4 ms·
Fails to simulate the speed of light, at least from what I can tell. Should be some million years ago civilization starts, lives for thousands of years, goes e
by bluGill 3y ago
Fails to simulate the speed of light, at least from what I can tell.
Should be some million years ago civilization starts, lives for thousands of years, goes extinct - but we never become aware of them. Most never send signals (radio or otherwise) strong enough for us to detect. Others did, but the signal hasn't reached us yet. Still others did, but the signals passed by before we developed the ability to detect them. Still others are reaching us now, but are so far below the noise floor we can't detect them.
The universe is large. You have to account for how slow the speed of light is when talking about the Fermi paradox.
- zamadatix 3y agoI wonder how much that changes the final probability. I think the biggest piece is instead of both able to detect each other only one will (the other will probably be dead by the time the information gets back the other way) which halves the chances of detecting another civilization. Beyond that, given sufficiently short civilization lifespans vs the age of the universe they can randomly appear in and a relatively uniform rate of random occurrence, I don't think "a random civilization appeared x years ago x light years away for the timing to work out" actually ends up being any less likely than "a random civilization appeared at the same time". It feels like it should but really if you just take the chance it'd happen normally and say "well, there is an equal chance a civilization could have developed x years prior" you correct for the time for traversing the distance without changing the probability. The main thing the speed of light prevents is a single civilization staying together as a galaxy sized empire.
- Vox_Leone 3y ago>The main thing the speed of light prevents is a single civilization staying together as a galaxy sized empire. It seems to me that, in principle, a ruling class could set itself apart from humanity and conduct the business of a galactic government -- ahem, a galactic enlightened dictatorship, with its own timing. For example, Alice and Bob live on Trantor, and are employees of the Galactic Federation. They constantly travel [at the same fractions of the speed of light] to clusters located in different galactic hemispheres, and, thanks to almost identical rates of time dilation in their [perhaps carefully chosen] travels, they meet every weekend of their proper time. They live happily as a family in the headquarters of the government, to the rhythm of the passing of countless generations on the myriad planets of the federation.
- zamadatix 3y agoThe main issue with this is a week to the traveller crossing the galaxy near the speed of light still requires civilization to stay together for 100,000 years without them. The second issue is it's not as attractive as it sounds. Travelling 1/10th the galaxy in a proper time of 5 days requires a trip of a constant 2400 G's. Maybe solvable once your civilization has already overcome the Fermi paradox (probably don't need bodies at that point) though.
- UncleOxidant 3y agoExactly. Life may not be unusual in the universe. But technologically advanced civilizations could be rare enough that we don't detect them due to distances in space and time.
- goatlover 3y agoFermi wasn’t talking about detection when he came up with the paradox. There was no SETI yet. He did a back of the napkin calculation that a civilization could colonize the galaxy in 1 to 100 million years with sublight speeds. The galaxy is much older than 100 million years, so where is everyone? There’s been plenty of time for many civilizations to show up here.