4 ms·
I liked Udacity best at first, but after a while found myself spending a lot more time with Coursera. Mainly for two reasons: - Udacity sometimes belabors some
by DennisP 15y ago
I liked Udacity best at first, but after a while found myself spending a lot more time with Coursera. Mainly for two reasons:
- Udacity sometimes belabors some really basic points. Coursera never gives me that "dumbed-down" feeling. It's more like a real, and challenging, college course.
- Coursera lets me speed up the lecture, as much as 2x, and every time I go to a new lecture it remembers that speed. I managed to speed up Udacity lectures by going to html5 in youtube, but I had to reset it every time I started a new 2-minute segment.
- Alex3917 15y ago"Udacity sometimes belabors some really basic points. Coursera never gives me that 'dumbed-down' feeling. It's more like a real, and challenging, college course." I think this actually may be Udacity's biggest strength. It's a lot more hands on than a college course, which makes it somewhat easier. But do you actually learn less? After thinking about it, I really don't think so. With your average college CS class they spend a few minutes talking about some problem, and then you spend a week on your own working on it. Whereas with Udacity they actually teach you all the concepts you need to solve the problem, and then you work through it together step by step. The strength of the traditional college approach is that it teaches you to be resourceful to some extent. But this comes at an enormous cost. You basically spend all week writing shitty code and trying to make it compile just to learn at best one or two concepts. Whereas with Udacity they are actually teaching you how to write quality code, but you still have to do the most challenging parts of the algorithm yourself. (And these aren't trivial, they often take several hours.) Clearly at some point you do need to learn to fly yourself, but with Udacity at least you can wait until you're up to speed on the basic tools rather than being shoved out of the nest on day one. Even if it seems dumbed down, I'm completely convinced that you're actually learning much more this way than what you learn in the traditional CS classroom. And after all, the measure of a class shouldn't be how hard or easy it is, but rather how much you learn from it.
- DennisP 15y agoI like the short cycles and quick bits of programming, especially given that they've also got the weekly homeworks. I'm just saying that sometimes they move too slowly for my taste. Let me run the videos at high speed without hassle, and that'll help. I can slow down when I need to, and speed through the parts I already get. (I've found that at high speed, having to concentrate a bit just to understand the words helps keep me focused.) Ultimately, maybe we'll end up with classes that have several levels of explanation, letting you pick which you think best suits you for that particular piece...maybe for one part a quick presentation of an equation is sufficient, and for a less familiar part you want a step-by-step walkthrough with lots of intuitive explanation.
- minikomi 15y agoHmm. Telescopic lectures ala http://www.telescopictext.com/ http://www.telescopictext.com/ .. You get a short explanation, some tests, and if you get below a certain score, they go into a more detailed explanation.
- brown9-2 15y agoBeing able to speed up the lectures is a huge nice-to-have.
- dfc 15y agoYou do know you can speed things up in vlc? VLC also does a great job of keeping the pitch accurate.
- hacman 15y agoI'm going through the Coursera machine learning class right now and I have to say that the professor glosses over several details and often makes comments like "if you're not familiar with calculus..." and "if you're not familiar with statistics..." which caught me off guard at first. I really doubt that actual Stanford students enrolled in a machine learning course would be lost on the incredibly basic operations (e.g., taking the partial derivative of a polynomial function) he is using. Also, there has been no acknowledgement of how contrived the exercises are. For instance: exercise one gives a data set of a the profitability of a company's existing stores versus the population size of the city in which the store is located (in units of 10,000 dollars and people, respectively). The range of the data is 5-23 (population), with most of it concentrated below 10. We fit a straight line to the data using least squares, then use that line to predict the profitability of two new locations--in cities of populations 35 and 75. I understand that this is an intro course, but there is not a word about how ridiculous this is. I don't mean to be overly negative. I am enjoying the course, but I am surprised a bit by how basic it is. Let me say that I do like the approach of the course to ML, which is to formulate a parameterized cost function and then minimize it by some general method, rather than the typical statistics course approach which is to solve ordinary least squares directly, which gives an "exact solution" (given the data) but does not generalize to more general models. I know this is foundational material and overall, I am impressed by the approach of the course, but I would expect more comments on the weakness of the naïve methods we are employing at this early stage and how they will eventually be improved. I find it very helpful when professors at least reference more advanced methods or provide references for further reading by the interested student. Admittedly, that is more frequently a feature of graduate courses, but encouraging students to go beyond the material is an important aspect of good teaching. I have watched the videos for several other online courses and I do appreciate the fact that Coursera is allowing me to hand in assignments for grading, which vastly increases by engagement with the material. This, in fact, is the most valuable resource offered by the program. The lectures themselves are fine--if a bit dry--but a good book or a set of well-prepared notes (not slides) would probably suffice just as well if accompanied by the assignment grader. All in all, this is great. The more people who know about machine learning (and have access to higher education in general), the better.
- 15y ago