4 ms·
I'm fully with you, but my question is how you actually inform people at the power of their data? I often pressure people into chatting with me through Signal a
by godelski 3y ago
I'm fully with you, but my question is how you actually inform people at the power of their data? I often pressure people into chatting with me through Signal and I'll be honest, there is often a defeatist or lack of knowledge at what this data can be used for even among graduate CS students.
Honestly, I think one of the major issues is that the world is exceptionally complex these days (well, always has been, but surely there's more now). Our entire world runs on specialization but we often act as if one needs to be an expert in nearly every domain. Is not the definition of an expert someone who understands the nuances and complexities of said niche? It would then seem de facto unreasonable for people to have a nuanced understanding of practically any given subject.
Because of this, I want to question the common framing about focusing on informing people. I don't want to stop informing people, to be clear. But I think we should look for solutions that are not reliant upon people being informed, as this is clearly not a scalable nor stable mechanism for creatures with finite ̶t̶a̶p̶e̶ ̶ knowledge and finite time.
- 20after4 3y agoThe thing is, people don't have the ability to withhold consent. I don't think people would need to be fully informed to realize that withholding consent is better than giving it, if that was actually a viable choice to make. I mostly trust Mozilla but I still turn off all of their data collection in Firefox. This wasn't always my default but it is now my default in any place where I am given the choice. It really is difficult to understand all of the implications and it's taken me years of experience to realize that I should just default to presuming that data collection is going to be bad for me in the long run. When there is a complex and nuanced situation involving a binary choice then all you really need to know is which of the two choices is generally more likely to be in your best interest, then always choose that one. For data collection the safe bet is always "no"
- godelski 3y agoYeah that's how I am too, even with Mozilla. For the same reason: default to the most secure option. Everything is so complex that I can't know what my information makes me vulnerable of.