2 ms·
> The government is supposed to play by different (more constrained) rules because it has a monopoly on force. How is this relevant when the government is purc
by gruez 3y ago
> The government is supposed to play by different (more constrained) rules because it has a monopoly on force.
How is this relevant when the government is purchasing the data on the open market?
>but it feels like it violates the spirit of the law that says they shouldn't be spying on their citizens.
No, the spirit of the law is that the government can't use its monopoly on violence to gather evidence.
- janalsncm 3y agoWe can set whatever rules we want for the government. Whether the information is available on the open market doesn’t matter. Government isn’t a force of nature. We could say the government is only allowed to buy data on a Friday the 13th during a full moon if we want.
- gruez 3y ago>We can set whatever rules we want for the government. But that's not what was discussed. The comment I replied to was talking about "the spirit of the law", which is separate from what the law ought be today.