4 ms·
I may be missing something, but name resolution has been touted as one of the more legitimate and sensible uses for blockchain for a very long time. Could you c
by int_19h 3y ago
I may be missing something, but name resolution has been touted as one of the more legitimate and sensible uses for blockchain for a very long time. Could you clarify what your issues with it in IPFS context are?
- edent 3y agoIt isn't. Unless you want a long incomprehensible string. Someone is always going to want a short, unique, and memorable name. And when two people share the same name (McDonald, Nissan, etc) there needs to be a way to disambiguate them. If people die and are unable to release a desirable name, that just makes the whole system less desirable. I know one of the canonical hard problems in Computer Science is "naming things" and this is a prime example!
- bombcar 3y agoAnd if you want a long incomprehensible string we already have that .onion sites work without a blockchain, too.
- null0pointer 3y agoENS (which is what the GP refers to) has human readable names. But it doesn't have support for A/AAAA records today (does anyone know why? A-record support was in the original spec). Aside from that the only reason you wouldn't be able to type "mycoolsite.eth" into your browsers URL bar and have it resolve to an IP is because no browser has an ENS resolver built in. Yet.
- dazaidesu 3y agoBrave does right?
- null0pointer 3y agoI didn't know that. That's good if it does.
- patmorgan23 3y agoNamecoin has existed for a long time. It acts just like a traditional domain registar. First person to register a name gets it, and they have to pay a maintenance fee to keep it. Don't pay the maintenance fee and then someone else can register the name.
- acdha 3y agoYes, but statistically nobody uses it due to those problems. Squatters quickly snapped up the most popular DNS names but since nobody uses it there’s no financial benefit from paying Danegeld, and that’s a vicious cycle of irrelevance. This is the core flaw of most of these systems: people hype them up selling the idea that it’ll become huge later, but without some link to real value or authority there’s no reason to favor one implementation over another or doing nothing at all. This comes up a lot in the case of IPFS because the core problem is that most people won’t host anything on the internet. It’s expensive and legally risky, which forces you to vet who you host and then you have a less revolutionary pitch which has to be based on cost, performance, etc. and that’s a tough market.
- int_19h 3y agoIt might not be popular in general, but surely IPFS crowd specifically would be a lot more receptive to such a thing? IPFS itself is similarly niche.
- acdha 3y agoPerhaps, but that doesn’t mean they’re suckers. If you’re going to have to deal with bootstrapping an alternate root anyway you probably aren’t motivated to pay off a speculator for the privilege of making their holdings more valuable.
- ShamelessC 3y ago> but name resolution has been touted as one of the more legitimate and sensible uses for blockchain for a very long time. Blockchain enthusiasts have a history of talking out of their ass and being susceptible to the lies of others.
- ShamelessC 3y agoDownvotes, nice. Whatever helps you sleep at night.
- p4bl0 3y agoWell, I do not actually believe that blockchains can do name resolution correctly. First and foremost, the essential thing to understand about blockchains is that the only thing that is guaranteed by writing an information on a blockchain is that this information is written on this blockchain. And that's it. If the writing itself is not performative, in that it's mere existence performs what it describes, then nothing has been done. It works for crypto-assets because what makes a transaction happen is that it is written on the blockchain where that crypto-asset lives and where people look to see what happened with that crypto-asset. But for any other usage, it cannot work, blockchain are useless. Someone or something somewhere has to make sure either that what's written on the blockchain corresponds to the real world, or to make the real worlds corresponds to what's written on the blockchain. Either way you need to have a kind of central authority, or at least trusted third parties. And that means you don't actually need a blockchain in the first place. We have better, more secured, more efficient, less costly alternatives to using a blockchain. Back to name resolutions. Virtually no one is going to actually host locally the blockchain where all names are stored. That would be way too big and could only get bigger and bigger, as a blockchain stores transactions (i.e., diffs) rather than current state. So in practice people and their devices would ask resolvers, just like they currently do with DNS. These resolvers would need to keep a database of the state of all names up-to-date because querying a blockchain is way too inefficient, running such a resolvers would be a lot more costly than running a DNS servers so there would be less of them. Here we just lost decentralization which was the point of the system. But that's just a technical problem. There is more: what if someone gets a name and we as a society (i.e., justice, whatever) decides that they should not be in control of it? Either we are able to enforce this decision and it means the system is not actually decentralized (so, we don't need a blockchain), or we can't, and that's a problem. What if a private key is lost, the associated names are gone forever? What if your private key is leaked by mistake and someone hostile take control of your name? Using a blockchain for names resolution doesn't actually work, not for a human society.
- mikegreenberg 3y ago> Either way you need to have a kind of central authority, or at least trusted third parties. You lost me here. Couldn't the local user ('s process) reference the same block chain instead of another trusted party?