is not, and we already have far too much of that as it is.
- Xeyz0r 3y agoThat's true. I remember when I switched from the iPhone 6s to the iPhone 13 and tried taking a selfie in low light. I was so dissatisfied because the image became brighter than it appeared on the camera preview during shooting. Good shots with minimal phone editing now only happen in good lighting. But if a photo is taken in low light, the face gets heavily smoothed to remove noise in the photo, but in my opinion, it only makes everything look worse.
- whakim 3y agoBut what is a "real thing"? I would argue that photography is a medium for understanding a deeper underlying reality - just like our own brains and sense-perceptions are, but with different mechanics. The angle with which you take a photo, or the optics which the camera uses, or the post-processing that camera software applies are just as much a mechanism for interpreting the "thing itself" as the vagaries of our own sense-perceptions when we "see" something. In addition, these multiple representations (our senses and the images we create) interact - for example, we sometimes think a photo is "bad" because it doesn't match the representation in our brain, and sometimes we find that "hyperreal" photos (to use Baudrillard's term) override our perceptions. So I think it's silly to worry that Generative AI might make photos less representative of "objective" reality. Perhaps it's even a good thing if more folks accept the inherent subjectivity of any media.