14 ms·
Google is making a huge and annoying mistake
- dendory 15y agoPersonally I think removing the thumbs up and down is a huge mistake. I understand that video producers don't like them, but guess what, when I load a YouTube video the rating is the first thing I look at, and if it's under 50% I know that the video will be crap. That judgement has been right EVERY time.
- johnnyo 15y agoLooks like this was a test Google recently deployed, more information here: http://thenextweb.com/google/2012/03/15/dislike-youtube-considers-phasing-out-likedislike-in-favor-of-its-giant-1-button/ http://thenextweb.com/google/2012/03/15/dislike-youtube-cons...
- kefs 15y agoThank you for that link. Yours is the only relevant comment in this thread, and should be read prior to upvoting. The rest is just fud.
- lysol 15y agoWhile I appreciate the sentiment and agree with his point of view, his simply telling Google 'go fuck yourself' doesn't really offer an in-depth critique of why these changes or wrong -- it just smacks of the same old 'Everything that's new sucks' sentiment that I can and do find on IRC every day already. Leave the analyses to the real UX folks.
- libraryatnight 15y agoI don't think it's meant to be an in depth critique, it's his feedback as a user. He doesn't need to be a design expert or UX expert to know that as a user something is annoying. The real UX folks should be listening to users, they don't have to agree or implement everything said, but they should be listening. The point seems to be don't rob people of functionality they've come to expect just to push sign-ups.
- huggyface 15y agoI don't think it's meant to be an in depth critique, it's his feedback as a user. It sounds like it's more his feedback as a creator, worried about what the functionality will do to users. But, you know, those are the breaks when you sharecrop on someone else's land: they retain the right to change things for their own benefit. Still don't quite understand the complaint, though. You've long needed a Google account to give feedback on YouTube. Now they call those accounts G+ accounts (just as Hotmail accounts became Live accounts, etc). What's the problem? sidenote -- gah, accidentally downvoted you when I was trying to select text. Apologies.
- libraryatnight 15y agoWhen I read his blog post I assumed he has a YouTube account that is not linked to his Google account. You can unlink them[1]. It's also possible to have an account with Google without being on G+. My understanding of his complaint is that he was signed in to youtube, which is why it's billed as an 'upgrade.' He should be able to easily use YouTube with a YouTube account. I think that's where the complaint comes in, it's not just calling the account something different, it's making things more difficult for those who might want to keep some things separate. That doesn't make your points any less true, but I at least think I understand the complaint. edit: also no worries on the downvote ;) [1]http://support.google.com/youtube/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=183819 http://support.google.com/youtube/bin/answer.py?hl=en&an...
- ryanmolden 15y agoUX folks? This is an actual end user expressing strong dislike of something and explaining why. That should have much more weight than "UX folks", unless it is a rare piece of dissat in otherwise glowing feedback, though I doubt it. I have a Google+ account but I would not sign in (or up for one) just to rate a video, I would just say "meh" and wander off elsewhere on the internet. I doubt that would be an uncommon reaction and would change the meaning of the up/down votes from "What do most people think of this video" to "What do Google+ users think of this video". Those are two very different metrics.
- mullr 15y agoThe main reason he gives is that it increases the barrier to entry for liking a video, which is important for many content creators. (like him) This seems concrete and significant. I don't agree however with his assessment of this changing the funding equation for people getting production funded. As long as the change applies globally, everyone should feel the hit equally and it they should be able to correct for it.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoIt won't hit people equally, though. It will hit people who have viewers who are signup-averse harder. Kids watching lolcats tend to be much more willing to sign up to anything so they can post their roflcopter than technically minded adults with interesting things to say. Guess which market Wheaton is going after?
- iamgilesbowkett 15y ago"While I appreciate the sentiment and agree with his point of view, his simply telling Google 'go fuck yourself' doesn't really offer an in-depth critique of why these changes [are] wrong" what you said is literally false. here's his in-depth critique: "I’m going to lose a crapton of potential upvotes for Tabletop, because the core of my audience is tech-savvy and may not want to “upgrade” to yet another fucking social network they don’t want or need... Those upvotes are incredibly important to us, because we need them to earn another season of our show... [this] will negatively affect how users can interact with us on YouTube." translation: "we might lose the ability to do our show, because this G+ +1 button introduces friction and a sign-up process we don't expect our users will bother to complete."
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- TomGullen 15y ago> translation: "we might lose the ability to do our show, because this G+ +1 button introduces friction and a sign-up process we don't expect our users will bother to complete." Yeah, but he misses the next step in logical thinking which is that the changes will apply to everyone. This new button is for everyone, which means everyone will get less votes which means less are needed for him to continue to run the show.
- erichocean 15y agoEveryone will get less votes in different proportions, based on their audience. It's not a linear adjustment for everyone.
- TomGullen 15y agoOf course, but I imagine the proportional increase/decrease will probably be the same with the people he's competing with. That's not the point the author is arguing anyway.
- iamgilesbowkett 15y ago
- OzzyB 15y agoOkay I'll bite: Look at where that G+ button is. It's big, its first, and it combines, as-one, an already existing feature -- the "Like" button. The G+ button isn't optionial, placed in a "secondary" position (i.e. to the right), or a single feature/choice. That's probably why users are getting upset with this, UX background or not.
- mistercow 15y ago> his simply telling Google 'go fuck yourself' doesn't really offer an in-depth critique of why these changes or wrong Well it's good that in addition to "go fuck yourself", he offered an in-depth critique of why these changes are wrong. I guess maybe you stopped reading before that? > Leave the analyses to the real UX folks. Whoa now, hold on just a goddamned minute. What "real UX folks" say only holds weight insofar as it accurately pertains to the interaction and communication of producers and consumers. When content producers say "This change breaks an important connection to our users", then "UX folks" had better listen good and hard.
- ww520 15y agoThat's his express of strong emotion, which is a very important data point for UX. Emotion trumps cool analytic fact in any day for UX. When a user is extremely annoyed, you change you UI/UX.
- tomkarlo 15y ago"Emotion trumps cool analytic fact in any day for UX." Uh, no, it doesn't, at least not at any responsible software project I've worked on. The whole reason you run experiments, A/B testing, etc is so that this doesn't happen.
- abeh 15y agoDoes not seem like a UX issue, but rather a business decision.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- thekungfuman 15y agoIt's perfectly reasonable that Google would try to consolidate their properties. You used to need a YouTube account to do anything, and they own YouTube and don't feel like managing disparate databases about their users. It may be a minor inconvenience because it's a change from what people are used to, but it makes sense logistically and serves their business interests. They ARE a business after all...
- mattmanser 15y agoYouTube is not Google. Google is not YouTube. They just happen to own it. Google should start remembering that before YouTube gets myspaced. Which imo is looking increasingly likely. Vimeo is one competitor which seems to already be growing like crazy for example.
- kcbanner 15y agoYouTube isn't going anywhere
- Teapot 15y agoyoutube has been going downhill for several years now. The only thing that keeps people from fleeing is the poor alternatives out there, so far..
- Kronopath 15y agoVimeo will never overtake Youtube because of their draconian policies on copyrighted content. For example, you're not allowed to upload videos that show videogame gameplay unless it's a game you developed yourself (and shows like these are a BIG part of Youtube's audience).
- luser001 15y agoHmm, I always thought the restriction on game recordings was just a way to curate the community.
- 15y ago
- vibrunazo 15y agoThey're not crippling functionality to force people to g+. Adding a social layer to existing products can potentially make them better if done right (ie: finding content that was upvoted by people whose opinion you care about, vs randoms you don't care about). If done wrong it can be crippling. But then it's a problem of that specific implementation, and you could make a constructive critic to improve it. Instead, the author is just raging against g+ for no good reason.
- debacle 15y agoNo, the author is right. The same thing happened when they linked up gmail accounts to YT logins. I just stopped watching videos that required a login, because I didn't want to link my YT account to my gmail account for privacy reasons.
- Rudism 15y agoThis reminds me of the backlash against Facebook's "Like" button replacing the "Become a Fan" button. Personally, I would be happy to see G+ get a little more traction among my less-techy friends and family which isn't going to happen without Google doing stuff like this.
- rsl7 15y agoAs a user this makes me wonder how long it will be before I have to sign up for Google+ in order to watch youtube videos at all? Or to search?
- Auguste 15y agoYears later, it still annoys me that you need a Google account to sign up for YouTube.
- jrockway 15y agoWhat's the difference between having a Google account and a YouTube account? Google owns YouTube.
- est 15y agoIt's the difference like you have to get a Condé Nast subscription in order to comment on reddit. Condé Nast owns reddit, remember? I don't want to link my personal email (Gmail) account with the what cats I watch on the Internet.
- Auguste 15y agoI liked being able to have a separate YouTube account to my Google account. Actually, I like having separate accounts for everything.
- eternalban 15y ago
- loeschg 15y agoThe one video I checked still had the typical thumbs-up and thumbs-down feature.
- datagramm 15y agoYeah, I still have the old buttons. I checked when signed in with my G+ account and also with a non-G+ account.
- NickPollard 15y agoThis is where I show my complete lack of understanding about Social Media, but really, what is the point of a 'like' button? The web is built on URLs. If you like something and want to share it with people, send them a URL. That's what they're for.
- jdludlow 15y agoIt's done partially because "everyone else is doing it," but there is also the "wisdom of crowds" value. The number of likes or dislikes is a quick metric that can be used for sorting, searching, populating a home page, or building recommendations.
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoIt's also a metric that because it's tied to accounts is relatively hard to game, at least in a major way.
- jentulman 15y agoBecause the sharing is usually implied by the action of liking. Clicking a like or +1 button causes your network on the associated social site to see a link to what you liked in their stream. In theory it's made it far easier to share cool things with people. as an aside, I say 'in theory' because with the millions of 'me too' buttons scattered around the web, in even my modestly small socially networked connections, the S/N ratio has made them near enough useless.
- masklinn 15y ago> what is the point of a 'like' button? Feedback to the author, and crowd-rating for people you don't know. What do you think the point of HN's up and down arrows are?
- NickPollard 15y agoOk, I understand that. My issue is the conflating of approval with sharing. In this case, the problem is that people without G+ cannot voice their approval. This is obviously a deliberate ploy to coerce people into joining G+, but motives aside the issue is that Google are forcing people to share when perhaps, some only want to approve. As people have noted, whilst the frictionless sharing is good for viral marketing, in the long term it's devastating to signal vs. noise. I left Facebook largely because my stream was full of updates from people - good friends, who I enjoy talking to - that said 'John Doe likes this: "Click like for a chance to Win!"'
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- alfbolide 15y agoIt's just funny that people want google to fuck herself while they are perfectly fine to be forced to sign in to comment either on the original article or here.
- dasil003 15y agoWhy are you anthropomorphizing a corporation?
- starwed 15y agoHN lets you sign in with an OpenID...
- recoiledsnake 15y agoIf I comment or upvote here, it is not broadcast to all my "friends".
- jack-r-abbit 15y agoor that a bazillion other sites only give you the option to log in with your Facebook account. Haters gonna hate.
- dlikhten 15y agoFlip side: wouldn't it be nice if everything you had just played well together? I don't see such rage when evernote is going to get the boot in osx 10.8.
- rkudeshi 15y agoHuh? Why won't Evernote work in OS X Mountain Lion?
- joejohnson 15y agoThis is annoying, but how is it a huge mistake on Google's part? Sure, they're going to annoy a few people, but I think that these tactics forcing people to use G+ will probably work. People will be forced onto this G+ platform whether they like it or not; the mass exodus threats about any social networking platform never materialize into anything more than a few users deactivating their accounts.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoHow much does Google gain from having a bunch of people who technically have G+ accounts, but don't actually use them for anything aside from liking/disliking videos?
- xxbondsxx 15y agoThey already have a ton of people who have G+ accounts and do nothing. Automatically sharing youtube likes to your G+ stream would an explosion of activity for the majority of users. It's all about baby steps. The chicken and egg problem sometimes needs coercion in the beginning
- notcertain 15y agoIf you extend this thinking far enough, they have a lot to gain. It's an extra dimension that Google can use to further refine their ad inventory against your interests. The theory is that you will see more relevant ads and Google will earn more because of it. i.e. if you like this video, and someone else liked this video, and they clicked on that ad, then maybe you'll click on that ad. Perhaps on its own this single dimension doesn't add all that much value, but in aggregate and with a mass number of participants, it should.
- ajross 15y agoThey gain a bunch of people with an easy and painless upgrade path to G+ usage if/when their friends start using it. It reduces the technical friction, which is always the biggest blocker for early adopters. Like most people, all of my friends use Facebook more or less exclusively. But I know if I have a photo in my G+ account (the Android app syncs all photos to the G+ cloud by default) I can send people a link and have a pretty reasonable assurance they can see it.
- mgurlitz 15y agoTabletop made a huge mistake making their bottom line dependent on YouTube's upvoting system. What if YouTube decides to get rid of the "Thumbs up" system? Or if Google wants a share of your revenue from this service? See edw519's comments here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2255615 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2255615
- runevault 15y agoMistake? Youtube funded them (and all of Geek and Sundry) as part of an initiative to get better content onto Youtube. That's like saying taking VC is a mistake as an entrepreneur.
- jasonlotito 15y ago> That's like saying taking VC is a mistake as an entrepreneur. Not quite, but nice try. Though, in a way, even if it did apply, it's still holds water. If you are 100% dependent on VC funding you for your survival and operations, then yeah, mistakes are being made. Rather, it's like resting your entire business on a single entity, one big customer. If that customer goes away, you lose your funding. Sorry, but if you think being reliant on another businesses for all your funding is smart, you're in for a rude awakening.
- TomGullen 15y ago> I am adding now: Those upvotes are incredibly important to us, because we need them to earn another season of our show. I'm assuming the changes are site wide, and not just targeted at you? If so, everyone will get less votes. Therefore it doesn't matter in regards to this point at all. Supply and demand right? > You don't get people to enthusiastically use your services by forcing them to. We're talking about a button. It's amazing how much hyperbole and irrationality comes out the woodwork when small changes are made. How is such an angry meaningless blog post making it's way to front page of HN?
- runevault 15y agounless when Youtube set any requirements to earn continued funding it was based on hard numbers, in which case they may simply see fewer of their content partners make the cut to continue. Stupid? Yes, but it's dangerous to just assume they'll do the right thing. Frankly they should have added a + button on top of thumbs up/down so you could easily share as a separate feature, not replace the thumbs.
- jgroome 15y agoG+ is a joke. Nobody outside of the tech and geek industries either wants it or uses it. And yet they carry on doing everything they can just to herd people into creating G+ accounts. Hey, it might work. Got to get those numbers up, right? But they can't make me USE my G+ account.
- sp332 15y agoAny page with a +1 button on it reports your visit back to Google. Even if you don't push the button! So now Google can mine your browsing history for advertisers.
- waqf 15y agoGood news everyone! Chrome now supports multiple profiles. So you can have one to log into Google services, and one for the rest of the web.
- Lost_BiomedE 15y agoCan I have one tab for google, and the others for the rest of the web. Or, am I doomed to alt-tabbing between windows?
- throwaway64 15y agoyou do realize that any page that contains google analytics (practically every website) will do the same thing right?
- tbatterii 15y ago"The Internet is a joke. Nobody outside of the tech and geek industries either wants it or uses it. " sometimes, things change.
- artursapek 15y agoThat's a terrible comparison. There was no alternative to the internet that did the same things.
- nextparadigms 15y agoIn the beginning people complained that Google has like a dozen different "Like" buttons on the Reader, Youtube and so on. Now they complain that they want to use just one everywhere? I think it's a great move. Personally, I even want them to integrate their G+ commenting system into all their services. It's one of the best commenting systems out there, and certainly much better than the Youtube one. It might even encourage better comments on Youtube.
- leovinci 15y agoin 2012 they will make fun of us for all the 'stupid like buttons', as we now make fun of those 'stupid javascript alerts' in the 90s.
- SkyMarshal 15y agoAgreed. Anedotal - I've been using Youtube since it was released, and I just found out a month or so ago that you don't have to dig through the annoyingly short paginated comments below videos to find replies to yours, there's a page in your dashboard that shows all that. I'm not a heavy Youtube user and don't care that much, but it was not intuitive or apparent. Further, I mostly like G+ (except for one complaint [1]), and I'm all for better integration of their properties with it. 1. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3828010 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3828010
- rhizome 15y agoYeah, and there's a series of clicks you can use to get to the list of videos that you've favorited, but damned if I can ever remember what they are. Every time I want to find one of my favorites, it takes a maddening number of clicks to get to it.
- m0nty 15y ago> Now they complain that they want to use just one everywhere? It's almost like the Internet is lots of different people with wildly divergent opinions!
- 15y ago
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- drivebyacct2 15y agoWhen are people going to just shut up about this stuff? Google is going social. Either get with it or don't. I'm tired of seeing rants everytime they decide to try something new out (by the way, this was a test for less than 1% of their users). If you don't want to participate in Google's social network, you don't get to participate in Google's social network. That includes YouTube and it has for years. Downvote away, I look forward to the next rant about Google's social unification as if it's a big shock and surprise, maybe we can also discuss semicolons in Javascript. (everything else aside, I have no idea why they would throw away everything they've invested in the '+1' branding) Funny, both of my comments shaking my head in disbelief at unexplained Google hate are commentlessly downvoted. Let the rage at Google flow through you and the downvote arrow!
- ixacto 15y agoThe only reason that I have a Gmail address is that it is not blocked by spambots and it is a bit of a defacto standard. I had a Facebook account in 2006, but deleted it after they let you sign up with a non .edu address. Back in the day the point of Facebook at college was to organize activities and share pictures with people I personally knew. Strangely enough most students did not want people (or employers) seeing drunken party pictures of them, but Facebook wanted to expand and the coolness of college was the PERFECT way to leach out to everyone else. TL;DR I am a facebook hipster. Facebook isn't cool anymore.
- drivebyacct2 15y agoI don't understand how this is relevant. Though I also don't understand why every last HN post about Google's social effort is a circlejerk of how Google sucks, is evil, etc.
- cargo8 15y agoDid you consider that Google just cares about its own operations and future profitability than it does about your startup's future? Google has realized it NEEDS to have some social layer and influence integrated into its services in order to compete and not fade into the archives of the web. A much lower # of likes from identified users is MUCH more valuable to Google than millions of anonymous likes.
- sp332 15y agoGoogle likes aren't anonymous. You needed to have an account before you could thumb-up a video already. But to get a Google+ account, you have to give them your real name, or risk having your account banned.
- javajosh 15y agoGoogle thinks it will die in the long run without social. They realize that all the tech-savvy software product in the world can be reproduced eventually, but secondary, human-savvy products, can never be reproduced. Furthermore, they see the power in adding ever more context to search - see Bret Victor's talk about how 'interaction' is bad, and inferring context is everything. There's no better context than social. While my visceral reaction is basically the same as Wil's, I actually think that this is something Google needs to do if they believe in this vision. Time will tell if it's justified: when they removed social features from Reader I basically stopped using it. I probably won't stop using YouTube, but this may be annoying enough for me to stop giving feedback (apart from the navigation event itself, of course). Also on the plus side, since Google insists on real identities on G+ then we can at least look forward to more civil comments on YouTube, which I think we all agree would be a net benefit.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoI haven't seen a convincing argument that Google needs social. I know they believe it, I just haven't seen anything that made a compelling case that it's actually true.
- amirmc 15y agoThis is my take on things but happy to hear other views. Google (and Facebook) are advertising based so try thinking about it in terms of how well they know their users. The better they know their users, the more specifically they can target ads to them. For example, if I wanted to reach 20-somethings, who really like pizza and motorbikes, travel widely and currently reside on the west coast, FB can put ads in front of that group (I don't know if Google can, but I assume it's more tricky for them). Since there are likely a large number of people that use the web while still logged in to FB, then FB could feasibly start offering to place highly-targeted ads out on the web at large. This could obviously have a dramatic effect on Google's dominance. In other words, it's not just social per se, but being able to learn more about users in order to ensure that they can keep their hold over advertising revenue. Once I looked at it this way, Google's 'need' for social made more sense. To test the above, we could look at what Google offers in terms of demographics/interest filtering when you buy/place ads around the web. If the ability to refine who sees your ads is really part of the plan then there should be signs that it's happening. I've never used any of Google's ad stuff so I wouldn't know where to look.
- epicviking 15y agoGiven that you need a google account to access YouTube in the first place, shouldn't google already have all the data they need here? They don't seem to gain much with this...
- gallerytungsten 15y agoIn a perverse way, I kind of like annoying "upgrades" like this. Because I have even less incentive to use the more-annoying service, I don't use it at all; and thus have more time for productive activities.
- idleloops 15y agoI wish these things were decentralised. Somewhere in my browser there should be settings to set up my 'like' service, and the same for sharing and blogging and a whole gamut of activities. Plus a simple way to switch between these, and turn them off. I have a real hatred for the merging of Google services - and I'm not even sure why. I think it's because it just feels like the erosion of my privacy. I've become someone that uses multiple browsers. I'm logging in and out of services - just because I want to shed my persistent identity - that I probably have exposed anyway. Not having to sign into different services with different credentials is one of the only benefits I feel I get, and yet I'm doing more logging in and out then I ever did before.
- maaku 15y agoHmm. this shouldn't be too difficulty to piggyback on top of something like bittorrent's DHT, which does have a p2p like/5-star rating system.
- mbreese 15y agoIt used to be that it was all decentralized... you managed all of this stuff with bookmarks/bookmarklets. If you liked something, you'd bookmark it. If you wanted to share your bookmarks, you'd use a site like del.icio.us and their bookmarklet. Nice and neat. And then sites began adding the bookmarklet code directly to their pages. Which seemed like a good idea - until they had to add a button for everyone's favorite service. And then they had 10-20 buttons on each page, each using javascript to call a remote service on the backend. And then it wasn't such a good idea... so we started to see consolidation. I miss my old bookmarklets. (and get off my lawn).
- jentulman 15y agoI think this move comes down to issues of branding with google accounts. What's happened here is replacing needing a 'Youtube' account with a 'Google' account, which for all intents and purposes has been a Google account for a while now anyway. I have a feeling that this is the beginning of consolidating the various ways in which you hold a google account for any of the services under one G+ bannner. The problem I see they might have with this is issues of association on non-social networked activity with the G+ social network. I've found amongst my non-tech friends a strong opposition to moving from Facebook to G+ as they perceive Google to be less trustworthy than Facebook when it comes to matters of privacy, and in extreme cases to think that Google is actively evil in its data sucking in comparison.
- masklinn 15y ago> What's happened here is replacing needing a 'Youtube' account with a 'Google' account No, that happened years ago, you haven't been able to log into Youtube with a Youtube account for a very, very long time. Instead, you've been greeted with this: > Update your YouTube account by linking to a Google Account > You will no longer be able to sign in to YouTube without a Google Account. > If you do not want to link this YouTube account, you can sign out here. This new move is about forcefully shoving G+ further down user throats in the hope of ever making it relevant.
- naner 15y agoThis is just as bad as companies forcing me to “like” something on Facebook before I can view whatever it is they want me to “like.” I don't think it is "just as bad" but it is quite obnoxious.
- petercooper 15y agoDoes YouTube share playlist popularity for videos? I've been using YouTube since the early days and have several thousand videos in my "Favorites" folder yet have almost never used the thumbs up/down (I don't see a direct benefit). If I've dumped a video in my favorites for watching again later, that should carry more weight for what WW wants likes for.
- VikingCoder 15y ago> It is bad for viewers, bad for video creators, and bad for YouTube’s ability to curate and tailor videos to potential viewers. First, a question: any random person on the internet, without being logged in, used to be able to Thumb Up a YouTube video? If that's true, then I bet it was very easy to spam. Giving it a Thumb Up, without being logged in, would also mean that none of your friends had any idea that you had given it a Thumb Up, and you could never again find a history of things you had Thumbed Up. And now, to upvote, you need to be logged in... What website, anywhere on the internet, allows you to upvote without being logged in? Not HackerNews. Not Reddit. Not Facebook. By knowing who you Follow, Google and YouTube now have a much better way to find information that you care about. If I search on YouTube for "python", it has a chance to know that I mean the programming language, because of who I'm Following. Also, every single +1 that you get on your YouTube videos now has a real person behind it. Every single +1 is now worth Gold. Every single +1 has a better chance to go viral, because the Followers of that person who clicked +1 have a chance to see it. If I search on YouTube for something, and I see "Wil Wheaton +1d this," I'm MUCH more likely to want to check it out.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- adventureful 15y agoA lot of news sites allow voting without being logged in, as well as in the comment sections. Business Insider, the largest business site, allows it (Quantcast #235). It's premised on the notion that for 99.999% of people, they're not going to bother going through any amount of hassle to bolster votes artificially. It works, it's not worth the time or effort to game content and comments that are modest in traffic and throw-away in nature. The only way it's worth gaming, is on front pages like Reddit where there's a massive simultaneous concentration of traffic.
- sad_panda 15y agoNot just Reddit, HN derives tremendous value from quality commenting. Commenting with zero accountability (authenticated accounts, voting, flagging, whatever) is basically doomed to be awful and a net negative to the service.
- leoh 15y agoIs it me, or is this post exceedingly whiny?
- jes5199 15y agoYoutube used to be a demilitarized zone in the social wars. Every social network uses Youtube as their default video provider, every cell phone OS has a Youtube app as the default video app. Google saying that Youtube is now, fundamentally, a G+ territory means that social video is no longer something we can take for granted; expect Facebook and Apple to jump ship, and Youtube is left with, what, only the loyal G+ users? I miss the days when Google, Apple, and Facebook cooperated rather than squabbled. The internet has gotten crappier lately.
- jiggy2011 15y agoVery true, I often dread "upgrades" or "redesigns" to software or websites that I like using. Everything seems to now be adding hoops that you have to jump through. This is why I often prefer things that I either have to pay for or that are OSS because then at least I feel like I have some of influence in the relationship. I dread the day that google slap a login page up in front of their search engine service.
- jahmed 15y agoSometimes I forget that services I use everyday have login pages. I cant remember the last time I logged in to facebook.
- DavidAbrams 15y agoFacebook is still trying to use E-mail addresses as user IDs. Amateur hour, just like Apple.
- Raphael 15y agoYour custom URL ending also works for signing in to Facebook.
- kragen 15y agoI do it several times a day, because I keep Facebook isolated in an Incognito tab, which I strongly recommend to everyone else.
- igrekel 15y agoRemembers me how frustrated I was when I shared pictures from Picasa with people on my contact list and what it did, without warning me, was to send everyone a Google+ invitation.
- josteink 15y agoYeah. Google+ got me labeled as a spammer as well. I had no idea, until I got told (in person) much, much later at some party that I was "spamming them". Thanks for handling your social network in a non-evil way Google. Appreciated.
- cnbeuiwx 15y agoStop using Google! You know its a company that spies on your every move, you know they are selling your information to governments, you know they are constantly IN YOUR FACE everywhere you turn on the net these days. They are even worse than Microsoft was back in the days, when Google came along with a clean search engine and a clean slate. These days, "dont do evil" is as ridicolous as Obamas "Change!" campaign. Google is a strong supporter of CISPA as well. Whats left to like in this company? They make a good browser and good apps, but its not worth what they are doing to their customers.
- waqf 15y agowhat are your references for: (i) selling your information to governments (emphasis added) (ii) strong supporter of CISPA?
- fear91 15y agoSending users detail to governments: http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/governmentrequests/userdata/ http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/governmentrequests/... Google supportive of CISPA: http://livewire.talkingpointsmemo.com/entries/report-google-supportive-of-cispa-revisions http://livewire.talkingpointsmemo.com/entries/report-google-...
- gcb 15y agostill less benign then sites that only have facebook's like. at least g+ is the same 'account' as your youtube one. they already have your data. PITA still.
- guynamedloren 15y ago> Oh, go fuck yourself, Google. This is just as bad as companies forcing me to “like” something on Facebook before I can view whatever it is they want me to “like.” Wow... can you say overreacting? Is this really that bad? Is it even bad at all? Wow.
- taosaur 15y agoThis... does not appear to be a thing. Wil Wheaton is great and all, but I and most of the commenters on his blog are still seeing normal, non-G+-integrated thumbs up/down buttons.
- kwerty 15y agoThis newest change won't affect me too much because I wrote a Google Chrome extension to keep my YouTube and regular Google accounts separate. However, as the author suggests, content creators will not be so lucky. Please try my extension if you're interested - http://kwerty.com/YouTube-User-Guard/ http://kwerty.com/YouTube-User-Guard/
- gubatron 15y agoso I guess this guy won't like all the extra traffic he will get from G+, meh
- appleaintbad 15y agoThis is nothing. What I'm more concerned about for Google's sake is all of the people giving up their Android phones for iPhones. It isn't an immediately obvious trend but it will be within the next two years as people's contracts run out. Google needs to refocus on search and advertising, and put more effort into R&D that might actually have world impact and significant ROI like perfecting and licensing driverless car technology.
- est 15y agoGoogle Plus already fucked up a good portion of faithful GReader users. The share feature used to be a very nice feature used exclusively among a group of people, not it just sucks. Also the G+ button tries to re-crawle the RSS source, so it lags and is anoying as fuck.
- yaix 15y agoI agree that Goog is currently making mistakes, but this one isn't one of them. Of course they consolidate all the upvoting and liking stuff into one database to then use that in their universal search ranking. Whining about not getting upvoted by anonymous users is a little silly, because your competition doesn't either. If you want to talk about huge mistakes of Goog, count the seconds it takes to execute all the JS crap they have stuffed even into the simplest of their pages now. Or talk about their failed attempt of a re-design and even them following the current position:fixed; hype, cluttering small screens with headers and footers that don't scroll (the rainbow <hr> of our times).
- danbmil99 15y agoI think the mistake here is that a company that collectively suffers from Asperger's syndrome should not try to "bring the social". Stick to your core competence always.
- jal278 15y agoI had a similar response to "fab" this evening, some kind of design site. It looked interesting but in order to even view a product linked from facebook they required me to sign up. Immediate rage; I can't investigate if the site is interesting enough to meriting signing up because signing up is required to investigate. No thanks.
- nns1212 15y agoIt is just being paranoid by Viddy & Socialcam funding. Both the apps (and Dailymotion) are deeply integrated with the FB timeline and hence getting a lot of views because of it. People will laugh if they integrated Youtube with FB timeline. So, I think it was in their best interest to integrate it with Google+. So, either Google+ wins or Youtube loses. I believe that most likely the latter will come true because of this move. I think Google should buy social networks like Pinterest, Viddy or Socialcam (and leaving them they way they are) instead of ruining its own products by integrating them with Google+. Facebook acquired Instagram in spite of it being integrated with Twitter. Google should also play the same game.
- Niksko 15y agoGoogle are doing this because the reason G+ is floundering is nobody is on there. Forcing people to use it is one way of getting more people on there. If even on in a thousand people stays to look around, that could mean a snowball effect that causes a massive spike in G+ users.
- gusandrews 15y agoIs anyone else facing a related problem, like I am -- that YouTube inexplicably deleted their videos because there is no Google+ account associated with the YouTube account? That's the only explanation I can see for what happened to an account I created for a client. All of our videos were taken down, and it says they were "removed by user" -- which they most definitely were not. Other data points on this would be appreciated.
- gusandrews 15y agoI've summarized my problem over here: http://groups.google.com/a/googleproductforums.com/forum/#!category-topic/youtube/feedback--suggestions/afQwLwEaIuU http://groups.google.com/a/googleproductforums.com/forum/#!c...
- known 15y agoWith more money, you'll have more options in life. With less money, you've to pick the right option. Google has lots of money.