6 ms·
>but did Figma even need to sell in the first place? I've worked a company that was profitable, operated well, growing ... but were sold and the CEO said (I'll
by duxup 3y ago
>but did Figma even need to sell in the first place?
I've worked a company that was profitable, operated well, growing ... but were sold and the CEO said (I'll get the words not quite right):
"I fought for keeping independent and not selling, that's how I've kept that company and I wanted it to stay that way. But the offer was increased into the range where I didn't feel like I could survive a legal challenge (if it came to that) as far as my requirement to do what is best for the shareholders."
In the case of that CEO, I believed him (i'm not usually inclined to do so). I could be wrong, of course he made a lot of money, but this guy really did seem like he really did like building companies so to speak and that was more a motivation than anything else. But in his case I think he was right, he couldn't seriously argue that he could likely provide a return to investors even for a decade or more than they could get taking the offer right then and there.
It is a problem I always worry about, good businesses are there to return value to the stockholders, it makes sense. But in the face of gobs of cash they must fold.... and so often poorly managed after that and some things are lost. It's a black hole in the free market.
- Mistletoe 3y ago*good public businesses Private businesses don’t have to do anything and is where you get some of the best companies that exist and care about their customers like Patagonia. https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-gear/gear-news/patagonia-axios-harris-poll-2023/ https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-gear/gear-news/patagon... Maybe it’s the only way out of the enshittification death spiral because there are no shareholders to destroy the company to “create value” for.
- dyno12345 3y agoThere is still a fiduciary duty even for private companies
- bombcar 3y agoPrivate companies often have so few shareholders that you can simply talk to all of them, together.
- over_bridge 3y agoThat fiduciary duty needs to die/ be reimagined. It's turned corporations into one dimensional money makers. Profit at any cost. You should make money in order to achieve your goals, not just to set the high score for making money. It's way too easy for hostile shareholders to force companies to do things that the workers, even CEO level workers, don't want to do.
- zare_st 3y agoYeah but it takes quite a success story in IT to have a breakthrough product and not yield under all the millions thrown at you, especially when you know that 'competitors' might try to break your legs all the way if you decide to stay in the race. It gets tough as the numbers start to get unreal fast. Patagonia and any physical product oriented business has a curve to ride, they grow in percentage not N fold. Someone registers a company and develops new technology, if he has the edge the company worth will skyrocket over night.
- bobthepanda 3y agoPatagonia is a unique corporate structure because it is a nonprofit that shovels all non-invested money into a 501c4. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/30/climate/patagonia-holdfast-philanthropy.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/30/climate/patagonia-holdfas...
- duxup 3y agoNot that I disagree, but in my experience the enshittification, or at least a lot of prominent examples are often services that never made money and now have to and ... yeah they can't so it goes bad. The whole cycle of "free brings in users (and we users LOVE that) --> users bring in investors --> later you have to make money --> change the service to make money and now nobody is happy" is a whole other issue.
- hnbad 3y agoThere seem to be two things at play: 1. The current economic situation is causing a lot of investors to tighten screws and demand profitability where they had previously been fine with just seeking growth because it becomes clearer that fewer investors are willing to participate in the next round of hot potato in the hopes of catching a unicorn. 2. Investors generally seek growth and at some point you've hit the physical limits by having caught nearly every customer you can and the only way to drive up those numbers is by upselling to the same people which often means kneecapping user experience to help upselling on the cure (e.g. Amazon Prime Video "channels" as extra subscriptions on top of the Prime Video ad-free subscription on top of the buy/rent for individual movies and shows on top of the Amazon Prime subscription that also includes access to Prime Video itself). With streaming services specifically there's also the effect where Netflix itself ended up figuring out its niche's business model only to have every IP owning distribution studio try to copy it and become its competition, removing their IP from it (and any additional IP they can get exclusive licenses for) and locking it behind their own subscription model to cut out the middleman even if for the customer this means having to sign up to at least five different platforms if you want to watch every episode of the Pokemon animated series (for some reason). This is obviously enshittification for the customer and would still be so even if the individual streaming services all used the same exact pricing and business model as Netflix did a few years ago (before the price hikes, ads and measures against account sharing) - although it could be described as a monopoly being replaced by a market (which we're normally told should be a good thing).
- asoneth 3y agoMy current employer and my last were both 25+ year-old quietly successful private tech companies. In both cases there was a strong commitment to product quality in order to maintain our reputation and long-term customer relationships whereas the public companies I worked at were focused on chasing the next quarter to satisfy "the shareholders". Every once in a while I'm tempted to work for a public company again since I might be able to earn slightly more, but after working for adults for so long it'd be hard to go back to a place where my responsibilities to users and shareholders are misaligned.
- scarface_74 3y agoOut of all the major tech companies - Amazon, Apple, Google, Microsoft, Netflix, Tesla, Nvidia, etc. can you honestly say any of them are short term focused. Well it would be a stretch to say that Google has any focus.
- sirwhinesalot 3y agoYes, all of them, though not to the same extent. Microsoft and Amazon are probably the worst. Consider all the layoffs recently. Microsoft is hellbent on destroying windows if it means growth in the ads market. Amazon has let its store become a total cesspit, and look at the bullshit they pulled with prime. Youtube has 30 ads in a 3 minute video these days.
- asoneth 3y agoYes. Many of those companies have made choices that trade reputation and/or relationships built up over years to increase a quarterly profit margin. Whether that is sacrificing product quality, sunsetting well-loved products/services only to spin up similar efforts in the future, treating long-term employees poorly, burning through developer goodwill through high fees or API churn, etc. When I think about the value of long timeframes I don't just mean having a good R&D dept or throwing money at moonshots, I mean building up and maintaining goodwill with employees, customers, users, partners, developers, and regulators. Of course many private companies are run by profit-maximizing jerks and some public companies have patient shareholders who trust the company's management. But in general I have had better experiences working for an engaged owner who I can meet face-to-face over working for a crowd of shareholders and venture capitalists for whom the company is just another financial instrument in their portfolio.
- lolinder 3y ago> good public businesses > Private businesses don’t have to do anything Is this a baked-in legal distinction between public and private businesses, or is it that the company is supposed to do what the shareholders want and the shareholders of a private business are more likely than those of a public business to want something beyond ROI?
- graemep 3y agoI think very often with private companies it is not just looking beyond ROI (they may do) but they also look longer term. A shareholder whose children will inherit the business one day will have a very different outlook to one who is looking at their annual performance numbers, which is the sort thing institutional shareholders are looking at.
- collaborative 3y agoSadly, nowadays the shareholder will sell the shares and buy properties to pass on to children. Land owner is fast becoming the only profession with inter generational prospects. That's why a property crash is the only hope for a return to a normal economy (where people run businesses, develop skills, do actual work)
- gottorf 3y ago> That's why a property crash is the only hope for a return to a normal economy (where people run businesses, develop skills, do actual work) Well, let's not actively hope for a crash. Lots of normal people who run businesses, develop skills, and do actual work suffered greatly during the last property bubble of the GFC[0]. For what it's worth, outside of the major metropolises where a combination of supply restrictions (principally via zoning) and overwhelming demand (stoked by natural and economic advantages as well as policy that induces home purchases), people running businesses, developing skills, and doing actual work are able to afford to buy land and homes. My barber, for example, with no college degree and no inheritance, lives on 10 acres. The catch? It's in an area not fancied by urbane types, and his house on that land is a mobile home, though he is saving up to build a "real" one[1]. [0]: And with this, it's interesting to study the effect that government policy had on pushing loans to people who had no hope of repaying them. [1]: In many areas, building codes and zoning place a floor on the minimum price of a house, and it can be argued that this floor is too high.
- spaceribs 3y agoWorker-ownership via cooperatives is the best medicine for enshittification and oligarcy.
- adamc 3y agoIt makes sense as things are right now. It's anchored by a bunch of court decisions that arguably subvert the public interest. Do I think Shareholder value should be all that drives corporations? No. But I don't think corporations should be considered people, either.
- graemep 3y agoSo what should their aims be? Who should decide that? The shareholder's could also fire directors who did not accept the best offer? I am not familiar with the US decisions you refer to, BUT the same thing would happen in the UK, for example, where I would expect the other directors and the shareholders to ensure a really good offer was accepted.
- no_wizard 3y agoWhy not let them be what they are? The most base level definition, a corporation is simply A group of people authorized to act as a single entity and recognized as such in law. Even if you take a slightly more expansive take on that, there is nothing that inherently means a corporation should exist to maximize profit. Its minimally viable definition is pretty well understood: A legal organization of people to act as a singular entity and are recognized as such under the law, typically formed as commercial entities to transact commerce on their behalf. I don't think that misses anything. Anything piled on top of that seems like something that should be specific from business to business. Thats my general issue with the US courts siding with maximize shareholder value to the point its now seen as a decree. Especially when such rulings tend to trounce majority shareholders by minority ones.
- jorvi 3y ago> So what should their aims be? The market should decide that. And somehow, “shareholders” (what a giant tent) are currently destroying corporations and thus markets in the chase of ever higher returns. A good metaphor for a this as a whole is the Ultimate Ears Roll 2. For its time it was a really good Bluetooth speaker, punching far above its weight compared to competing Bluetooth speakers, but also within Ultimate Ears’ product line. There was almost no reason to go one or two product tiers higher. In a healthy market, the other competitors would have stepped up, and Ultimate Ears would have improved their other products to create sufficient differentiation. Instead, Ultimate Ears just discontinued the Roll 2 and replaced it with a relatively inferior product. In a rational market without shareholders this doesn’t make sense, but once you consider that the company isn’t optimizing for sales (good and/or cheap products) but for shareholder value, the picture fits.
- jampekka 3y agoA lot of people tend to not accept this plain fact that for-profits must maximize profit. It's literally illegal not to do so. https://www.wakeforestlawreview.com/2012/04/our-continuing-struggle-with-the-idea-that-for-profit-corporations-seek-profit/ https://www.wakeforestlawreview.com/2012/04/our-continuing-s...
- juped 3y agoIt's complicated, actually. Usually when you hear this it's about something management or the board or whoever wanted to do anyway.
- Bootvis 3y agoYour link is really hard to read imo and it doesn’t present an indisputed legal fact. From a quick Googling: https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/shareholder-value-purpose-corporation#:~:text=Just%20to%20be%20very%20clear,as%20serving%20shareholders'%20best%20interest https://insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/shareholder....
- duxup 3y agoI know..?
- toyg 3y agoIf it were "illegal", the State would be actively prosecuting any executive not making money. That's obviously absurd. Not maximizing shareholder value (which in itself doesn't necessarily mean profit, btw) is, at best, a breach of contract, a civil matter between private parties. Losing a civil trial doesn't mean having done something illegal. You know how people say things like "I wish the fundamentals of coding/math/financial accounting/music/whatever were actually taught in school, everyone should know them"? I wish people also got a basic understanding of legal terms.
- earthnail 3y agoNo, because the state only prosecutes criminal law and not civil law.
- 3y ago
- TylerE 3y agoIt is anecdotes like this that make me think that the public shareholder model is fundamentally flawed and a large part of why many American companies are struggling to truly build long term value, and many once great companies have been destroyed by beancounters to bleating calls of shareholder value.
- andsoitis 3y ago> public shareholder model is fundamentally flawed and a large part of why many American companies are struggling to truly build long term value This doesn’t stand up to scrutiny (there are many publicly traded companies that build immense long term value, and there are multiple reasons why companies fail to produce long-term value). It is easy to be a critic (and fine), but do you have an alternative to publicly traded companies that you think would , on balance, be better?
- tough 3y agoU just keep private and not ever get share holders if you want full control
- TylerE 3y agoHard when you "have" to give VC equity to get off the ground.
- tough 3y agodont hate the player hate the game, then
- Vicinity9635 3y agoAssuming you're using VC. It's not the only way to start a business.
- hnbad 3y agoThis is the outgrowth of a VC startup accelerator. "Startup" in these parts usually implies being VC funded, seeking VC funding or acting as if you were VC funded (i.e. growth focus rather than sustainability).
- some-guy 3y agoI know many people who joined Figma specifically because of the promise and goal of a large buyout. Even if it isn't explicitly stated, in most circumstances people want to go public at the right price.
- duxup 3y agoI believe it, I knew some folks at the company who I mentioned who left (before the acquisition) and said it was because they CEO didn't to sell. Personally I've found it never a good idea to bank on that kind of thing.
- kelnos 3y agoThose are the kinds of people you never want working for you. And, frankly, the kinds of people I hate working with. I get that for many people a job is just a job, but these sorts of people tend to be opportunists who are just there for the hope of a big payday, and will likely be a drag on you and your team while they're there.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy else would I work for a for profit company other than because they have money and I have a skill that allows me to trade my labor for money to support my addiction to food and shelter? Also, all other things being equal, why wouldn’t I trade my labor for the most money possible? That is as long as it doesn’t require working for Amazon (been there done that) or Facebook (I don’t hate myself that much).
- jhatemyjob 3y agoIts depressing how basically every tech company (except like... craigslist) is a Delaware C Corp with investors and a cap table... all these naive 20 year old technical founders getting screwed over right at the beginning when they cash that investor check. Work for FAANG for a few years, stack $500k, and bootstrap to profitability. That's the only good path
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]
- eviks 3y agoIf he liked building companies, that'd be another incentive to sell and build something else, not keeping it stable