3 ms·
A domain registrar and a domain registry should really be acting as a common carrier. If it's not legal in their relevant jurisdictions, fine. Otherwise, my reg
by toast0 3y ago
A domain registrar and a domain registry should really be acting as a common carrier. If it's not legal in their relevant jurisdictions, fine. Otherwise, my registrar is hardly endorsing my content.
Website hosting, sure, they've got wide latitude to exercise editorial control. DNS services, yeah, I guess.
If your registrar doesn't like your content, maybe they should disallow you to use ancillary services and refund you for the free dns they usually provide, but won't. But I don't think they should be making editorial judgement about the content, all the content they see is your domain name, your contact info, your registered authoritative name servers, and ips for registered name servers inside your domain.
- tsukikage 3y agoDomain registrars do not exist in a vacuum. In order for a registrar to be able to make this kind of guarantee, they also need it from /their/ contractors. Specifically, for a registrar to stay in business, ISPs and payment processors should not be able to refuse them service (or, if they are also an ISP in their own right, other ISPs should not be able to refuse connection/peering arrangements). Otherwise, they're stuck between a rock and a hard place: either they kick out the undesirables to appease their suppliers, or the whole business is forced to fold and cannot serve anyone at all. A few more steps in this chain and your free market democracy isn't looking so very free any more.