5 ms·
CloudFare outage (System Status, back online now)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Udo 15y agoSame here, glad I don't have anything critical hosted there. They have just come back online again though.
- wahnfrieden 15y ago"Expanding investigation for upstream network issues affecting all locations." "Network issue should be clearing up. Continuing to monitor." Seems to be back up now.
- jaytaylor 15y agoTwitter search is nice for staying up to date on this: https://twitter.com/#!/search/cloudflare https://twitter.com/#!/search/cloudflare
- wahnfrieden 15y agoTheir status page is currently 500ing, but they have a Twitter account for it too: https://twitter.com/#!/cloudflaresys https://twitter.com/#!/cloudflaresys "Investigating upstream network issues in EU." -- even though the outage appears to be global...
- pwenzel 15y agoMy Pingdom monitor started making notes a few minutes ago. Having the same downtime problems on one of my sites.
- eli 15y agoSeems to be back now. https://twitter.com/#!/CloudFlareSys/status/197785441360023552 https://twitter.com/#!/CloudFlareSys/status/1977854413600235... blames an upstream network issue. But I dunno, cloudflare.com was giving me a 502 error from ngnix, which indicates a cloudflare-backend problem.
- jjoe 15y agoJust thought I'd expand on this part of your comment: "cloudflare.com was giving me a 502 error from ngnix, which indicates a cloudflare-backend problem" Everything is a backend (ex: your server). Your CF hosted website is a backend to their front end (Nginx). Except the "backend" here is located in a remote network where your actual server is hosted. So it could very well be a routing issue between their network (Nginx nodes) and your server. Hence the 502 (backend unreachable). Regards
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- micro-ram 15y agoYes, but CloudFlare is supposed to show a cached copy of my site when my server (i.e. backend) is unreachable.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Udo 15y agoTo their credit, they turned this issue around very quickly. Overall I have to say that Cloudflare is an excellent service. This event does remind me of the predictable and somewhat obvious question though: do the benefits of a service like Cloudflare outweigh the downsides that inevitably come along with introducing another single point of failure to a website?
- jyap 15y agoWell theoretically Cloudflare is designed with a decentralized approach which means it is not a single point of failure. I've noticed that large scale issues like this are usually down to botched router configurations or related networking changes.
- Udo 15y ago> it is not a single point of failure. Obviously today Cloudflare did become a single point of failure for many sites, so I'm not quite sure I understand your point. I also don't believe you can design any service with 100% uptime. Things will go wrong.
- jyap 15y agoThe operative word here is "theoretically". Theoretically the concept of CDN's (a broad term to describe the main aspect of Cloudflare's service) gives you greater replication and redundancy of data. Now this all depends on their overall design (not all CDN's are created equal). You can eliminate SPOF's through replication and redundancy. It's like saying I have 2 cars I can use to get to work. Then you say "But what if both break down?" Uh, 2 cars breaking down is not considered a single point of failure. Take the example of serving a single image on the internet. It starts with DNS. You can have multiple DNS servers for your domain (no SPOF for DNS lookups). You have multiple web servers in different countries. Your web servers point to CDNs to serve the image. Your CDN has multiple DNS servers for their domain. They have multiple servers in different countries to serve up your image. Tell me where the 100% uptime of the single image fails in that scenario. To answer your original question, if Value derived (can be high say for a news site) > Risk involved (can be low depending on provider), then that is when the benefits outweigh the downsides. In most cases, a CDN is meant to give you better uptime as well as provide you benefits such as geographically delivered content and the ability to serve your content to more people (eg. videos and other large media content).
- jgrahamc 15y agoPerhaps change the title to "CloudFlare was down briefly" because it's not down any more. We were aware immediately that a problem was occurring and fixed it. To quote the people who watch the CloudFlare network night and day: "While tuning Asia performance, an improper router config was pushed, causing our upstream provider to misroute. Pinpointed issue and fixed." Lots of red faces around the office and people apologizing.
- wahnfrieden 15y agoUpdated, thanks.
- qeorge 15y agoThis explains a lot, thanks. We noticed that the traceroute for one of our domains was running through Asia (usually DFW) and found it odd. It also changed shortly when the sites came back online. Glad to know it was just a mistake though, as opposed to an attack or failure. Much less worried about recurrence.
- vinayan3 15y agoThanks. My site went down and we were trying to get some new user on today. We held on and things seem to be ok now!
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Nyr 15y agoCloudFlare promotes their service as a highly redundant CDN but the truth is that this isn't the first outage and they fail at very simple things. I was using them until one day, they had routing problems with their DNS servers to some parts of the world (about 20% IIRC). This shouldn't be a issue except because all the name servers they provide were routing to the same network, making all my services unavailable for more than one hour. Yes, they have anycast and all that cool things, but if they fail providing real redundancy for DNS, I can't be their customer anymore.
- true_religion 15y agoI think CloudFlare isn't bad for a small-to-midsize site. They're new in the industry and still learning. If you have a large mature site, then its likely your uptime will be better than theirs and you'll lose serious money for every minute of downtime. In that case, don't use CloudFlare because they're still learning from their mistakes.
- benatkin 15y ago> They're new in the industry and still learning. They aren't that new, and they would have learned faster if they had better priorities. Not only do they seem to prioritize the script minification and code insertion over performance, they seem to prioritize popularity over customer service. It's easy to find reviews of CloudFlare where someone running a small-to-midsize site gave them a fair shot and was disappointed.
- codexon 15y agoThey seem to have random unexplained outages every other week that aren't even mentioned on Twitter.
- larrys 15y agoWhen I first considered cloudflare the thing that kept me away (and this was quite some time ago) was the "quality" of the customers. In looking at the domains they hosted I rarely saw anything but small and spammy type sites. I also notice that they had constant churn. They would bring on customers but many customers were also leaving every day in numbers for any day I checked. This doesn't appear to have changed. For the link below, simply change the date in the URL to any day and you will see the domains that are added and transferred out of cloudflare on a constant basis: http://www.dailychanges.com/cloudflare.com/2012-05-02/ http://www.dailychanges.com/cloudflare.com/2012-05-02/ Added: To me given what cloudflare is it doesn't make sense that these domains are transferred out as frequently as they are other than for service related reasons. In fact we had suggested cf to a customer and they lasted about a week on the service and had issues.
- eli 15y agoWhat are you comparing them to? Based on your logic they don't seem any worse than any other DNS provider I plugged in. E.g. http://www.dailychanges.com/dnsmadeeasy.com/2012-05-02/ http://www.dailychanges.com/dnsmadeeasy.com/2012-05-02/