3 ms·
It seems like you cant separate the negotiation aspect from this specific case and the ruling of this specific judge. I have said to put this aside and focus on
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
It seems like you cant separate the negotiation aspect from this specific case and the ruling of this specific judge. I have said to put this aside and focus on the other question multiple times. Now you negate everything you argued with this statement making your position contingent on the other facts of the case:
>Now, billions is a lot of compensation for 1 year, but if elmu wants more compensation than that, he has to honestly put together a compensation board that represents shareholders, honestly negotiate against it, honestly disclose all relevant info, and hold a shareholder vote. He failed at all these, so now he has to start over (if he wants).
I dont think you are honestly trying to engage in a conversation about negotiation, and want to make a specific point about Musk that I'm not interested in. If you want to continue, you can respond with relevant points about negotiation. If not, that fine too, I just wish you hadn't wasted my time.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoI'm not interested in continuing this discussion if you insist on making it about me personally. If you'd like to address any of the specific points I made, rather than just replying to the elmu ones, or attacking me personally, please do so. Case in point: of the 7 paragraphs I wrote, you ignored 5 or 6, attacked me personally, complained about the remainder, then attacked me personally again. As for the judgement of the judge: you brought judgment up, claiming you personally thought something was obvious or presumable. It wasn't, as a matter of judgement. You claimed that something wasn't "fully fleshed-out logic". It was, as a matter of judgement. These matters which you brought up, were decided by a judge, whose judgement supercedes ours, and it's not unreasonable to point that out when you bring them up. Missing is a response to the basic tenet that, if you own a company, increasing the value of that company (by performing, rather than checking out or quitting) is compensation equal to the amount you increased the value, multiplied by the fraction of the company you own. If you are honestly trying to engage in a conversation about compensation, you can respond to that point. If not, that's fine, you can spend your time how you wish.