5 ms·
> Many people clearly like going into the office. Many people with jobs involving in-person manual labor clearly love their jobs. Anecdotal, but whenever the t
by ryandrake 3y ago
> Many people clearly like going into the office. Many people with jobs involving in-person manual labor clearly love their jobs.
Anecdotal, but whenever the topic of work comes up among my friends and neighbors, and I disclose to them that I work from home, 100% of them say things like "Wow, good for you!" and "You're so lucky!" and 0% of them so far have said "Sorry to hear that... you must really miss your commute and face to face meetings!"
- randomdata 3y agoKeep in mind that work from home doesn't literally mean work from home. One can 'work from home' in an office, on the train, or even in a field out in the middle of nowhere. It means work from wherever, whenever. It represents autonomy. It is the autonomy that is enviable. A manual labourer needing to be at a remote location in order to do the job, but able to come and go as he pleases, would be met with similar statements of "Good for you", "You are lucky". If you, instead, told that you were locked in your bedroom from 9-5 and if you so much as stop moving your mouse you will be instantly fired, "I'm sorry" would assuredly follow. It is not the "from home" part that you are being congratulated on.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNobody misses the commute. Nobody misses face-to-face meetings. (For approximate values of "nobody"). Human contact... at least some people miss that. No, Teams is not the same.
- asoneth 3y agoAgreed that most people do not miss their commute, though because I am lazy I found it useful to force me to ride every day. But I'm surprised to hear that you think "nobody misses face-to-face meetings". At least in my office that seems to be the only reason anyone shows up -- people pop by the office when they have discussions, presentations, collaborative design sessions, etc and WFH otherwise. In several cases someone has explicitly polled the group chat the day before to find out who is thinking about to coming in -- if enough attendees plan to join remotely then we typically switch the whole meeting to be a dial-in only so it doesn't end up being one person calling in from an empty conference room and everyone else at home.
- JambalayaJim 3y agoFace to face meetings are a thousand percent better than virtual meetings.
- eggy 3y agoI think a lot of those people think that you also get away with a lot without supervision because the average worker will tend to comfortable effort if they think they are not being audited somehow. For me, I could keep productive, but work crept all across the day and sort of put a buzz kill on WFH even when I lived in exotic locations in SE Asia (before the digital nomad thing). I have a lot of manual labor and knowledge skills, so I pretty much work where and when I want. Sometimes I do manual labor overseas in a job that lets me do both. I would never be able to make six figures and do 40 to 50% of my job manually here in the US. The respect for manual labor, the closing of trade schools, and the false ruler of the college degree have led to the decline of such hybrid position possibilities. Construction is still a field where you can wield a computer and have boots-on-the-ground experience. It's also easy to see productivity, something real, tangible as the product, which for me, as an effort of my mind and body (Mens et menus, MIT's slogan) feels more fulfilling than when I was purely doing computer work. I am at the stage of thinking on really working for myself - not for others - by subsistence living with my family. Growing up in Brooklyn, I used to dream about a large piece of land in Wyoming or Montana. By the 80s, the Japanese were buying lots of property in Montana.
- danaris 3y agoNo, because that's not how people who wouldn't want to work from home would react. They'd say things like "That's great for you—I would never want that," or "Man, I could never work from home—our place is too small," or one of the various other perfectly legitimate reasons people have for preferring in-office work (that I don't happen to share, but still understand). Again: the problem is with people whose jobs could allow them to work from home, who want to work from home, but who are not permitted to work from home. That's not a problem with the people who work from home, and the solution isn't mandating office work for everyone. That's a problem with the employers who won't permit it, and the solution is unions.
- randomdata 3y ago> the solution is unions. A union is only a solution where workers are trying to screw over each other to get a leg up. The classical example is where a worker accepts lesser pay to ensure that they get the job over the guy beside him who wants more money. A union sets up a 'brotherhood' where the workers mutually agree to not undercut each other like that, allowing them to maximize their benefit. Unions are not effective where the company is driving the bus. Going back to the classical example, a company that has decided that the work is worth $x and not a penny more, no union is not going to eke out more than $x. If a company is hell bent on the office being strictly necessary, there is nothing a union can do to change that. Only if a worker is trying to screw over another worker by dutifully showing up to the office, where the company would otherwise be lenient towards WFH if that were their only choice, might a union be effective. Granted, perhaps you misspoke and this is what you really meant? But that questions how effective the 'brotherhood' is when people are isolated from each other. It is one thing to honour your promise to other workers when you have to see them every day and face their scorn if you break the promise and continue to be an asshole. It is quite another when you have no connection to the other 'brothers' whatsoever – where you have probably never met, and may not even know that they exist. Unions are usually quite protective to ensure that doesn't happen. There is good reason why a software developer isn't normally welcome into a teachers union, for example. What successful WFH-focused unions that have stood the test of time can we look at? The various farmer unions fit the bill, perhaps, but I'm not sure they have proven to be all that effective. Farmers are quite good at screwing each other over and there isn't much reprisal when they do. The farmer unions that are enshrined by government rule fare better, but no doubt only because of a third-party (the government) holding the 'brotherhood' together. That is not quite the same as a 'brotherhood' by first-party accord.