5 ms·
Lawmakers Seeking to Outlaw Rent Price Fixing Reported by Propublica
- toomuchtodo 3y agoTitle adjusted from "We Found That Landlords Could Be Using Algorithms to Fix Rent Prices. Now Lawmakers Want to Make the Practice Illegal." due to title character limits.
- mc32 3y agoPrice fixing of this kind as well as the rent control kind should all be outlawed. Government should pay the diff, if they want to subsidize grandma and grandpa or low level service job workers in their apartments --and I am for subsidies for people how do need them; I just don't think rent control is a good instrument. Arguably rent control is a soft form of expropriation. Governments can pass taxes and build/buy, if they like.
- philipov 3y agoBecause price caps cause shortages? Subsidies are just a scheme to funnel taxes to landlords: bad idea. If you want to avoid using price caps, then you gotta flood the supply with cheep housing to crater the market instead. I think landowners are going to fight that even harder than landlords fight rent control.
- samatman 3y agoBecause there's no such thing as a price cap. This applies to rent controls as much as it does to "gouging" laws. An imposed maximum price which is below the market-clearing rate just means that some of the cost has to be paid in a different way. With apartments this is often information, you have to be in the know to get a chance to rent. Sometimes it's just illegally charging the difference between the rent controlled price and the market price: if you won't pay it, someone else will. Or you get a second mini-landlord, someone rents at the artificially-low rate and subleases the apartment at market rate. For rent "stabilization", which is rent control lite, the cost is paid with friction (people who would move but can't because they're paying below market), scarcity, and (as a consequence of that scarcity) higher prices when the landlord is finally free to charge market rates. But you can't just defeat market pricing by fiat, it just doesn't work.
- Retric 3y agoThe article makes it clear this isn’t about rent control. The concern is market manipulation via artificially reducing supply and similar tactics not the government picking a price. Collusion is far easier with housing because nobody can flood the market so you don’t need every participant to agree. In Seattle, for example, ProPublica found that 10 property managers oversaw 70% of all multifamily apartments in one neighborhood — and every single one used pricing software sold by RealPage. “Setting prices with an algorithm is no different from doing it over cigars and whiskey in a private club,”
- worik 3y ago> But you can't just defeat market pricing by fiat, it just doesn't work. True But there is still a lot city and national governments can do. "Rent control" should not mean simply "cap rents". It means having a richer set of criteria for allocation accommodation units than a market with price, and ability to pay
- Retric 3y agoIt’s outlawing collusion via algorithmic adjustments not setting a specific price. “A group of senators are set to introduce legislation Tuesday that would make it illegal for landlords to use algorithms to artificially inflate the price of rent or reduce the supply of housing.”
- MSFT_Edging 3y ago> Protect the landlord's profit at all cost Why should the gov subsidize the landlord in order to allow people to not be homeless? The market rate is too high, sorry landlords.
- mc32 3y agoBecause presumably it's your property and they are interfering with market prices. If the gov wants to make them free they can, if they buy your property and through taxes make it available to indigent people. That's not something you should shoulder.
- MSFT_Edging 3y agoIts a bad investment, they should sell at a loss and find something else to do.
- itake 3y agoLandlords have the opposite problem on the west coast: Instead of the gov subsidizing landlords, private landlords subsidize the government. The rental protections give renters a softer landing for non-payment on the landlord’s dime. Landlords literally have to pay tenants to leave. The "cash for keys" money comes from the backs of future tenants. Also, for most of the usa now, it is cheaper to rent than buy. My mortgage, taxes, and insurance is way beyond what I could rent my house for. It makes zero sense to create more rental properties.
- mikeyouse 3y agoEh.. in California at least, most landlords are being massively subsidized by Prop 13 related shenanigans. At my last apartment in SF, my landlord's property tax bill was less than 1 month of my rent (less than $3k annual) -- I was shopping for similar homes and my property taxes would have been closer to $20k annually. Multi-unit buildings were way worse since they can be transferred creatively without reseting the property tax assessment. Just picking on a random building in my old neighborhood but 498 Carl in the Inner Sunset of SF is a 6-unit rental building - at least 3 of the units have turned over in the past few years and were rented for over $3k each. Total property taxes due on this 6,000sq ft building which is netting the owner more than $150k in rent are $6,800 annually. https://sanfrancisco-ca.county-taxes.com/public/property_tax/accounts/1265-015?qid=89768972d3905eb5e36e92dc14c0a1f0 https://sanfrancisco-ca.county-taxes.com/public/property_tax... Across the street a nice 1,700sq ft SFH which sold in 2021 -- property taxes on this house are $20,000 annually. https://sanfrancisco-ca.county-taxes.com/public/property_tax/accounts/1750-042?qid=85dd0a746a5e47a345687b9b64f6a583 https://sanfrancisco-ca.county-taxes.com/public/property_tax...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- standardUser 3y agoMany rent control implementations are fairly extreme and you end up with people paying $400/mo for a $4000/mo unit. What we need is better rent control, wherein prices are capable of rising to market rates gradually, but are not allowed to spike in ways that destabilize families and neighborhoods. We also need laws mandating 2-year rent increase notices and multi-year lease options.
- lumb63 3y agoWait until people figure out this is going on for salaries as well… I don’t see how this is any different from what companies do with data they but from, e.g. PayScale.
- mikeyouse 3y agoWe use salary bands from these types of companies when hiring -- which isn't at all what's happening here. This would be more equivalent to Google + Amazon + Facebook + Apple all hiring e.g. engineers with 5-years experience and then making them a "take it or leave it" offer at the same precise dollar amount as determined by PayScale. Paying market rate is much different than forming a pricing cartel with a loosely "3rd party" tool serving as your cover.
- pphysch 3y agoThis sounds like a bandaid fix. How do you disambiguate between really active price discovery, and price fixing. I believe the current situation is closer to the latter, but the solution is making historical housing data more transparent, especially for tenants. The current "price discovery" mechanism is more or less "whatever those desperate suckers looking for housing are willing to pay". That's ripe for abuse. There needs to be more feedback from the tenants and public administration. The government should require all housing units on the market to be registered in a public database that requires details about vacancy, price history, detailed corporate ownership, major maintenance/disaster history, possibly prior (anonymized) tenant reviews, etc. Otherwise the information asymmetry will continue to drastically favor the property managers, regardless of the extent price fixing is prohibited.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheGlav 3y agoIt's not so much that they're "Fixing" prices, but that so many companies/businesses are all using the same algorithm. Man, if only they knew how many industries do this exact same thing. Services like this exist for just about every market, from housing price estimation, to salaries, to magic the gathering cards. What they're effectively saying is that "Services that estimate rent prices should be illegal." OK. Good luck with that.
- Retric 3y agoNormally this is self correcting. In most markets when a single participant defects from a cartel they can flood the market. When 70% or housing is under control of a single pice of software the other 30% can’t flood the market.
- jcrben 3y agoIt's also affected by the fundamental barriers to entry in offering a competing product - homes don't get built quickly and people can't move that easily.
- treffer 3y agoIt's not that. It's basically the old question: can algorithms format cartels? I am strongly on the side of: yes, they can. In a time where most offerings are public you just need to make sure you stay slightly above the p50 and prices will go up. Similarly on the buying side of e.g. Ads most algorithms and platforms have a "bidding war avoidance". Stop bidding more even of it would make you money, in order to keep the proce low. In all those cases you try to sync and rise /lower the price (as seller/buyer). It's not about just estimating a price. It is doing that on a large scale with an algorithmic outcome of upwards price fixation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 3y ago
- rufus_foreman 3y agoThey are looking at what competitors are charging before setting their own prices. That should be illegal? Does anyone think that software developers should be prohibited by law from looking at what other software developers are charging before deciding how much money to ask for? I don't believe that. Why would it be illegal for landlords to do it? The article shows no evidence of price fixing. It shows companies doing absolutely normal things that every company does in order to determine what price to charge. Yes, that means looking at what other companies charge for the same service. Yes, for landlords it sometimes makes sense to accept a higher vacancy rate in exchange for higher rents. Sometimes it would also make sense to accept a lower vacancy rate in exchange for lower rents. Yes, landlords are going to want to look at market data to determine what the vacancy rate is that makes them the most money.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- notaustinpowers 3y ago> They are looking at what competitors are charging before setting their own prices. That should be illegal? That practice isn't what's illegal. What people are having issues with is that RealPage which is used by a large number of landlords (from private landlords to megacorps), recommends prices to the landlords when it comes to marketing a unit. This data is pulled from other rentals on the market and what other RealPage users are charging. A majority of the time, landlords just use that number to advertise. That's why some apartment communities have prices that change daily, since RealPage changes their numbers daily. As such, this is a roundabout way of price fixing as RealPage is in a position that artificially raises rents across a wide location range. This isn't a case of companies looking at what other companies charge for the same service. This is one company that's comparing their pricing against themselves. This results in cases such as a primarily affordable apartment community can see rents shoot up $300-$400/month all because a luxury apartment opened on the other side of town and both management companies just so happen to use RealPage. It's removing relevant comparisons from the actual pricing schedule, which in some cases can be seen as price fixing as the prices no longer reflect the actual market.
- Ekaros 3y agoWhy not actually mandate that rent prices are public information? At least for participants in such sharing schemes. That is both renters and rentees would get the information of current rents of comparable units. Then they can make educated choices on both sides?
- notaustinpowers 3y agoThis is something that I've been wanting to try to implement within my local government, but there's just no easily enforceable way to do so. The agreements are private, so what information should be shared? How can this information be verified? What are the punishments for not complying? Who will enforce the punishments? Is it a self-report database? Unfortunately, many of these questions are something that no local government wants to tackle or even attempt to enforce. Especially when we get into the more under-the-counter transactions like Mike paying Bob $500/month to live in his basement with a handshake agreement. Maybe a self-report online database could be beneficial, but then the concern becomes getting users, ensuring the information is fresh and routinely updated, etc. Not even taking profitability into consideration.
- zie 3y agoWe managed to do it with health care (well OK we are still in the rolling out period), but it's slowly happening.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoTo a degree, yes, but the healthcare industry is also obfuscating the data as best as it can. Such as using proprietary codes instead of procedure names. Yes, the data is there, but unless you work at that specific hospital and understand their codes, it's essentially useless. It could happen, but with how effective NIMBYs are on a local government level, and how strong of a hold NAR has in federal lobbying, I can see any legitimate legislation dying before they even come to a vote.
- 3y ago
- interactivecode 3y agoPerhaps we should have a system where there is a basic level of housing available for anyone to afford. And anyone who wants something with any luxuries can rent something from a business / landlord? That way private landlords can run their business how they want, and if a customer sees value in what they offer they can pay for it.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> we should have a system where there is a basic level of housing available for anyone to afford There is plenty of cheap land in the middle of the country. The problem is getting (and wanting to get) there.
- OkayPhysicist 3y agoIt's a cyclical problem: There are no jobs worth moving for in most of the middle of the country, which means no one wants to move there, which means that there's no workforce for big companies, which means there's no jobs worth moving for. Likewise for social scenes, services, etc., It's the same feedback loop that makes the existing big cities attractive. Good jobs bring people with skills and money, which support services and provide a labor pool for companies that want to hire, which provides a glut of good jobs.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoAgree completely. My point is the problem isn't "housing available for anyone to afford," it's affordable housing in Tier 1 cities.
- angmarsbane 3y agoIt’s can’t reasonably afford shelter within a reasonable commute of jobs that require you to be in the area.
- arcbyte 3y agoIve been playing with the math on usong Pareto distributions to provide universal rental assistance. A city could require reporting yearly of all rent prices as part of licensing. Then levy a tax on the 20% most expensive apartments that is sufficient to allow the distribution of that fund to renters in the bottom 20% of income. Or some such scheme. It should provide a strong disincentive on very expensive apartments while allowing the most vulnerable population to live comfortably in 80% of the city's rental offerings.
- jeffbee 3y agoThe underlying belief here seems to be that if you inhibit price discovery, prices will be lower. There is no evidence of this. Slow price discovery can just as easily set a too-high price. There is plenty of evidence of that.
- jlhawn 3y agoIt seems they'll do anything but tax land values
- dantheman 3y agoI'd bet they'd support land value taxes before they allow new construction.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoThe root problem is that we allow vacancies. People can't just choose to not live somewhere and participate in the housing market. Vacancies allow renters to take advantage of this asymmetry by limiting market supply. They are naturally empowered to do this, because participation is inherently guaranteed. Renters don't even have to coordinate this behavior: it's a shared goal already (to maximize the price each asset, while minimizing the number of total assets that are sold/rented), which means this pattern will emerge naturally from any efficient real estate market. Like other commenters have recognized, this system can be compared to contract work. A contracted engineer can choose to allocate any arbitrary amount of her time to not working. This is a desirable pattern, because a person not working is a desirable outcome. In real estate, it's an undesirable pattern because a vacant home is an undesirable outcome.