3 ms·
I've never understood the benefits of a pie menu in regular computing. They've always seemed difficult to read (my eyes travel linearly easily, but following a
by crazygringo 3y ago
I've never understood the benefits of a pie menu in regular computing.
They've always seemed difficult to read (my eyes travel linearly easily, but following around a circle is non-intuitive), and similarly difficult to click. Even using a gamepad joystick, I often find myself accidentally selecting a neighbor of what I meant to pick, because I wasn't getting the angle exactly right, or inadvertently relaxed the joystick as I clicked the button to confirm.
Keyboard shortcuts, or just regular linear context menus, have always seemed a lot faster and easier to use, respectively, on the desktop. On game consoles I can understand that they're more useful because you don't have a keyboard or mouse... but even then it's more a question of being the least-bad alternative when you really need to instantly select between 8 alternatives.
Am I missing a context where the usability of a pie menu is superior?
- SnooSux 3y agoKeyboard shortcuts don't have the discoverability of a menu interface but are good for power users. Ideally they would complement each other. I really like the ergonomics of pie menus, though my experience is limited to Blender. Navigating linear menus require more fine movements than flicking the mouse in one of 8 or fewer directions. And the direction of mouse movement becomes muscle memory the way a keyboard shortcut does. I find a pie menu works well in a mouse-heavy workflow like 3D modelling. But there are definitely applications where it wouldn't be the right fit.
- crazygringo 3y ago> I find a pie menu works well in a mouse-heavy workflow like 3D modelling. Ah thank you, that's very helpful. I can see how you wouldn't want to move your hand from mouse to keyboard for keyboard shortcuts that aren't one-handed, but the pie menu would allow you to develop a spatial/directional muscle memory (like keyboard shortcuts have) that linear context menus don't have. Exactly the context I was missing -- I've never done any 3D modeling!
- ramses0 3y agoIt's "point free" (can be initiated from anywhere), and can be "regular" (same motions results in the same actions), making it navigable without looking or requiring precise selection. Close cousin to "gesture" interfaces. eg: Up/Right/Up => something, Up/Left/Down => something else. With three gestures you get ~4x3x3 => 36 actions => a whole alnum-keyboard of 26+10 digits! (assuming you only allow four gestures and remove the "reverse" after choosing any direction, eg: Left/Right/Left would be equivalent to Left/... with pending input). Even better if you throw in an 8-way selector minimally in the first position.
- Terretta 3y agoHe and you say "initiated from anywhere" but the demo video conveniently only gestured parallel to screen edges. I imagine with first click starting where the video does, three up choices would feel constrained.
- WorldMaker 3y agoIf that's a common gesture for you, you are going to learn some muscle memory to initiate the menu lower on the screen. (Also, I think the gesture distances in the demos are exaggerated for effect?) If you are discovering your way through the menu you don't need much distance at all to make your choices obvious, and some of the pie menu implementations in the worst case let you reposition the menu entirely if need be.
- eviks 3y agoYou don't read them, you use icons for instant recognition, your eyes don't even need to travel anywhere as that will fit in your focuse'd vision (as is illustrated in the repo's gif), gamepad joystick is worse vs. a mouse since in a mouse you can move it further away faster to the distance where you avoid any angle issues. This is the superior usability - a pie menu you can switch to any item with the same distance while in a regular list to get to the last one you have to skip everything, so the menus tend to be smallish in height, thus making the selection harder For example, while moving horizontally to a sub-menu, you can easily cross the width of a single line since it's not easy to move your mouse absolutely steady horizontally (in pro graphic apps you'd usually hold a Shift for that), so instead of moving to a sub-menu, you switch to another item. In a Pie menu that's much harder since as you move further the menu's area increases, so the tolerance is higher Keyboard shortcuts can also be enabled for this type of menu.
- aidenn0 3y ago> For example, while moving horizontally to a sub-menu, you can easily cross the width of a single line since it's not easy to move your mouse absolutely steady horizontally (in pro graphic apps you'd usually hold a Shift for that), so instead of moving to a sub-menu, you switch to another item. In a Pie menu that's much harder since as you move further the menu's area increases, so the tolerance is higher This is why properly implemented context menus don't strictly require you to move in a straight line. Implementations vary; I just tried it with the firefox context menu on linux and found that, once the submenu was open, I could move the cursor quickly to the submenu on any path, even taking a diagonal line to the most extreme options in it. I have also seen implementations where you had a ever widening path you could take as the cursor moved closer to the submenu, making the active area of the currently selected parent item trapezoidal.
- eviks 3y agoWhat implementation allows you to move diagonally? What if you slow down or move diagonally to another top menu instead of a submenu, do you know have to wait a bit before selection changes? This is tricky dynamic guesswork, and isn't great UI even with the visual height increases guiding you, in pie menus you see beforehand all the borders, so it's more explicit and predictable
- somishere 3y agoI mocked up an "infinite" circular menu concept last year. Idea was to use for navigating a non-linear timeline of photos / dates (in limited space on a website / map). Felt like a good use case. Still think the use case feels solid. https://codepen.io/theprojectsomething/pen/JjmgXrg https://codepen.io/theprojectsomething/pen/JjmgXrg I'd also say keyboard shortcuts can work really well alongside this kind of UI, giving a single mapped key much more depth.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Keyframe 3y ago(now Autodesk) Maya has a form of this, called hotbox, since first beta around 1997 when I first saw it, and probably before during development and probably before that from Alias where it probably originated. They researched a lot on UI and interaction between a designer and the model and that's one of the things they went with. It's context sensitive and eventually you build out muscle memory for it, you don't even read anymore what's in it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MrjMy3N6vo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MrjMy3N6vo
- DonHopkins 3y agoFitts' Law intuitively and mathematically explains why pie menus are faster and have lower error rates than linear menus. Fitts's Law says in effect: the bigger and closer a target is, the faster and more reliably you can hit it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitts%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fitts%27s_law >Fitts's law (often cited as Fitts' law) is a predictive model of human movement primarily used in human–computer interaction and ergonomics. The law predicts that the time required to rapidly move to a target area is a function of the ratio between the distance to the target and the width of the target. Fitts's law is used to model the act of pointing, either by physically touching an object with a hand or finger, or virtually, by pointing to an object on a computer monitor using a pointing device. It was initially developed by Paul Fitts. Pie menus both minimize the target distance, while also maximizing the target size. And the physical directional gesture required to select an item does not demand your continuous visual attention and cognitively taxing hand-eye feedback loop. You don't need to look at the screen to select items from a pie menu, so you can reliably "mouse ahead" or gesture, which is impossible with linear menus. Another advantage is that they support "rehearsal", by seamlessly training novice users to become experts. Unlike keyboard shortcuts, the physical action of the novice and expert is the same, only experts can do it faster without looking at the screen. Unlike traditional "invisible" gesture recognition systems like Palm Graffiti or StrokePlus.net, pie menus are "self revealing" in that the can pop up a menu that shows all the available options and their direction. It's quite difficult to learn which invisible gestures are available and what they all mean, but easy to discover them with pie menus. Pie menus also support "browsing" and "reselection", which gesture recognition doesn't, allowing users to correct errors or even browse around highlighting every item to preview its effects. Since pie menus can provide live continuous preview of the effects of the selected item in the application itself (which is especially nice when you use the distance as a parameter, for example a pie menu that lets you create eight objects, with a pull-out size parameter: the more you pull out, the bigger the object previewed at your cursor, which switches to different objects as you browse around the menu, then turns into a real object when you release the button), so you can see the effect and release the button when it's perfect, or go back to the center to cancel. Often the only feedback you need is the live preview of the pie menu selection, and popping up a menu would be a distraction. Once you learn the directions, you can quickly select items by stroking in the desired direction without even looking at the menu, so pie menus can perform the selection without popping up the menu. There's no need to pop up the "self revealing" menu until you stop dragging the mouse, or you can pop it up instantly by "clicking up" the menu. So a novice can get directions instantly, while an expert can fly ahead without waiting for directions, then pause for directions or confirmation that you have the right selection at any time. There's a smooth escalator moving you up the learning curve every time you use a pie menu, training your muscle memory through rehearsal. That is how pie menus "Lead, follow, or get out of the way". We performed an empirical study in 1988 that measured eight-item pie menus to be 15% faster than linear menus, with less frequent errors. An Empirical Comparison of Pie vs. Linear Menus (Jack Callahan, Don Hopkins, Mark Weiser, and Ben Shneiderman, Proc. ACM CHI’88): https://donhopkins.medium.com/an-empirical-comparison-of-pie-vs-linear-menus-466c6fdbba4b https://donhopkins.medium.com/an-empirical-comparison-of-pie... >Pie menus gain over traditional linear menus by reducing target seek time, lowering error rates by fixing the distance factor and increasing the target size in Fitts’s Law, minimizing the drift distance after target selection, and are, in general, subjectively equivalent to the linear style. [...] >Pilot study results: A pilot study of 16 subjects showed that users were approximately 15% faster with the pie menus and that errors were less frequent with pie menus. Statistically significant differences were found for item seek time but not task type. Subjects were split on their subjective preference of pie and linear menus. Some commented that they were able to visually isolate an item easier with linear menus and that it was hard to control the selection in pie menus because of the sensitivity of the pie menu selection mechanism. These subjects tended to be the most mouse naive of all whereas those who had heard of or seen a mouse/cursor controlled system but had not used one extensively tended to prefer pie menus. The most mouse naive users, while finding linear menus easier, tended to be better at pie menus and commented that with practice, they would probably be superior and in fact prefer the pie menus because of their speed and minimization of hand movement with the mouse. Not surprisingly, therefore, most of those preferring linear menus did not have a strong preference on the scaled subjective questionnaire. More about Fitts's Law and pie menu in this thread from Sept 27, 2022 on: Cairo: Alternative Windows Desktop: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32992673 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32992673