6 ms·
The trouble is, Boeing hasn't built a new single-aisle transport since the 757, which first flew in 1982. There was supposed to be a 797 by now, but it keeps sl
by Animats 3y ago
The trouble is, Boeing hasn't built a new single-aisle transport since the 757, which first flew in 1982. There was supposed to be a 797 by now, but it keeps slipping into the far future. So they're still cranking out 737 variants, a 1960s design.
This is pathetic. Boeing could end up losing out to the COMAC C919, which, although years late, is finally flying a few routes.
- bestouff 3y agoDidn't Boing already lose to Airbus ?
- Semitangent 3y ago"Boing" because of the little jump it makes after crashing?
- panick21_ 3y agoWell, yes Airbus has more market share. More orders and more deliveries. But Boeing is still very competitive in the profitable wide-body market. So Airbus is bugger but its not like Boeing is going bust or something.
- charrondev 3y agoThey’ve definitely lost market share, but even if you would prefer to buy Airbus they now have a backlog of ~9,000 aircraft to deliver. For reference in 2022 they shipped 661 aircraft and 735 in 2023. I’m assuming they are increasing manufacturing capacity but that doesn’t change the fact that their backlog extends into the next decade.
- ZaoLahma 3y agoWhy is it troublesome? As someone with very limited knowledge in aircraft development, I'm genuinely curious about what more modern designs would bring to the table compared to the modern 737s, which I assume are heavily updated versions of the original 1960s design?
- consp 3y ago> heavily updated versions of the original 1960s design Isn't that the cause of many problems?
- ZaoLahma 3y agoAnd this is what I'm curious about. I can't imagine much of the original design would be left in the aircraft except for the overall shape of it. I'm guessing (remember now, basically zero aircraft development knowledge) that most tech has been updated to modern equivalents. Engines, controls, computers, ...? So what would be changed in a complete overhaul of the aircraft?
- kalleboo 3y ago> overall shape of it That's the problem. It was designed for 60s-style boarding via air-stairs on the ground (rather than modern jetways from the terminal) so it's too low down. This requires doing funky things to fit modern, large, energy-efficient engines, starting with those weird flat-bottom cowlings and ending in moving the engines back and changing their angle, which changes the flight characteristics of the plane so much it needed MCAS to compensate. > So what would be changed in a complete overhaul of the aircraft The certification, meaning pilots would need re-training since it's no longer the same plane. The MCAS thing clearly changed the plane so much it should have required re-training anyway, which is why the whole thing is so dumb.
- ZaoLahma 3y agoHuh, I see. So keeping it around for so long was mostly for avoiding expensive R&D and pilot re-training, and not so much for the 737 being the perfect platform to keep iterating on. Interesting.
- Gravityloss 3y agoThe aircraft world has its peculiarities. Lots of cases in light aviation where some crashed plane is rebuilt basically from scratch but it's cheaper from regulatory perspective to say it's the same plane, just repaired, ie reuse the tail number.
- vegardx 3y agoI don't really see that happening unless they make the C919 much more efficient. There's probably a market for Comac where Boeing and Airbus aren't allowed to sell due to sanctions or whatnot, but that's a separate issue.
- dmix 3y ago> This is pathetic. Boeing could end up losing out to the COMAC C919 Maybe that's a good thing. It will be a lesson to the US to not prop up a shitty monopolies for decades just because it's currently the only local option and losing dominance in the short term is oh-so-scary to techocrats who want to orchestrate everything. They should have encouraged and enabled the domestic development of competitors to Boeing - as a long term play - instead of repeatedly propping them up in the short term, just to keep the status quo going. It shows how little confidence, or interest, the US gov and US business community as a whole have in America's ability to compete on merit alone. With lots of juice by Boeing to manipulate an easily manipulated system that has become overly comfortable manufacturing these pseudo private businesses, without true accountability to either the market or gov. Although I don't blame any up and coming US manufacturer that looks at Boeing's cushy arrangement with the gov and the regulatory system bending over for them alone and hard passing attempting to compete.
- tracker1 3y agoBoeing strategies for domestic upstarts range from interesting to terrifying... Mostly burying them in decades of IP litigation until they are bankrupt. The auto industry has nothing on Boeing.
- jMyles 3y agoSure they have - they very family under discussion. Just because they have attempted to foist a polite fiction that it is a 737 variant doesn't mean that it actually is. It's a new single-aisle transport with several serious problems.
- filleduchaos 3y agoIt is a 737 variant, though. That's precisely where the several serious problems come from.
- jMyles 3y ago> It is a 737 variant In name only, and by dint of software cludges to prime the vividness of our ability to imagine that pilots needn't be separately type-rated. ...but we all know that if it weren't for MCAS (and by extension, if it weren't for Boeing's special seat at the FAA table), this wouldn't pass muster. (but yes, I think you and I are saying the same thing.)
- filleduchaos 3y ago"In name only" is an interesting way to say "literally re-engined 737s with minor tweaks to the airframe, in line with an incremental development". Again, the whole reason the "software cludges" were implemented in the first place is precisely because it's more or less the same "hardware". The entire problem is that the 737 MAX family is in fact made up of 737s when they should have been redesigned from scratch. It's baffling to me how one could come to the conclusion that they aren't 737s.