4 ms·
For a lot of people, the occasional check works pretty well. My housekeeper comes next week. I'll leave a check for her. I'll stick the occasional check in an e
by ghaff 3y ago
For a lot of people, the occasional check works pretty well. My housekeeper comes next week. I'll leave a check for her. I'll stick the occasional check in an envelope, but mostly I just fill in some bill pay numbers with my bank and it's transparent to me if it's ACH or a check is mailed. It's just not a problem for me or for the people receiving.
Of course, I don't try to pay by check in a store. (Though I did write about a $30K check when I bought my last car and that wasn't a problem either--assume they have back-end systems to verify.) Getting rid of checks just isn't a problem I care about or want to devote any mental bandwidth to.
- ggm 3y agoSo you just said you like writing cheques to make other people wear the 3 day clearing delay and paperwork hassle and you don't use them yourself when you are a consumer. You don't care because you're an issuer, and a net beneficiary of retention of the funds in your control for those extra days of clearing.
- mminer237 3y agoEven as a receiver of checks, I don't care. It's easier to deposit than cash or PayPal. Zelle is nicer, but if I can't wait three days for the money, I already messed up in my financial management.
- twiss 3y agoAs the article describes, it may be convenient for you, but for many people it's inconvenient and costly to cash a check. Also, saying that those people messed up in their financial management is sort of blaming their poverty on them, while we can't know (in general) whether that's their fault or not.
- ghaff 3y agoIf I'm paying them in person and a check is a problem I expect them to tell me and I'll pay them in cash is that's reasonable such as for already-completed work. But I'm not mailing cash or diddling around with other random payment mechanisms.
- twiss 3y agoNobody is asking you, specifically, to do anything. But your original point was that checks aren't a problem for you. My point is just that as the article describes, for those without a bank account it does pose problems, and so assuming you do have a bank account, "worksforme" is not a very substantive comment, since the article also already acknowledges that.
- ghaff 3y agoSo paying in cash seems the most straightforward mechanism in that case. Which is fine in-person if checks don't work for some reason.
- ghaff 3y agoSure, I use them myself as a consumer. Not frequently but I get refund checks etc. for various reasons. They take a minute to deposit with my banking app. Would I want to go back to doing bills every week with checks and mailing them? Of course not. But dealing with one now and then just isn't a problem.And for the generally small amounts involved, a few days of clearing generally just doesn't matter.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> make other people wear the 3 day clearing delay This is only applicable to the unbanked, for the most part. Regular banks make funds immediately available when a check is deposited. Unless you're already on their radar for kiting.
- alright2565 3y agoIn situations like this, where it's me and a small business, I very explicitly ask how the recipient would like to be paid. I've never been told cash, but if I was, I would be happy to pay in cash.
- ghaff 3y agoI have rarely had individuals who want to get paid in cash (off the books). But although some businesses like my furnace company are slowly switching over to having portable terminals, in my experience, checks are still the default around where I live in the US for service people and the like. (And, as I wrote elsewhere, even things like local tax payments can have outsourced third-party websites which charge a fee so it can be materially cheaper to pay by check.)
- fmobus 3y agoMeanwhile, I can pay the ice cream vendor in Copacabana Beach using pix and the transaction is confirmed on their device before I even lift my finger from the screen.
- ghaff 3y agoI'm fine with using whatever electronic transaction mechanism but a fair number of service people are not set up that way and I'm fine with just handing them a check.
- rootusrootus 3y agoWhy do you think we don't have instant money transfer available in the US, just because in a pinch we can still write a check? These days a check is just a paper form of digital payment anyway, my bank never touches the actual checks that I receive.
- dudul 3y agoSo? This is also possible in the US, I don't see the connection between the 2 examples.
- oh_sigh 3y agoWhat app do you recommend? The most common one is Venmo, but people don't realize it doesn't settle for a number of days after the transaction.
- fmobus 3y agoIs it really? How fast does it settle? Does it require an extra app and extra account? Is it guaranteed to be supported by any bank? Does it charge fees? Is it widely used and trusted by people? Seriously, I don't think people in this thread appreciate just how practical and efficient pix is. Adoption is essentially universal across the population, and we are talking about a poor country.
- xyzzy_plugh 3y agoYes? You can make transfers without an extra app or extra account that settle relatively "instantly" whether or not the banks have actually reconciled (as TFA alludes it's basically always some sort of credit). And this is true of many countries in the world, too! And many of those countries still use and support checks. There are a variety of systems in many countries, the key difference with Pix is that it is very modern and relatively mobile-first. There are not many other such systems in the world yet. How easy is it to pay without a phone? Or without internet? I regularly make payments in places where there is nearly zero cell signal. Pix charges fees, too, to merchants. Is Pix guaranteed to be supported by every bank? The mandate certainly doesn't seem to require it, but I'll take your word. I think the reason that people in this thread don't appear to "appreciate just how practical and efficient pix is" is simply because it's not very relevant. Sending and receiving money isn't particularly annoying in the US. Nor is accepting payments (merchant fees aside -- that's a whole different topic that I am sure patio11 has explored). I am sure that if Pix or something like it was widely available in the US, folks would be singing its praise too. But it's not particularly compelling when most people aren't even aware that something is or could be lacking in the current system.
- bombcar 3y agoThey don’t even really verify that much (they were willing to hand over the car on a post-dated check) because they know where you are and where the car will be. I presume they do some basic checks, but it’s really all down to trusting it’ll all come out eventually. They’d much rather have a check than 30k in hundreds.
- ghaff 3y agoYou used to have to run to the bank and get a cashier's check. I assume there are other verifications these days.