6 ms·
Could our Universe be a simulation? How would we even tell?
- vardump 3y agoWould it really even matter? Is there anything you'd do differently if we're conclusively determined to live in a simulation?
- pilaf 3y agoPerhaps not you or I, but collectively wouldn't we want to try to communicate with those outside running the simulation?
- deadbabe 3y agoIf sentient NPCs in a game wanted to communicate with you, what would you do about it? Say “interesting”, then turn off the app and go to sleep?
- xenadu02 3y agoNo way. What if those beings considered the simulation tainted and shut it down as a result? Not that this definition of simulation matches what most people think when this question gets asked. The answer is no you can't tell no matter how hard you try. Quantum behaviors should be enough proof that our reality can act way outside our sense of things at very small scales. Any kind of "eureka!" claims about our universe being a simulation can more easily be explained as it just being how our universe works and of course it doesn't line up with human common-sense notions of causality/physics/etc. And not that it is even an interesting question but my take is no this is not a simulation. Way too much detail. Even if some civilization had the resources to run a simulation the size of our universe it would be a massive waste to do so. The most efficient computational system for simulating a universe with the high fidelity our universe has is to create a universe and let it evolve.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago> No way. What if those beings considered the simulation tainted and shut it down as a result? That's just as plausible as those beings waiting for us to evolve our present level of understanding, and shutting down the simulation out of disappointment that we didn't try to contact them, or hack our way out of it. This whole discussion - not just the one we're having, but probably most discussions on this topic, here on HN and elsewhere - is the nerd equivalent of trying to figure out how many angels can dance on the head of a pin.
- rightbyte 3y ago> trying to figure out how many angels can dance on the head of a pin Wasn't that a parady of silly theological questions in general? Or maybe a "it doesn't matter" analogy? The nerd discussion on this sim question is totally serious. Edit: Oh. Ye. There is no upper limit on the size of a needle, so there is no upper limit on the amount of angles that can dance on its tip no matter their size, if they can intersect or what not. Anyhow, at least one, should cover any set of boundary values to the problem.
- pavel_lishin 3y ago> The nerd discussion on this sim question is totally serious. Yes, but just as likely to result in a useful outcome as trying to count angels. What I'm trying to say is that unless someone in this discussion is maybe a high-energy particle physicist, or astrophysicist, all we're really doing is the equivalent of trying to deduce what happened to the Holy Prepuce, or what Hermione Granger's canonical ethnicity is. Which isn't to say that it's not a fun thing to talk about; but we should recognize that we're just sitting around the fire with a couple of beers and bullshitting, and that we can't make any really definitive statements here. We're at the Greek Philosophy level of being able to talk about this stuff - all thought experiments without much actual data.
- pilaf 3y ago> And not that it is even an interesting question but my take is no this is not a simulation. Way too much detail. Even if some civilization had the resources to run a simulation the size of our universe it would be a massive waste to do so. The most efficient computational system for simulating a universe with the high fidelity our universe has is to create a universe and let it evolve. I also don't think we live in a simulation, but if we did, how can you know anything about the outside universe, leave alone its resource limitations? Perhaps what we consider to be huge and complex (our own universe) is the equivalent of a simple Conway's Game of Life to the outside world.
- mikub 3y agoLike those Star Trek Holodeck episodes whith doctor Moriarty where he becomes aware that he's only an hologram. I always find it fascinating to think about that, when we would be living in an simulation, they could shut the whole thing down for let's say 1 million years, turn it back on and for us it would be like nothing ever happened. Like, I sit here write this comment, in the middle of it they shut it down, wait for "a while" to power it back on, and I wouldnt even know. :)
- mettamage 3y agoThey could be doing that every millisecond too. Maybe in their time, a millisecond takes 1 year. We wouldn't know.
- corobo 3y agoI would dedicate my life to trying to find how to open the console
- MightyBuzzard 3y ago[dead]
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIf by simulation one means 'a systematic application of laws/rules through time' then it's a tautology to say that we are in something like a simulation by the mere fact that there exists the laws of physics. The more interesting question is where are the laws of physics located? How does an electron 'read' their rules?
- Buttons840 3y agoIf our universe is a simulation, we're presumably the focus, or at least a result worthy of attention. If some Gods able to see all of our universe could inspect, say, an entire galaxy, or a single microbe on Earth, they'd probably find the microbe on Earth more interesting. Even the simplest life is more interesting than all the rest of the universe, and all available evidence suggests Earth has the only life.
- lanna 3y ago> all available evidence suggests Earth has the only life Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence
- postingawayonhn 3y agoThere is evidence though. We've been using telescopes and listening to radio waves for decades but are yet to find anything substantial. We can at least conclude complex life is exceedingly rare.
- ethanbond 3y agoNo, you can conclude that there aren’t any immediately discernible radio signals pointed our way in our rather extremely small space-time vicinity.
- O1111OOO 3y ago> We've been using telescopes and listening to radio waves for decades but are yet to find anything substantial. To add to what @ethanbond said about space-time vicinity: --------------- Article, subTitle: We have been broadcasting for over 100 years. Now a new 3D map of the galaxy reveals the stars these signals have reached that can also see Earth: https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/our-radio-signals-have-now-reached-75-star-systems-that-can-see-us-too https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/our-radio-sign... “1,715 stars within 326 light-years are in the right position to have spotted life on a transiting Earth since early human civilization, with an additional 319 stars entering this special vantage point in the next 5,000 years,” they say. ----------------------- A microscopically small amount given the total number of stars in our own galaxy, the total number of galaxies in the Universe.
- Kaibeezy 3y agoHas “no way to tell the difference” been settled?
- tlb 3y agoThere are several proposals, like looking for anisotropy in physics as evidence of a grid coordinate system. Perhaps some day a more precise measurement will find something, but not yet.
- bediger4000 3y agoI'm pretty sure the answer there is "no". I've heard of a couple of methods that are almost purely computational: Measure the randomness of something like radioactive decay, try to figure out the PRNG used in the simulation. Measure all those very basic constants of the universe to a large number of decimal points. See if they indicate register size of the simulator.
- Geee 3y agoWe can tell by looking at the beginning. It looks like this universe started from nothing, but this is not possible, unless it's a simulation. Therefore, this universe can't be a 'top-level' universe. However, it's a different question whether this is a 'simulation created by conscious beings' or a 'natural simulation', e.g. some kind of natural process in a different kind of universe which somehow results in a simulation of our universe. 'Conscious being simulation' theory is just kicking the can further, rather than solving the origin problem, if we assume that their universe is similar to us.
- munchler 3y agoIf starting from nothing isn’t possible, how did the top-level universe start?
- Geee 3y agoYes, I forgot to add that there must a type of universe which can start from nothing, or exists always. Otherwise this argument doesn't make sense.
- fluoridation 3y agoYou're contradicting yourself. If there can exist universes that can start from nothing and are not simulated then this universe could have started from nothing and not be simulated.
- Geee 3y agoNo. We know the laws of this universe (not perfectly yet of course). However, as far as we know, it seems that those laws don't allow it to be created from nothing. A top-level universe must have different laws. It must be something completely different than our universe. Something that allows it to either always exist or be created from nothing.
- fluoridation 3y ago
- deadbabe 3y agoThe 1/137 constant is probably the key to figuring out the simulation.
- TwoNineA 3y agoI liked this take by Neil deGrasse Tyson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmcrG7ZZKUc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmcrG7ZZKUc
- gerad 3y agoIf we’re in a simulation and that simulation is advanced enough for our ancestors to build a simulation of the simulation - at what point does the recursion break down?
- imp0cat 3y agoIf it's like VT-x then building another simulation in a simulation which is already in another simulation should break it down - or at least run really slow. :)
- deepfriedchokes 3y agoWhat if it’s a circular paradox and it’s simulations all the way round?
- mjburgess 3y agoThere's a class of propositions we could call "effect-indistinguishable" which can have no possible effects which distinguish between their truth and falsehood (eg., that a god exists with no spatiotemporal location and no causal effects, etc.). If these are true, they do have genuine implications (eg., a world with such a god is different than one without). However, I shortcut all this with a simple meta-epistemic principle: I will never believe one of those propositions on the basis that it could never be rational to do so. I take it is the most rational belief in this case is simply to presume they're all false, since there are an infinite number and i think some argument can be made that theyre certainly largely false since most are contradictory (etc.) So, no the universe is not a simulation; nor a dream of a demon; nor one of any of these propositions. If you think it is, then why not draw randomly from a similar set? Why not the wish of an alien honoured by a angel? These kinds of propositions are "failure modes" of rational thinking that cannot be addressed in their own framing (consider, by analogy, "is the king of the US bald?"). The response has to be about what it means to think at all, to believe something is true, and so on. This is also how to address conspiracy theories. The issue with them is their belief in classes of propositions of this kind (eg., that all "official" claims are false).
- fluoridation 3y ago>There's a class of propositions we could call "effect-indistinguishable" which can have no possible effects which distinguish between their truth and falsehood (eg., that a god exists with no spatiotemporal location and no causal effects, etc.). >If these are true, they do have genuine implications (eg., a world with such a god is different than one without). What? Which one is it?
- mjburgess 3y agoThings can be true without having any distinguishable effects. To believe otherwise is to confuse epistemology and ontology.
- tlb 3y agoAn argument against simulation is that our universe seems gratuitously large. Why have billions of whole other galaxies in it? Given a finite computing budget, you'd expect whoever's running the simulation to want to simulate more planets with civilization and fewer giant dust clouds. If it is a simulation, it must be doing some very clever lazy evaluation to avoid thinking about every quark in every atom in every star in every galaxy, while still producing results that astronomers can't distinguish from physics on earth.
- Gualdrapo 3y ago> you'd expect whoever's running the simulation to want to simulate more planets with civilization and fewer giant dust clouds. How so? What if the goal of whoever is running said simulation is something else besides simulating life and civilizations or whatnot, and we are here because an unexpected result?
- tlb 3y agoIf it were me, as soon as I found a civilization in my simulation, I'd shut down all the dust clouds and run many versions of the civilization. The big limitation of studying our civilization from the inside is that we only see one path, so it's hard to tell what parts of history were inevitable vs. accidental. In a sim, you could fork 100 copies of earth starting from 1900 and watch all kinds of different futures unfold. We can't know for sure what would interest simulation runners, but they must come from a technological civilization and would presumably find other civilizations more interesting than dust clouds.
- SAI_Peregrinus 3y agoWho's to say that they don't have plenty of other simulations for simulating civilizations, and we're not just an unintended side effect in a dust cloud research sim?
- ianburrell 3y ago“Why does all this life keep showing up when I’m trying to simulate dark matter clouds. I’m this close to restarting with the parameters tweaked.”
- block_dagger 3y agoThe finale Futurama episode deals with this very topic. Well worth a watch.
- nocoiner 3y agoWhat does a holophonor opera have to do with this? Just kidding. Futurama must hold some kind of record for sheer number of series finales.
- mangecoeur 3y agoPhilosophically the question is not much different than “do we only exist in the mind of a deity”. It’s impossible to determine (since any search for “proof” would rely on assumptions about this external reality that are impossible to demonstrate), has no impact on our reality, mostly makes for some amusing procrastination.
- slibhb 3y agoYou can't disprove it but if the Deity in question lifted you into his world and allowed you to experience it, I'd say that would constitute proof.
- tbrownaw 3y agoIs it actually any better proof of anything than what people see under the influence of psychedelics?
- jstanley 3y agoThat's about as easy as lifting an NPC out of a video game and allowing them to experience reality.
- phantompeace 3y agoIn a reality where every one was experiencing Virtual Reality, it doesn't seem so far fetched to think about what it would be like for a "headset" to switch off temporarily. In our case, the "headset" could be something in the brain. There are too many quantum fuckeries going on within neurons (and plants, for that matter) for me to fully rule this out.
- fluoridation 3y agoHow could you distinguish being pulled out of the universe from being transported to a different part of it? If you're able to experience it, how could you know it's not an experience that's possible within the universe?
- mg 3y agoIs there any proof that the universe is bigger than what I experience right now? For example: My eyes can focus on this word on my screen: "Hello". I don't know how many bits of information this word contains. I can see the shape of the four chars quite clearly. Maybe that is 100 bits of information or so? So I would say the universe probably is at least 100 bits large. Is there any proof that it is larger? Is there any way it could be smaller?
- fluoridation 3y agoCan the universe read your mind? If it can, then the universe need not be larger than your own mind plus some comparatively small constant. When you're done reading this sentence and focus back to "Hello" you'll notice that its appearance and location are consistent with what was on your mind, so it's possible that there's some machinery reconstructing the previous state of what you were perceiving so it matches your memory. If it can't read your mind then the universe external to it must necessarily be much larger, since it can consistently hold much more information than you're able to recall.
- mg 3y agoYou bring up the concept of time. But is there a proof that time exists? I can "remember" something, but that act of "remembering" is happening in the now. I don't know if there really was a past. When I look at "Hello", I don't remember something at the same time. The shape of the four "Hello" letters are all I can hold in my mind. So from that perspective, "Hello" might be all there is and all there has ever been.
- phantompeace 3y agoIs there even a "now"? Our neurons add milliseconds to every signal impulse that allows us to experience the "now" (that's not to mention the time it takes for the brain to process everything). We're perpetually experiencing the past whilst moving through space.
- fluoridation 3y ago
- jstanley 3y agoHere's a point I always try to bring up whenever a "simulated universe" discussion comes up. I hope it is clear because I feel people often miss what I'm trying to say: If the universe can be evaluated in a simulation, then the computer carrying out the simulation is not actually necessary. In fact, even defining the rules of the universe is not necessary, because the contents of the universe with any given set of rules are not changed by the act of writing the rules down. Mathematical truths are true, even if they're never discovered. If a universe can be simulated, then it has a mathematical description, which means all of its configurations, and all of the events within it, are determined from the mathematical description. (As an inhabitant of the universe, you may experience non-determinism, but this is because you are limited to experiencing one path at a time. For example, you can make a mathematical model of the outcomes if you flip a coin 20 times in a row, and even though the outcome of any given path is non-deterministic, all of the possible observations are determined purely by the rules, and all are equally true regardless of how many times you flip the coin, or whether you even bother flipping the coin at all). By analogy to Conway's game of life: The outcome of any given configuration in Conway's game of life is fully decided regardless of whether anyone actually runs the simulation, regardless of whether anyone writes down the rules, regardless of whether anyone even thinks of the rules. The outcomes of Conway's game of life didn't become decided at the point that the first simulation was executed. The outcomes were always there. No observer inside Conway's game of life has an experience or lack of experience due to the simulation being evaluated on a computer. Evaluating the simulation has no effect on the outcome. Evaluating the simulation allows someone outside the simulated universe to inspect its state, but it has no effect whatsoever on the observers inside the simulated universe. They were there all along. The observations made by observers inside the simulated universe are decided by the specification of the universe, and are the same regardless of whether there is any computer outside the simulation actually evaluating it. All of this is to say that IF our universe can be simulated, then we don't need the simulator. The fact that it can be simulated is enough to create all of our experiences. And in fact I think this is the "true" explanation (whatever that means) of why the universe came to be: we exist just because mathematics says we can. (And, further: every possible universe "exists" - as far as the observers inside it are concerned - and every possible experience is experienced).
- 3y ago
- rcbdev 3y agoSurprised they didn't mention the Bekenstein bound. It has clear implications on how to calculate the amount of information contained within a 3D volume of space in our universe and how that maps to other dimensionalities. I've even heard it stated by physicists that the Bekenstein bound helps to prove the feasibility of constructing a simulation of a universe within the size of our universe - but alas, I am not a physicist and this is merely armchair conjecture.
- nurettin 3y agoYou could make something up like: Simulations as we know them have limitations. Given those limitations, things like recursion require more processing power than simulating a bouncy ball. And if we can detect slowdowns, or a higher state of energy simply by going between two mirrors, we could count it as evidence towards a simulated existence. Of course this is all conjecture, and assumes that there is no effort to conceal the facts, but at least it is a solid, actionable starting point.
- alienicecream 3y agoCan thought encompass reality? We can't even prove that there is causality, we assume it.
- LinuxBender 3y agoAccording to Douglas Adams if one of you talking about this in the comments figures it out then the whole thing resets and becomes even more complex. I don't even want to guess how many times this has happened or how many sub-optimal decisions I made in the last instances.
- rambojohnson 3y agoblah blah blah
- ThinkBeat 3y agoI think we might be, and I think it would make a lot of sense. A funny thought is whether whoever is running us as a simulation is themselves simulated and follow the recursion "upwards". My nonscientific best argument is that it explains how we came to be and how we end. How can there be -nothing- and then there is matter, and then there are stars. Our understanding of time is linear. ¹ If we are a "sim-city ULTRA" game, then the users starts it, plays it and closes it. That all makes sense. Thinking about being a simulation I find it amusing to think it of as fractal. Whenever we discover -the- final element/particel the game creates another layer. ¹ I am aware of scientific theories explaining why there was nothing and then something. I personally do not find them satisfying. Do have the multiple doctorates to make a scientifically informed decision? Probably not. I know someone, possibly Hawkins, was irritated when people asked him "what was before" it wasn an absurd question that made no sense. I do not think it is an unreasonable question. All we do in daily life is dependent up on a linear timeline. But yes experiments on particles may show us a different world.
- avidphantasm 3y agoIf we are in a simulation, then I argue that our laws of physics are necessarily less detailed than the laws of physics of our host universe. This may explain why we having difficulty reconciling quantum and classical mechanics; it may not be possible in our lower fidelity universe. I am drawn to the conclusion that a simulated universe must be of lower fidelity than host universe based on my experience simulating ecosystems within an ecohydrology model. Our model was really detailed, but still our ability to model things like soil physics is in the end limited by our inability to observe soil properties at smaller and smaller spatial scales. So the model necessarily simplifies the soil physics to the point where the model produces results that statistically match what we can observe. As a result, there are some things in the model that we can’t quite model and some things that don’t quite make sense in the model.
- ijhuygft776 3y agoour universe could be anything since we don't know what it is