6 ms·
> where a huge amount of information can be gathered about people without “searches and seizures” Although in my opinion, the vast majority of this data collec
by JohnFen 3y ago
> where a huge amount of information can be gathered about people without “searches and seizures”
Although in my opinion, the vast majority of this data collection and use absolutely counts as "searches and seizures" -- just by private corporations rather than the government. Which, in my view, is worse than if it were just the government.
- psychlops 3y ago> Which, in my view, is worse than if it were just the government. Consider that no matter how evil the corporation, they can't seize your property or freedom. Be careful who you empower.
- kmeisthax 3y agoYes, they can, and they have. What do you think Apple is, if not a government in corporate clothing?
- JoshTriplett 3y agoApple cannot jail you, fine you, or legally enjoin your activities.
- JohnFen 3y agoUS history is full of examples of private corporations doing exactly this.
- psychlops 3y agoAre you saying that this is still done today or just bringing up an interesting historical fact?
- kmeisthax 3y agoTheir behavior against Gizmodo over an iPhone 4 prototype got really close to jailing tech bloggers. Their technical control over the signing keys that Apple devices trust also gives them the ability to enjoin shittons of otherwise legal activity (e.g. emulators). Apple also pays shittons to have Customs & Border Patrol lock down the US border and ban iPhone parts imports that aren't authorized by Apple. Does that count as a fine? I'm pretty sure that's already two out of three.
- JoshTriplett 3y agoThe first and third of those are Apple trying to get a government to do something on their behalf. The second of those is attempting to technologically restrict activities you can do with an Apple device, not legally restrict your activities in general. Apple still doesn't have the legal authority of a government, nor should it.
- cj 3y agoI think there needs to be some kind of "responsible and clear disclosure" laws that require companies to very clearly and overtly disclose what data they're collecting and how they're using it. Some kind of standardized "label" (something like the standardized nutritional facts on food products) that is easy for consumers to read and comprehend, not buried in pages of paperwork, without needing to read a 20 page TOS / Privacy Policy. The legal problem is everyone is "consenting" to data collection by accepting a TOS which protects companies and makes it "legally acceptable". The real problem that needs solving is consumers are rarely aware of what they're consenting to. Companies might not hoover up and sell as much data if they were required to clearly tell everyone they're doing it. Basically, let's get rid of this idea that agreeing to a 20 page TOS / Privacy Policy is legally binding when < 1% of people actually read what they're agreeing to.
- JohnFen 3y ago> The real problem that needs solving is consumers are rarely aware of what they're consenting to. Right, which means consent was never actually given. In order for it to be consent, you have to be fully informed of and understand what you're being asked to consent to, and there has to be a realistic and meaningful way to withhold that consent.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoThere's so many adults that were clearly never taught F.R.I.E.S. and it's both depressing and horrifying. Freely Given Reversible Informed Enthusiastic Specific
- godelski 3y ago> you have to be fully informed of and understand what you're being asked to consent to This really makes it seem like only a very limited set of contracts would actually be legal. To me a big problem we have is that we act as if there is a fair "fight" between a mega corporation with a expensive team of lawyers, expert psychologists, and supercomputers against ... my gandma who googles to get to google. I think we all know that nearly no one reads pretty much anything they sign and if they did it is not clear that they are fully informed, understand, or are not under pressure (clear case might be medical consent forms authorizing something like a emergency surgery. I'd find it impossible to convince me the person signing was well informed and not under duress. I'd rather case like that revolve around expert of doctors determining if an action was reasonable to another doctor rather than have anything to do with a patient or surrogate signing a document. Seems to just waste time). It really would be great if the crack team of lawyers was required to put terms and conditions into text that is understandable by an average person in a reasonable amount of time.