3 ms·
Maybe people have been gaslit into thinking that being an ""elite"" is somehow a word of shame rather than something one should be proud of? Anyway, all this c
by pjc50 3y ago
Maybe people have been gaslit into thinking that being an ""elite"" is somehow a word of shame rather than something one should be proud of?
Anyway, all this comes down to power, both in terms of market power and the social relations between manager and employee. The elite knowledge workers have something that is a critical factor of production for many businesses. Since this thing - knowledge, a form of fixed capital - exists inside the human mind and is extremely time-consuming to transfer, it has to be leased from the employees. Since it's in relatively short supply that commands a high price.
But that scarcity also converts into other forms of market power: the ability to set non-monetary conditions of sale on the knowledge.
This upsets the social relations of the office, because managers are used to being able to micromanage and physically surveil subordinates. The idea that an employee can set boundaries radically upsets American managers. Next people will be asking for holiday.
The reverse of this is of course at the very bottom end of the market: if your boss can change your shift pattern at the last minute, if you're on a so-called "zero hours" contract, then that's because you're deemed utterly replaceable and have no market power.
- vidanay 3y agoAnd yet so many people practically worship the concept of elite athletes, or elite actors, or elite musicians.
- ben_w 3y agoThe concept, yes; the word? I've seen the phrase "elite athletes", but never "elite actors" or "elite musicians". For a different example of that split, there are a lot of proud religious fundamentalists in the USA, it was only the decade following 9/11 that "fundamentalist" seemed to be a dirty word (from my perspective, which at that point was going through university and my first job, both in the UK).
- pjc50 3y ago.. and another thing: although I work in an office some of the week, my boss^2 works in a different city and the parent company including people I work with frequently is in a different country in a different timezone. I can't not be remote from some people, because we're spread out. Building a massive office, getting visas, and paying staff enough to afford to live within commuting radius of a particular city in the western United States is very expensive.
- candiodari 3y agoI think this site just has a seriously warped view of what "elite" means. To everyone it seems to mean something like "people with 2x your wealth or more". Great, but a more reasonable definition of elite would be akin to, "top 10%": 1) any higher degree => elite 2) $150k or more family income => elite (and this is only counting people being paid a monthly wage for at least, I believe, 4 months of the year, otherwise it's $89k to get you into the top 10%, this is definitely not all Americans) And if you count worldwide ... let's just not go there. Take off multiple zeroes. So it is not about manager vs non-manager. I think you'll find managers don't have much decision making power anyway. It is not about directors or CEOs or people who own companies. Elite is nearly everyone that reads this site.