22 ms·
"for reasons" is doing all the heavy lifting here. I think the whole point of this series is to lift the tablecloth a bit and look at the dust bunnies underneat
by ggm 3y ago
"for reasons" is doing all the heavy lifting here. I think the whole point of this series is to lift the tablecloth a bit and look at the dust bunnies underneath.
- Swizec 3y agoJust in case you didn't notice: patio11, author of the comment you're replying to, is also the author behind BitsAboutMoney, the source of this article/series.
- ggm 3y agoThank you I did not realise. But, noting that I don't think it alters the intent of my comment much. For reasons
- adolph 3y agoHeh, I didn’t notice it was him but when scanning through the comment noticed the “(for reasons)” and was wondering if that was some subcultural or regional dialect that so perfectly mimicked patio11.
- bigstrat2003 3y agoHe does that. He's simply eliding the explanation in his comment here, because he explained both of those things in the article. The "reasons" he elided are: * Banks don't want to do business with these particular people because they know them to be a bad business risk. They often know, via credit reporting methods, that the specific individual human standing before them has a history of cashing bad checks/committing fraud/whatever it is. Therefore, they decline to work with that person. * The people who are bad risks for banks get rather tired of dealing with banks, both because constant rejection is tiresome and because bank employees make it very clear (though unspoken explicitly) that they are persona non grata there. By contrast, the people at the check cashing shop treat them better, so they would rather take their financial business there. I get why you want the explanations and not just "for reasons", but both of these points are quite clearly spelled out in the article. So I don't really think the author deserves the grief you're giving him in this case.
- shiroiuma 3y ago>They often know, via credit reporting methods, that the specific individual human standing before them has a history of cashing bad checks/committing fraud/whatever it is. This wouldn't even be an issue if America didn't still rely on the utterly archaic check scheme for transferring money.
- JoshTriplett 3y ago> This wouldn't even be an issue if America didn't still rely on the utterly archaic check scheme for transferring money. It still will be for as long as many people cannot get and maintain a free bank account that is usable for transferring funds via whatever scheme you envision replacing checks. And the property that checks have, namely that some percentage of them get unwound for various reasons and that percentage varies substantially by customer, is very hard to get rid of. As long as that property exists, access to a bank account that provides that mechanism will be an extension of credit and thus not universally available. It's possible that a system for instant payment clearance, like FedNow, might reduce the problem of insufficient funds and similar clearance issues. However, that doesn't eliminate the possibility of bad/fraudulent/etc checks, just reduce it.
- shiroiuma 3y ago>whatever scheme you envision replacing checks. You're acting like this is some kind of futuristic concept. Are you not aware that everyone in every other country manages just fine without checks? They're only used in the US. If I went to my bank now and asked them about "cashing a check", they'd probably look at me like I had two heads. They simply don't exist.
- Symbiote 3y agoOh, your bank knows about cashing American cheques (or British or I think French ones, though they're much less common). It's on their table of fees, and costs €20.
- quickthrower2 3y agoBut the dust bunnies are with cheques. There is no bounce risk with a bank transfer. There is no identity risk. The money goes or it doesn’t. There is fraud risk, money laundering and terrorism etc. “risk” (airquotes because, HSBC) But most of the shit it is gone with a bank transfer. The problem is poor people would need to pay for their bank (as banks need to make money other ways and from the middle class that will be credit cards and mortgages etc.)