5 ms·
Current data, if stored, can become a problem in the future if data analysis techniques improve dramatically. (Brute force, technological progress, etc.) Which
by ceejayoz 3y ago
Current data, if stored, can become a problem in the future if data analysis techniques improve dramatically. (Brute force, technological progress, etc.) Which seems... likely.
- RandomLensman 3y agoLack of current data produced can also become a future problem. What's the optimal data footprint?
- anonym29 3y agoLack of current data produced offers potential adversaries a hunch, not confirmation. In a hypothetical scenario where Nazis come into power in the USA, who is safer, the Jewish person with their real name tied to their Amazon account, who orders menorahs with their voice over Alexa, or the Jewish person who does not own an Alexa, only buys religious items from a physical shop, pays with cash, and offers a fake name to the seller? Everything that you do or don't do produces data in some sense, but the odds that what you're not doing is being explicitly logged are almost certainly lower than the odds of what you are doing being explicitly logged. Besides, what you're not doing is data point. What you are doing is information. Data does not deterministically produce information, it is merely possible to extract information from data, and it's possible to extract the wrong information from data. Ergo, I posit that the optimal amount of data to voluntarily hand over under the premise of "I'm doing nothing wrong, so I have nothing to hide" is zero, because voluntarily handing over your data is offering more concrete information than not doing so offers, and because other people, including those who achieve positions of power, can define "doing something wrong" extremely differently than you do.
- teddyh 3y ago> from a physical shop, pays with cash, and offers a fake name to the seller? Who gives their name to a physical shop when paying cash?
- anonym29 3y agoSomeone making polite conversation with the shopkeeper who politely asked the name of a repeat customer they get along well with in a socially appropriate context.
- RandomLensman 3y agoA hunch might be enough to get you into trouble. Not taking a phone along has been used against people, for example (not a US case). By the way, buying something in a shop that people can observe is zero protection against actors like Nazis.
- nothercastle 3y agoYour cash guy is going to draw suspicion on that alone. Besides the Germans are now on the same team there isn’t much danger.
- corethree 3y ago[flagged]
- beedeebeedee 3y ago> Ooooo Im so scared to see a relevant product recommendation. Duly noted. Thank goodness you are not in a position of authority. Your attitude towards the invasion of privacy (and other people's concerns) is alarming. You sound like a frog joking about the water getting warmer (it's just like a jacuzzi right now, who cares?)
- corethree 3y agoMaybe I am a frog. But so is everyone else. I mean who doesn't own a smart phone? Everybody mostly doesn't care.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Ooooo Im so scared to see a relevant product recommendation. Maybe you purchased a Palestinian flag in the UK: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/oct/10/people-supporting-hamas-in-uk-will-be-held-to-account-says-rishi-sunak https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/oct/10/people-supp... Maybe you purchased a dildo in Texas: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_obscenity_statute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_obscenity_statute Governments can change. I wouldn't want my Amazon purchase history looked over by a theocratic regime like Iran's.
- macintux 3y agoWomen in red states today in the U.S. need to be concerned about pregnancy indicators in their data.
- complianceowl 3y agoNo disrespect, but that's an extremely wrong mindset to have. There are so many things wrong with that way of thinking. You fail to understand that in our modern reality, our data is our identity. Like computers, we too have vulnerabilities that can be exploited. Imagine how well a hacker could exploit software if he had access to the source code? You fail to understand that Big Corporations DO care about our data. They harvest it precisely to manipulate our behavior for their benefit, at our expense. ("Digital Minimalism" by Cal Newport) You fail to understand the many Big Corporations are essentially quasi-governmental organizations; they work in tandem with government to carry out agendas that are mutually beneficial to the government and the corporation, at our expense. Ask Edward Snowden. You fail to understand that people are not paranoid. Many people simply understand that big corps may CURRENTLY take what is primarily a commercial interest, but as the political climate continues to shift, that primarily commercial purpose can pivot overnight to using your data to suppress dissent, influential voices, target members of whatever group they deem the "opposition". You fail to understand how our lives are altered by Big corps Having access to our data. We are in an unfair fight; we are up against Big Corps that invest millions and millions into R&D to find the most effective ways to manipulate us to promote consumerism, for their profit. > I think people are paranoid. I think you're too trusting and need to think deeper about this topic.