3 ms·
I wonder if you could make it even more "beautiful" by gradually easing between the various curvatures rather than having the discontinuities at the intersectio
by ryandrake 3y ago
I wonder if you could make it even more "beautiful" by gradually easing between the various curvatures rather than having the discontinuities at the intersections of the curves. Kind of like the difference between a square with rounded corners and a "squircle"[1].
1: https://webflow.com/blog/squircle-vs-rounded-squares https://webflow.com/blog/squircle-vs-rounded-squares
- alexchamberlain 3y agoDo you have discontinuities though? The tangents at the point of intersection match.
- fanf2 3y agoThere is a discontinuity in curvature where each arc meets. It’s possible to make joins between curves smoother using Euler spirals, but I don’t know how to use them well enough to apply them to eggs. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euler_spiral https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euler_spiral I recently tried to draw f holes using Euler spirals, but they turned out too short and fat, and I gave up on them. But they are quite fun to draw on a computer by simple numerical integration, ignoring all the more complicated mathematics in the wikipedia article. Perhaps I could have made my f holes more elegant by understanding the parts I ignored… https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_hole https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_hole
- notfish 3y agoI do hate when f holes are too short and fat, but yes: understanding the parts you generally ignore might help.
- pimlottc 3y agoThe issue is more the smoothness in the change in curvy-ness: https://www.figma.com/blog/desperately-seeking-squircles/ https://www.figma.com/blog/desperately-seeking-squircles/
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoIf you sit in a rolling car and the driver suddenly presses the break vs eases it in, you could halt with the same deceleration and yet one will feel smoother than the other. The car's position is not discontinuous, the velocity isn't either (in both cases it has to slow through intermediate velocities). It is the decelaration that in one case grows suddenly and in the other changes smoothly. On an egg, there is no place where curvature changes suddenly, and yet on a four point egg there are points where it does exactly that.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoFrom [1]: > “This may seem trivial, a cool story, but subconsciously it really makes a big impact: a squircle doesn’t look like a square with surgery performed on it; it registers as an entity in its own right, like the shape of a smooth pebble in a riverbed, a unified and elemental whole.” Am I the only one who prefers squares with rounded corners? "Shape of a smooth pebble" is not something I like to see anywhere outside a garden. A "squircle" looks inflated, like Li-Ion battery about to pop and set your house on fire, or like package with food that spoiled, and will stink if opened, and make you sick if eaten. You need to hold your breath around a "squircle", because the moment you breathe out and time unfreezes, it'll start rolling and tumbling. Even nature itself doesn't really do "sqiurcles" unless it must. The last "squircle" I saw was when I burned my back badly and had them pop up on my skin (if you read this and think "gross", well, that's what "squircles" are for me in general). The most benign connotation I have with a "squircle" is a pillow, which again is something that doesn't belong in almost any context. A square with rounded corners, in contrast, looks purposeful. An object created with intent. It speaks of precision, of quality, of human workmanship. It looks stable, unspoiled, new. It fits.