3 ms·
The Sun CEO at the time claimed that they would have paid Google to use Java, the disagreement was who got to make decisions and neither side trusted the other
by ZeroGravitas 15y ago
The Sun CEO at the time claimed that they would have paid Google to use Java, the disagreement was who got to make decisions and neither side trusted the other to get it right (personally I think history has vindicated Google on this point).
- pron 15y agoWell, considering the success of Amazon's Android fork, I think that vindication is still pending. And no matter who's been right - legally or business-wize - I find it seriously annoying to have two Javas.
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoAmazon use Dalvik don't they? Why not the JVM?
- pron 15y agoBecause OpenJDK is GPL licensed, and I guess Amazon didn't want to open-source their code. BTW, Google doesn't want to open-source (or even let Apple look at) the Nexus Android code.
- nl 15y agoThat's not the case. Sun wanted to charge Google for the license, but also wanted there to be a per-handset license fee. That per-handset fee was what Google couldn't agree on.
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoDirect quote from Schwartz's testimony: "We probably would have paid them to work with us on a Java phone" The decision of exactly how open-source to be and therefore whether to require a per-handset fee is the kind of decision I was referring to that they couldn't agree on.
- nl 15y agoFrom Schmidt's testimony: Sun wanted $30-50 million for a Java license http://mobile.theverge.com/2012/4/24/2970872/live-eric-schmidt-testimony-oracle-google-trial http://mobile.theverge.com/2012/4/24/2970872/live-eric-schmi... I've read the $300 million figure and per-handset fee elsewhere, but I can't find it now.
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoThe bigger point is, these figures (even $300 million) are a pittance for Google/Sun/Oracle compared with meeting their wider business goals. Google must have spent about that much just trying to launch a competitor to H.264 (e.g. roughly 130 million to buy On2).