3 ms·
The speed of light compared to the size of the universe means that even if there is life out there they will not find out about use before we are gone. Even if
by bluGill 3y ago
The speed of light compared to the size of the universe means that even if there is life out there they will not find out about use before we are gone. Even if they are going to all solar systems odds are against them finding us. Not to mention there is no reason to think they would survive a trip to us.
- fortyseven 3y agoSays, so confidently, the member of a species who hasn't yet discovered a form of FTL travel. The general assumption is that any visitor from outside the solar system has found a unique solution to this enormous problem beyond our current level of understanding.
- bluGill 3y agoSays confidently someone who has studied physics enough to get a basic understanding of relativity. I'm not very good at physics, but I know enough to state confidently that FTL will never be possible. Anyone who has studied physics will agree with me: while there is a lot we don't know, every possible answer to them still needs to fit with what we already know and you can't explain several things we know while also allowing for FTL.
- addandsubtract 3y agoWe still can't explain the big bang, yet here we are. Just because something can't be explained with our current models or understanding, doesn't mean it's forever impossible.
- bluGill 3y agowhat we cannot explain must still obey the rules we have figured out. Much as you might wish otherwise.
- cevn 3y agoI have one thought on FTL travel. Creation of a “naked singularity” by spinning a black hole fast enough to counter the forces holding it together. However the singularity will remain incompatible with our universe, and will then spread at the speed of causality popping, destroying everything in its path. But within that new universe, it might be possible.
- elashri 3y agoThe problem is not the current size of the universe is big, it is that it is expanding with time. Aliens will still have to contend with the same physics laws because they are universal (in the tight meaning of universal here). We can actually model the recession velocity of emitted photon from a source (will be higher that speed of light) depending on our universe model. To have aliens that are near enough so that they made contact with us ( through some signal not by abduction of humans) would mean they they very close on cosmological scale that they must be living within our detection capabilites. And with all our searches for life so far nearby we couldn't see a signal for unique civilization signature.
- tmnvix 3y agoIs it possible that quantum entanglement could play a role here? Is travel actually necessary for information transfer? Obviously I know little to nothing about such things.