3 ms·
Consider a 100 x 101 grid (101 rows and 100 columns). Each row is a possible urn (from 0 green balls to 100 green balls). The columns correspond to the 100 ball
by layer8 3y ago
Consider a 100 x 101 grid (101 rows and 100 columns). Each row is a possible urn (from 0 green balls to 100 green balls). The columns correspond to the 100 balls in each urn. The rows are sorted by ascending number of green balls, and the columns are sorted by red balls first. Reduced to 10 x 11, this would be:
RRRRRRRRRR
RRRRRRRRRG
RRRRRRRRGG
RRRRRRRGGG
RRRRRRGGGG
RRRRRGGGGG
RRRRGGGGGG
RRRGGGGGGG
RRGGGGGGGG
RGGGGGGGGG
GGGGGGGGGG
The rows are parallel universes, each of them equally likely. When you draw the first ball, the universes each split into 100 also equally likely universes, corresponding to which of the 100 balls you drew. So each of the 10100 grid cells represents a possible universe you can find yourself in, each equally likely.
When you draw red, you know that you are somewhere in the upper left triangle of Rs, which each R being equally likely.
RRRRRRRRRR
RRRRRRRRR
RRRRRRRR
RRRRRRR
RRRRRR
RRRRR
RRRR
RRR
RR
R
It’s clear that you are more likely to be in the upper half of that triangle, because it contains more Rs. In fact, because there are 5050 Rs, and the upper 30 rows have 2565 Rs (I’m applying the triangle-number formula n * (n + 1) / 2), you’re more likely to be within the upper 30 rows (urns) than the lower 70 rows (urns), and hence it is clearly more likely that the second ball you draw is again red rather than green. (Though visualizing this further split of universes would require a 3rd dimension.)