10 ms·
Someone brought-up an interesting point: The thought of your entire iBooks or Kindle book library evaporating is a sobering one. Will all of this be around in
by robomartin 15y ago
Someone brought-up an interesting point: The thought of your entire iBooks or Kindle book library evaporating is a sobering one.
Will all of this be around in twenty or thirty years? I have physical books that are nearly 100 years old in my library. They don't require a third party to exist in order to be usable.
These kinds of things make you re-think some of these ideas.
Another place where this happens much faster is power tools. I still have a number of excellent power tools that are easily 15 to 20 years old. Sawzall, drill, router, biscuit joiner, circular saw, etc.
All of them have a chord and are AC powered.
None of the battery powered tools I bought long ago are around. In some cases the battery packs have been discontinued. In other cases the batteries went bad and the replacement cost for the obsolete packs is just too high.
So, if you want to leave tools and books to your kids, you might want to rethink what you are buying. It is possible to imagine that iBooks and Kindle will not be around in 40 to 50 years.
Anyone know what the TOS say about this for both Apple and Amazon? Do you own your books or have they become licenses that can go poof overnight?
- frio 15y agoIn the case of Amazon at least, the DRM on Kindle ebooks is ludicrously easy to crack. Every book I purchase, I crack - both for self-preservation (the removal of 1984 from every device it was installed on was worrying), and because not being able to share frustrates me. More than games, music, etc., not being able to share books drives me crazy. Everyone in my flat has a small library; we share our books between eachother. When we started getting Kindles, that was stymied: after reading the first book in the Void trilogy on paper, I was unable to let my flatmate (who read the first book after me) read the second book - because I bought it on Kindle. That was... well, lame. So now, I manage my Kindle with Calibre. Every book I buy gets cracked.
- caf 15y agoThis is exactly what I do with my Kobo. I buy EPUB format books and immediately crack the DRM off and load them into Calibre, confident that I'll be able to convert it and load it onto whatever device I may buy in the future.
- runjake 15y agoEither you are buying off a different Amazon store or there's some new Topaz DRM decryption scheme. As far as I know, most current Kindle books aren't crackable.
- wging 15y agoHardly new... they're definitely crackable.
- freehunter 15y agoI've had one Kindle book recently that Calibre wasn't able to crack automatically. It was a Kindle print replica textbook which I bought to read on my Touchpad in class. Turns out when they say "PC/Mac/iPad Compatible", they really mean ONLY PC/Mac/iPad. Android Kindle apps can't read them. I spent the entire weekend cracking their various obfuscation methods to find out it was a DRM'd PDF wrapped in a Palm Database format container. When I got it completely stripped, it was a straight PDF with no loss of functionality. Could they have sold it as a PDF with their normal Kindle DRM? Yes. Would this have been sufficient enough to keep piracy to acceptable levels? Yes. Any miniscule amount of DRM is enough. It's like putting WEP on your router. It will keep out the riff raff (which is good enough for most cases) but anyone who is determined to break your encryption will figure out how to do it. With something like an ebook, I would imagine that 9:1 sales to piracy rate would be realistic, and that's well within acceptable range in my opinion.
- wazoox 15y agolisten, if you want to get rid of DRM legally and as soon as possible, the only reasonable way is not to crack, but to boycott DRM laden ebooks, plain and simple. That's what I do. It's annoying but it's the price to pay if you want things to be what's right and not what egoistically please you more.
- drewcrawford 15y ago> Will all of this be around in twenty or thirty years? I actually have the opposite theory. Will books be around in 20 or 30 years? I mean, books that exist now will continue to exist. But will new ones continue to be printed? Will it continue to exist as a format? I am an early adopter, but a growing fraction of things I read simply do not come in dead-tree format. We are approaching a singularity where today's hardbacks becomes tomorrow's paperbacks--something to do when demand is higher than anticipated. I am with you when you are concerned about DRM and how long your iPad will last. But I think DRM-free PDF and ePub are a lot more futureproof than paper. Imagine if your house catches on fire--do you even have a list of books to put on the insurance form? Whereas, I have all my books backed up with geographic redundancy. Disclaimer: I've scanned all my books, http://sealedabstract.com/lifehacking/the-joy-of-electronic-books/ http://sealedabstract.com/lifehacking/the-joy-of-electronic-...
- anonymoushn 15y agoAll of your images seem to be 0 bytes.
- lukev 15y agoWith current technology, physical media is still more robust for the effort expended. If you throw a book on a shelf, it will be there in 50 years except in the event of a house-destroying catastrophe (which hopefully insurance would cover). No thought required. In fact, my son could discover it decades after I'm dead, with no other communication between us. Current digital solutions, however, require more or less constant upkeep. Physical media such as hard drives, DVDs and flash is susceptible to both catastrophic failure and bit rot with a half life of only about 5 years (in my experience). Online storage services which outsource the task of redundant maintained storage avoid this, but to protect yourself from services going defunct you need to have your data on multiple services and keep them constantly synced. In short, if you stop actively backing up/maintaining your data for even a few years, chances are you'll loose it. I think there's also discoverability issues with digital media in its current incarnation, but that's another discussion.
- firebones 15y ago
- ChuckMcM 15y agoYes, this is why I store PDFs on archival optical media with the C code to parse the PDF. I really need a good (as in compact) epub reader to keep with my OReilly library though. Any pointers appreciated.
- mattgreenrocks 15y agoIn thirty years, C code may be a goofy relic of ages past that is difficult to get going. (Yeah yeah, you're probably thinking C is eternal. But I'm sure people swore that older languages would survive no matter what.)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gaius 15y agoOn the Starship Enterprise, the payroll will still be done in COBOL.
- EdiX 15y agoOlder languages as widespread as C did survive and will haunt us forever and ever.
- freehunter 15y ago45 years later and I'm still waiting for something better than Unix and convoluted shell scripting. But what do you know, it's still around, it's still in production almost everywhere, and it's still required learning at schools. If something is going to replace the best tool for the job, it will have to be a lot better than "better". Not that it hasn't happened before, but in these two cases, it hasn't happened yet.
- spatten 15y agoAn epub file is just a zip archive containing HTML files and a manifest. You could probably get away with just epub and something to unzip them with. I'm assuming that HTML renderers will be around for a while, though. If you're feeling paranoid, throw in a copy of lynx or a quick script to strip out all of the tags :).
- rsl7 15y ago"re" think? Everything digital is far more ephemeral than their physical counterparts. Print your favorite photos in black and white on acid free paper if you want them to endure.
- phillmv 15y agoI'm interested in collecting links and thoughts on this very issue. Do you need to use special ink on acid-free paper? Is it easy to buy acid-free paper? Have we figured out any good ways for long term just plain data preservation? (let's forget about preserving obsolete encoding formats, for the sake of argument) I have a number of videos of someone dear to me that I'll never be able to replicate, and I'm very interested in making it last slightly longer than my current harddrive/the lifespan of my amazon S3 backups. I have half a pg-style-essay on The Great Forgetting kicking around my harddrive. I have this pet theory that future archeologists will have a better conception of 1980s pop culture than what is about to unfold in the decades to come. Or even what's happening right now that large tracts of late 90s/early aughts digital culture is evaporating.
- rsl7 15y agoWe are restoring some old family photos and movies - all the black and white photos are fine, but the color photos are fading. All the old cellulite film from the 30s and 40s is pretty much dead, it's just disintegrating. There is no long term preservation besides copying. All my digital video on tape from the early 2000s is dead. The early DVDs I burned in 2002-2004 are all dead (due to the organic dye, I guess). Many of the CDs I burned in the late 90s are dead. The most durable digital format I have has been the 5.25" disks, probably due to their ultra low density.
- RandallBrown 15y agoThe library of congress is cataloging all of our tweets. We'll be just fine.
- gaius 15y ago"Special ink" ;-) There is no ink in traditional printing, no printer as you think of it either. There is silver and there is gelatin embedded in the paper, and you project the film onto it, then wash it in special chemicals to make the projected image permanent. You can get it done from digital easily enough these days however http://www.ilfordlab.com/ http://www.ilfordlab.com/
- BrisbaneGreg 15y agoApologies for being cynical, but you can guarantee that things will be 'no longer supported' etc in the future.. purely by the planned obsolescence of the capitalist system. I work in the book trade and while we may see a shift in 20-30 years - certain things will never disappear - coffee table books, most kids books, drawing books etc. "Mainstream" (whatever that means) authors may become virtually exclusively electronic. Personally I like to look at my bookshelves and what is there - and enjoy viewing others.
- antidoh 15y ago"Will all of this be around in twenty or thirty years?" No.
- uvTwitch 15y agoI have bought a kindle, upon which are stored many books. I have also bought many physical books. Have I purchased any kindle books? Well, only if they aren't available in physical form. I am confused by people who believe that things on the internet are any sort of permanent - or private, but that's another matter entirely.
- dubya 15y agoMost of the battery packs for tools are proprietary shells around completely standard cells inside. If you can open the plastic shell without destroying it, you can just replace the cells, usually for less than the manufacturer wants for the whole thing. And maybe 3-d printing would allow case replacement.
- astrodust 15y agoThe usual "NiCad" and "NiMH" batteries are straight-forward to replace, but lithium-based batteries can be dangerous. They'll explode if not properly charged and have electronics paired to the cell to manage the charging cycle. I'd be extremely careful when hacking lithium batteries. If you must, follow a guide (http://www.electronics-lab.com/articles/Li_Ion_reconstruct/ http://www.electronics-lab.com/articles/Li_Ion_reconstruct/) and be very careful. When things go wrong, the results are spectacular (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3o_2mwRPdw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z3o_2mwRPdw).