3 ms·
That is a reasonable argument about Chrome! That's not hokum; even some people who have worked on and are invested in the Firefox security and isolation model w
by tptacek 3y ago
That is a reasonable argument about Chrome! That's not hokum; even some people who have worked on and are invested in the Firefox security and isolation model will concede that Chrome has historically had a material edge there, and it has been reflected in browser vulnerability prices (I don't want to cite the obvious chart here because I think the audience for that thing is message boards and not people working in the field, but it's directionally correct).
There's also the benefit of having one set of controls with respect to profiles and extensions.
- 616c 3y agoYou've been known for your hot takes past and present, but this one threw me for a curve. Is there empirical data on this? I think many in the security industry believe this. I ironically use FF if we can accept personal beliefs since I believe people attack the Chrome sandbox as a badge of honor and I can use containers to isolate state to different personas. That said also anecdata bullshit take on my part.
- tptacek 3y ago(1) I think public exploit price lists are bullshit, and mostly about marketing, but directionally they consistently put Chrome >2x of Firefox. You can choose not to take that seriously. (2) The fact that people attack Chrome as a badge of honor is a reason to use it, not to avoid it. It's why exploits for Firefox would be cheaper. (3) I don't think my take is spicy at all? I haven't refreshed it in a few years, but when last I did, I don't think I talked to anybody on either side of browser security who felt that Firefox outclassed Chrome (I got a long, valuable Slack thread from a FF security person that I wish I'd saved that built a claim that FF was approaching parity with Chrome architecturally). I have spicy takes, to be sure, but I think I'm giving you a pretty mainstream take from software security land. (4) Even if you believed Firefox and Chrome (or Chrome and Safari) were at parity, it makes a great deal of sense to standardize browsers, for the reasons I gave previously. The right way to think of your browser "fleet" is as multiple single points of failure; diversity isn't helping you at all. This is one of those "put all your eggs in one basket and guard it" situations. I don't have any particular personal reason to love Chrome. I'm a Mac person, so I guess the best outcome for me would be for Safari to be perceived as the best browser. Certainly my batteries would last longer! Every couple of years I talk to people about what the landscape looks like; if I ever get different answers, I'll be sure to update my take.
- 616c 3y agoPoint made, I meant this take threw me for a curve (not that it this too was spicy), re your point 3. I didn't make that clear. I just know your other takes so I was being cute about it. I don't know you that well so 1-4 are valid, and I am famously not a Mac user in my personal life. I know I am full of anecdata and that shit doesn't matter, but I appreciate the detailed follow up to confirm: 616c, your choices are great but not so empirical, here is what I think.