8 ms·
Patients say keto helps with mental illness. Science is racing to understand why
- adaptbrian 3y agoKetosis will likely be what I credit for saving my marriage and actual life once science catches up with reasoning. The last year for me has been profound. Cluster headaches are mental warfare and ketosis has played a major role in my body's ability to chill the hell out. Can't wait to see more research here.
- tmikaeld 3y agoI started with intermittent fasting (16H) and I reached ketosis within a few days. I've been on lchf/atkins before, but getting there via fasting was easier and less brain-fog. Being in ketosis is such a drastic difference in energy and mental clarity that it's ridiculous.
- Pete_arten 3y agoI'm also doing the 16/8 IF schedule, but I honestly don't feel like I am able to enter ketosis. However, I do have better sleep and I would say more energy. It also helps me to limit "junk" intake.
- tmikaeld 3y agoHow often and how much I eat during non-IF matters a lot. But doing regular Huel Black sizes (2-3 Scoops) 2x/day and I'll easily be within keto, sometimes it's too little energy though so I combine it with 2 eggs (organic).
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- Erratic6576 3y agoRestricting meal hours made me realise that eating junk is worse than not eating at all
- mmcgaha 3y agoThe surprising benefit that I noticed on a keto diet was the lack of joint pain.
- elliotec 3y agoI can't help but think "finally" and "told ya so" regarding this news. It's difficult to describe how massively my life changed when I started keto. Like the subject of the article, I've had Bipolar (1 in my case, they didn't specify their version) for most of my life, since way before it's supposed to manifest in late adolescence. I was misdiagnosed here and there since I was a very young child, but I finally got on the right treatment plan at 20 years old. The maintenance of that treatment plan has been taking a medium dose of Lamictal, an epilepsy drug, daily. It worked damn well compared to the regular mania, often culminating in psychosis and occasional full-on can't-even-hold-a-job levels of suicidal depression, but within a week of full-blown ketosis, I was a new person. I found out about it through some documentary disguised as "In Defense of Fat" or something similar, and I was fascinated by the epilepsy cure thing. I had always known there was a connection between my condition and epilepsy, given that I was on seizure drugs and often experienced what I figured were mini-seizures (often described as brain zaps, I think). I couldn't find any information on links except a few random, very weak studies, and sorta just told everyone who naysayed me to fuck off cuz it works for me. I lost 20 lbs of excess covid weight as a very nice side-effect, but I can safely say this is the most effective treatment I've ever experienced for my condition (of the many, many I've tried) and I feel like I have superpowers in comparison. It is very obvious if I get kicked out of ketosis now after a few days or so. I've done it purposefully on vacations or just random cheat times. After a while I feel worse in the head, body, and soul. I make dumb or impulsive decisions (like my old self), or am grumpy in a way I haven't been since starting. I start to have awful dreams again and wake up my wife sleep-talking in distress, and am tired all the time like the old days. It's certainly not the easiest diet to adhere to, it's also surely not the best for the environment unless you're really strict in specific ways like some, and it's potentially disruptive socially, but it's a lifestyle choice that has given me personally a truly new and improved life that I don't ever want to or plan to return from.
- tmikaeld 3y ago> It's certainly not the easiest diet to adhere to, it's also surely not the best for the environment I'm able to sustain keto when using Huel Black (17% carbs), but your mileage may vary. And Huel is both vegan and sustainable. (I'm not affiliated, just a user)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoI mean we already know switching to a keto based diet can have massive effects on the brain, it's been used to treat seizures since the 1920s, so it's not surprising it would have more effects.
- toomim 3y agoAnd fasting has been a part of human spiritual (read: "psychological") practices for millennia. It's no surprise that it does something to the psyche.
- gibagger 3y agoRegardless of spiritual or psychological practices. Fact is food was generally nowhere near as available as it is now for the vast majority of our evolution as a species. We didn't evolve around day-long snacking.
- imadierich 3y ago[dead]
- m463 3y agoI've read the book "the glucose revolution" and it is pretty interesting how regulating glucose spikes can affect your mental clarity, energy levels and general health and wellbeing. When you eat carbs, your blood sugar rises. At first it fuels your muscles, then at some point your body has to release insulin to protect itself, keeping your blood sugar low using fat storage. Later, the blood sugar will crash, leading to a lack of energy and brain fog. There are some hacks in the book to help with this, like walking after eating (muscles take up more of the spike), or eating in order (fiber first to moderate blood sugar, followed by protein/fat, and finally any carbs) I think a keto diet probably has the same effects, as a consequence of removing simple carbs from your diet. It might be better to understand this all holistically and manage it with decent nutrition, not just cutting out all <x>.
- yurishimo 3y agoEating things is order really is "life-hack" if you're into low-carb/keto. If do some extended fasting and break it with only meat, I usually have some mild gastric distress side effects. Not really a problem for me, but for some people, it can be a distraction that they would rather not have to deal with. However, if I start eating again by first consuming a large amount of fiber, a big (150g+) salad for example, the effect is much reduced. Another benefit of starting with fiber, is that your body will begin processing it and sending signals of satiety earlier than if you started carbs. Another hack I suppose is waiting 10 minutes between courses in your meals. Giving your body time to digest can help you feel fuller and prevent overeating. Especially when you grew up with the "clean your plate" form of parenting, learning to break that habit and stop when you're actually full can be a game changer for managing weight and body composition.
- zczc 3y agoInteresting, the "hack" of eating in order is just return to the traditional way of eating veggie appetizer first, then meat main dish, and then dessert.
- m463 3y agoI guess it depends on tradition. Some restaurants "traditionally" bring out bread or chips while you're waiting for the food (even the appetizers) to arrive. And in most restaurants, many appetizers are not plant-based.
- triyambakam 3y agoKeto just ignores the real issue - microbial (im)balance. It might help short-term (that's relative) , but it's not a fix for gut health. Humans are unspecialised frugivores. Our teeth be flat like for eat fruits and plants, not for tear meat. And our digestion system be long, cherry for fiber. Da kine sweet ono loa!
- shzhdbi09gv8ioi 3y ago> Humans are unspecialised frugivores. While this is true for some ape species, it is not true for the human or our ancestors in the Homo genus. [1, 2]. > Our teeth be flat like for eat fruits and plants, not for tear meat. That is not true. Human teeth are specialized for an omnivore diet. > The best evidence that humans are omnivores comes from the teeth. Humans have short canines that are a functional consequence of having an enlarged cranium and associated reduction of the size of the jaws. In other primates, the canines are comparatively longer than humans as they function as both defense weapons and visual threat devices. Interestingly though, both Gorillas and gelada baboons prefer vegetarian diets. Humans may have no need for long pointy canines as carnivores do for such use, particularly for capturing prey and threatening enemies. They do have canines that are pointy enough to serve the purpose of tearing meat. The molars and premolars, in turn, are used to crush food. [3] 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_habilis#Diet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_habilis#Diet 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_erectus#Food https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_erectus#Food 3: https://www.biologyonline.com/articles/humans-omnivores https://www.biologyonline.com/articles/humans-omnivores
- triyambakam 3y agoI'd really like to see a human try to tear raw flesh off an animal with their canines. I am highly skeptical that would work at all.
- shzhdbi09gv8ioi 3y agoMe too. What gave you that impression it would be a reasonable interpretation of what I posted, or are you just trolling?
- Almondsetat 3y agoPeople have shit diets (and they don't realize it) so when they finally decide to stick with a famous one they get results. Every popular diet tells you to eat less and eat natural, keto amongst them. Unless you have allergies: no, it'a not keto, no, it's not Atkins, no, it's not veganism: it's not eating crap.
- dawnerd 3y agoThat’s being awfully dismissive about what keto is, it’s not just a diet, it’s an actual state you maintain your body in which is why it’s being looked into for helping people out.
- sigmoid10 3y agoThis is the real answer. Keto, Paleo, intermittent fasting... all these things work exactly the same way: by limiting your calorie intake. When the population approaches an obesity rate of 40% (not overweight, clinical obesity!), anything you try will help to counteract the highly processed, far too calorie dense food we get on every corner. People swear on their own diet approach because of some biochemical aspect, but the only relevant difference between these diets is that most people find some easier to stick to than others. Minding your calories is far better for your mind and body in the long term than anything else.
- watwut 3y agoAnd then you have rising rates of eating disorders due to all the messaging being all about restricting calories which creates fear of food which puts people in a real acute danger.
- sigmoid10 3y agoThe most prevalent eating disorder is still (unintentional) overeating. Not eating 2000+ extra calories of fast food every day has never put anyone in danger.
- 3y ago
- Modified3019 3y agoA PSA: Pigs and chickens (and likely most Monogastric animals, which includes you) tend to bioaccumulate polyunsaturated fat from their feed, though the specifics will depend on the breed and circumstances. Pigs and chickens fed on soybean meal can have polyunsaturated fat percentages that rival or exceed what you see in vegetable oils. Also note that the nutrition label can often be outright wrong/outdated. Polyunsaturated fat has a big tendency to exacerbate mental issues, for a variety of possible reasons but a big one likely being that it can result in chronic systemic inflammation. So don’t make the mistake of thinking “animal fat = saturated fat” like I did, and ending up triggering a major depressive episode. Ruminants (cows/goats/sheep) seem remarkably resistant to this accumulation even when fed shitty meal.
- scoofy 3y agoThere are a lot of claims here, but not a lot of citations.
- rkho 3y agoI lost a lot of weight on ketosis several years ago but could not maintain the diet and gained it all back shortly after. Since then I've found something that works better for my body that I can sustain which keeps some of the principles of keto. I no longer limit my carbs, but when I eat carbs they come from rice and potatoes instead of wheat because I wore a CGM for two-week periods of time multiple times last year and the year prior and found that wheat was always the number one culprit spiking my blood sugar which would result in massive carb crashes, which overall affected my energy levels which snowball into negative second-order effects on my feelings of productivity and mood.
- edu 3y agoInteresting, I ended in the same position but just from observing myself.
- yurishimo 3y agoI'm envious of people who can realize these things about themselves. For me, I almost always need concrete data to make me stop and think about how I'm feeling and put two and two together. Otherwise my scatterbrain is thinking about anything and everything else.
- k__ 3y agoI saw some improvements on my ADHD symptoms after doing keto for a week or so.
- sph 3y agoMy meds definitely feel stronger one week into keto. Paired with the increased energy and better sleep, it feels like being on a constant caffeine high. Perhaps that's what normal people feel when they take stimulants.
- yoaviram 3y agoAlso worth mentioning that Keto shows promise as a treatment migrants. Here's a good place to start: http://www.ketoformigraine.com/ http://www.ketoformigraine.com/ (I'm not affiliated).
- eptcyka 3y agoKetosis nominally is associated with a state of hunger, which in turn contorts this innocent typo into something darker.
- jijijijij 3y ago> Also worth mentioning that Keto shows promise as a treatment migrants. Lol. This typo could make it big time! A large urea crystal finally dislocates from Mr. Jordan Peterson's biological urethra, and so he weeps for a white kid getting bullied somewhere. Master P signals the host, who allegedly is in ketosis too, for the recording to keep rolling, although, that goes without saying, he can't speak profoundly at the moment. With uberwill and force, simply not possible running on carbs, he bravely breaks through weltschmerz vocal chord spasms, faintly reaching peak insight for the audience: "It's not just a diet; it's a revelation of white genocide!"
- watwut 3y agoI really wondered how does it treat migrants, like they wont come at all or they have some sickness that gets help with keto? So the link was actually useful as it migraines
- TruthWillHurt 3y agoHell, if I was eating steaks every day my mood would improve too...
- srid 3y agoI did this for a while. It was great in the beginning, but gets boring soon. I now do quite well on eggs and ground beef. Been eating like this for many years now: https://srid.ca/carnivore-diet https://srid.ca/carnivore-diet
- KptMarchewa 3y agoOne steak a week is a reasonable proposal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- spidersenses 3y agoAs a person of normal weight, I tried a keto diet a couple of times but just couldn't get it working under vegetarian/vegan dietary restrictions for a daily work + workout schedule. I got either underfed to the point of fainting, had to rely on expensive restaurant meals and questionable supplements, or had to spent an enormous amount of time on meal preparation. So either I approached this in a completely wrong way or keto just isn't for "normal" folks like myself with busy schedules.
- dustincoates 3y agoVegan is decidedly not "normal" if we define normal in the sense that it is common. Only 0.5% of the American adult population is vegan (only 2% vegeterian).[1] Not that there's anything wrong with being vegan! But it definitely a minority position. 1: https://veganbits.com/vegan-demographics/ https://veganbits.com/vegan-demographics/
- spidersenses 3y agoThe “normal” in my comment referred to the average weight and busy life. I am primarily an ovo-lacto vegetarian, only occasionally vegan.
- OJFord 3y ago> primarily an ovo-lacto vegetarian, only occasionally vegan That's like an omnivore saying they're occasionally vegan because not 100% meals contain meat or dairy?
- spidersenses 3y agoLet's just say, that every once in a while I go vegan for a couple of days or weeks. That's slightly different from the "accidentally vegan" meal. If it was possible to combine keto, a meat-free diet, and intermittent fasting, without breaking the bank or breaking the body, that would be the dream.
- hellectronic 3y agoI heard the podcast from Huberman and Dr. Chris Palmer and they talk about ketosis and mental illness. It was really interesting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjEFo3a1AnI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjEFo3a1AnI
- wouldbecouldbe 3y agoHuberman jumps on everything that is being hyped and finds one minor study to support it and talks about it like it's revolutionary and super trustworthy at the same time.
- ilitirit 3y agoI don't think you really need keto, but I think many people could benefit from just training themselves to eat fewer times a day, and developing an aversion to sugar and unhealthy food in general. I don't eat breakfast - haven't done so for more than 20 years. It doesn't affect my enerygy levels or mood. It always made me wonder why we even had it in the first place. All I have is a cup of black coffee, no sugar. Sometimes tea with no milk. And that's only when I start work, which is around 2 hours after I wake up. These days I only eat after 5pm. My body is so used to it that I don't really get hungry during the day. Even if I go to gym in the morning. Do I notice a difference if I change my eating schedule or diet? Absolutely. If I eat during the day, I tend to want to eat more during the day. If I eat a lot of carbs and junk food, I tend to want to eat more. Also I feel like shit and my skin looks horrible. I think somewhere in all this mess there are mental health concerns as well, but I can't really quantify them in a meaningful way.
- EZ-E 3y ago> I don't eat breakfast - haven't done so for more than 20 years. It doesn't affect my enerygy levels or mood. It always made me wonder why we even had it in the first place I noticed it is closely related to habit. When travelling I usually eat breakfast, lunch and dinner while I usually skip breakfast and sometimes lunch outside of travel. After travelling is done I feel a hunger pang in the morning where I would have taken breakfast as my body starts to "expect" it. Few days after ignoring it, it goes away...
- saiya-jin 3y agoYou must realize the world and humanity is bigger than you. Some people with low blood sugar would be very weak without breakfast (ie my wife and most of her family, tested repeatedly under various real world situations ie in wilderness). Some thrive like that. Some, like me, don't care if they have or don't have breakfast, nothing visibly changes for me (unless I want to bulk a bit from ie weightlifting or generally doing very strenuous activity especially if its multiday). Another case point for each' uniqueness - you mention you just drink black coffee on empty stomach. On university one of my classmates went through mandatory military service back then and he did exactly this. He utterly and forever destroyed his stomach lining (as per doctor's findings it was due to that coffee habit, even sugar or milk would help but he didn't know) and till end of his days. Tons of basic food that would make him cramp painfully or shit badly for hours. That he achieved within 1 year while you did 20 years of same seemingly without any issue.
- aszantu 3y agoBeen collecting for a while, hope it helps https://github.com/cutestuff/FoodDepressionConundrum/blob/main/Toxins.md https://github.com/cutestuff/FoodDepressionConundrum/blob/ma...
- pavlov 3y agoAs a counterexample, a dear friend of mine has a cluster of mental illnesses which are clearly made worse by his ceaseless keto diet obsession. He didn't need an eating disorder on top of all the other issues he already had, but that's where he's ended up by consuming diet advice from the internet.
- watwut 3y agoDiet advice I collected from HN: no matter how much you eat, you should eat less. Ideally you should eat once a day and exercise a lot. You should pick one of those highly restricted diets too, completely excluding at least one food group. Also, no reason to ever worry about lack of anything (iron, vitamins, minerals, whatever), none of that is ever an issue.
- eurekin 3y agoFor all wanting to try out, please consider a dietician consultation first. They typically recommend cutting on gluten and dairy first as a protocol. For me it was enough to significantly alter the quality of life. You might not need the full keto, only the "autoimmune exclusion protocol", which can help after long time stress adaptations
- Llamamoe 3y agoThere's at least two possible ways for it to help: 1) Feeding different gut microbes. Often, pathogenic fungi and bacteria feed on simple carbs, which are abundant in normal diets, and drive inflammation that causes mental and physical illness 2) Ketone bodies are an alternative fuel for the brain that does not rely on glucose uptake mechanisms, which are often impaired by (pre)diabetes, inflammation, shit sleep, etc. all of which are very common.
- 2devnull 3y agoIt changes electrolyte balance from what I’ve experienced, so that’s another likely way. Try being dehydrated and depressed. You can’t! The will to live kicks in and overrides depression. Like the guy who jumped off Golden Gate Bridge who on hitting the water was filled with sudden will to live. Near death is a good cure for a lot of things. That’s why keto works.
- watwut 3y agoIt is very possible to be dehydrated and depressed. Or starwing and depressed. Moreover, people in acute mortal danger situations (wars) commit suicides. Depressed people dehydrate and starw themselves. Starwing people (including those with eating disorders) get depressed as result of starvation.
- incomingpain 3y agoThe article was just published but it's understood why it works, why are they writing as if it's not understood? There's no 'racing' to understand why anymore. The last big keto popularity like 5+ years ago now has enabled years of keto research to happen. In fact, we also know typical keto ways of exiting the mental health benefits while remaining keto. Sort of traps. There's many keto types which work. I'm not a believer in net-carbs. Carbs are carbs, limit all carbs to 30g or less per day. No artificial sweeteners, they all suck. No honey, you don't eat the barf of anything else, why bees? Eggs and Cheese are your big tester of if you can handle those. In my anecdotal experience, it's crazy how many sugar zombies exist in society. They are all depressed and think the world is ending. They think they are conscious, but they clearly arent, controlled by carb and other cravings. Something like 80% of north america are zombies? https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2021.1974336 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2021.1... > Our results show that meat abstention (vegetarianism or veganism) is clearly associated with poorer mental health, specifically higher levels of both depression and anxiety. I would disagree. Veganism is certainly possible, but 99% of vegans will not do what is necessary. Vegetarianism is not different from veganism in this discussion.
- n2dasun 3y agoI'm certain this is oversimplified and not really how nutrition works, but I always liked to think maybe eating more fat was fortifying the myelin sheaths around our neurons and preventing signal "arcs"