5 ms·
If I had to put a valid reason to this instead of simply declaring that EA are dicks (which is still true but...), I'd guess that the rights on the songs expire
by Karunamon 15y ago
If I had to put a valid reason to this instead of simply declaring that EA are dicks (which is still true but...), I'd guess that the rights on the songs expired and they are no longer legally allowed to distribute them.
Think about it. It would be even more scummy of them to leave the app up for download with no way to pull the songs required to play the game down from the cloud.
It's shitty either way, especially if you just bought the app but, I don't see a good way out of it.
- mikeash 15y agoNegotiating rights in such a way that leaves you open to this, then selling the app when you know you might have to pull it due to licensing, is not really any better.
- smackfu 15y agoThere is a middle ground. They can pull the app from the store, but it is still playable on people devices. It's not great, but it's a lot better than "you can't play this game anymore even though it's installed." And it seems fairly ridiculous that EA would not get rights that last for the life of a single product. They've been doing song licensing for 10+ years now.
- masterzora 15y agoIf the songs are in the cloud that middle ground doesn't work.
- jlawer 15y agoThe songs aren't on the cloud, as the game works perfectly on an ipod touch when wifi is disabled. The problem is games requiring "authentication servers" to do anything. The general thought has been when these servers were removed the last act of the company would be to release an update that disabled the requirement of the servers... however this has never really happened. It frustrates me as thanks to tools like DosBox I am still playing games on my Mac that I first played years ago (Master of Orion 2 specifically). There is a distinct possibility that every game you purchase will no longer work in 5 years between DRM'd executable, proprietary platforms and authentication servers.
- Karunamon 15y agoDon't you have to pull the songs down at least once though?
- yuliyp 15y agoEA sold you a copy of the song along with a license to use that song in the context of playing the game. If the copy was sold with a stipulation that you could not use the copy after a certain period of time that's fine, but that's not what happened. If EA was sending out copies of songs that it didn't have the right to do under its licensing agreements, then it sounds like people could probably easily sue to get the money the paid for DLC back (since the transaction was fraudulent as EA didn't have the right to sell what it sold, though ianal).
- coopdog 15y agoAssuming the songs are on the phone, it should fail gracefully Any functions requiring server access should inform you that they are no longer available, while the game bit itself should still be playable Obviously login wouldn't work any more, they should offer one final upgrade to let users use the app without logging in