5 ms·
What does "a shortage" mean in supply and demand? I don't understand, because it seems to mean "we want to pay less but then we won't find any people". Well, in
by stavros 3y ago
What does "a shortage" mean in supply and demand? I don't understand, because it seems to mean "we want to pay less but then we won't find any people". Well, in that case, there's a shortage of Ferraris, because the ones I can find are too expensive.
- andy99 3y agoAnd if you were a big business, you'd hire lobbyists to petition the government for Ferrari subsidies and buy news articles talking about the Ferrari shortage, and tell all your friends that the only reason you don't drive a Ferrari is purely because of the shortage and has no relationship to your finances or priorities.
- randomdata 3y agoTechnically, it means that there is some external mechanism that prevents price from rising. Typically that means government intervention. Healthcare often sees the government set a price ceiling on services to ensure that poor citizens are not priced out of receiving healthcare, so a shortage of medical doctors is quite possible. A shortage of truck drivers is unlikely. Under colloquial usage, as it is being used here, the term is meaningless. Under that definition, everything is always in "shortage". It is simply used as an attention grabbing mechanism to express some kind of emotion towards the subject.
- thfuran 3y ago>A shortage of truck drivers is unlikely. Surely a transient shortage is possible due to licensing requirements. You could offer ten million dollars a year, but there are only so many people with a current CDL and finite capacity exists to grant new licenses.
- randomdata 3y agoThe cool thing is that if we really did see ten million dollar per year offers, then most people wouldn't want to use the services of truckers anymore (too expensive), so you'd still have the right number of truckers, if not too many, among those currently able to drive, without the need for more. No need to wait on anyone else getting licensed. You have done well to highlight why a technical shortage is defined the way it is.
- thfuran 3y agoThat's begging the question.
- randomdata 3y agoDoes the question not find begging to be a tad bit pathetic?
- CydeWeys 3y agoThe licensing requirements for being a truck driver just aren't that onerous. It's way way harder to become a doctor, lawyer, hell, even hairdresser in many states.
- thfuran 3y agoA shortage of doctors could definitely stick around for longer, but it's still external influence limiting market actors.
- randomdata 3y agoA shortage of doctors is quite likely as many jurisdictions place price ceilings on doctor services. In fact, where I live, it is quite illegal for a doctor to accept any amount of payment from a patient. We as a society believe that people, no matter how rich or poor, should have equal access to healthcare, so a doctor giving priority to a billionaire who can offer a handsome reward to get his common cold looked at over someone suffering something much worse is considered abhorrent. As such, we rely on a mixture of first-come, first-serve and needs-based priority instead of a price-based mechanism. Never heard of any attempts to place similar restrictions on truckers, though. If you want to try and charge a billion dollars per mile, go nuts!
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoIn economics you can’t have a shortage in a perfect market as you note. Of course most (all?) markets are imperfect so various factors can cause shortages (eg rent controls is a common example). For labor markets imperfect mobility can cause a shortage. In common use it means that something costs more than many people are willing to pay for it. So your Ferrari example would be a valid use under this meaning.
- QuarterReptile 3y ago>In common use it means that something costs more than many people are willing to pay for it. More likely it costs far less than people are willing to pay for it. When the Colonial Piepline was shut down for ransomware, the shortage occurred because a reasonable populace correctly assessed that the local value of gasoline had just skyrocketed far beyond its steady state price, so the demand became limited only by time and social costs (e.g. you don't want to be the guy whose picture is shown filling trash bags of gasoline) plus ways to store it.
- grotorea 3y agoMaybe we can still call it a shortage if there's some unexpected and/or temporary reduction in supply or increase in demand. You could still buy oil during the 1970s oil crisis but it still was a shortage. Or it can mean that there's insufficient supply to meet demand at a "reasonable" price.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- solidsnack9000 3y agoIn most contexts, a shortage is when there is a gap in supply due to external factors. This results in resource allocation not responsively adapting to price signals. A commonly used example is milk, yogurt, cream and ice cream. Every year, the farmers produce milk. Some people want yogurt, some want milk, some want cream, &c. Say that one year, everyone wants yogurt for some reason. They are lining up to pay 200%, &c, for it. Then the allocation of resources adapts -- more milk is used to make yogurt. If demand for other products does not go down -- people still want just as much milk, ice cream, &c -- then their prices may go up. Over a reasonable time frame, the effect of this is that more land will be turned over to pasturage and more milk will be produced. Gradually the prices will come down. More people have more yogurt than before; more people are working on that and less on something else (whatever it was). The workers and consumers live happily ever after and resource allocation has adapted to price signals. One important consideration in the above example is that if people want more yogurt and are willing to pay more, they must also be willing to go without something else. They only have so much money (so much of their own resources to allocate). That is why the resource allocation has to change. Now that might not be milk, per se, but it is probably something adjacent to it, like tofu. We can see how if the shift is from tofu to yogurt, the reallocation of resources might take longer -- people can't just take the milk consumers don't want and turn it into yogurt, they have to get more milk first, which means feeding more soybeans to cows and less to tofu machines -- but it still happens. A simple example of a shortage is a situation where a virus affects a certain fruit tree, preventing it from growing (or, at least, preventing it from growing the desired fruit). Although people are willing to pay a lot for this fruit, and by extension are willing to consume less of other fruits or other foods, there is no way to turn resources over from the production of other goods to the production of this fruit. It might be that only a small number of areas are isolated enough to produce this fruit; they might all be turned over to it; but after that, there would be no elasticity in the supply of this fruit. Given what we know about the pricing, demand, ordinary cost of inputs for producing the fruit, the supply of this fruit before the virus, we must conclude that there is considerable demand which is not being met. (Something else notable about the second example is that most of the new, elevated price of the fruit would go into some form of rent. The ground on which the fruit could be produced would be exceedingly rare and valuable, but the material inputs, labor, skill, &c needed for the fruit are the same as before; the new high price would mostly go to the ground rent or financing costs.)
- nightpool 3y agoNot everything is a perfectly elastic market. In fact, nothing is. For example, if I wanted to go out and hire 250,000 US-based computer programmers tomorrow, I would not be able to even if I wanted to pay them a million dollars each, since there are only 132,740 computer programmers across the entire US. So that would constitute a shortage of computer programmers. It would take many years to create the number of educational institutions, training programs, etc necessary to have that many programmers available to hire. The same could be said for many industries on a much smaller scale—how many people are willing to relocate to driving trucks in northern Canada? Probably not as many as you'd like, even if you had an unlimited budget. How many qualified airplane pilots are there in the world? Too few—we don't have enough training programs for them and mandatory "aging out" requirements have removed a lot of the pilots we already had. A lot of new training and education programs for pilots have been started in the past year, but they're going to take 4-5 years until the supply has increased enough that we're no longer in a shortage. (And although this is a heavy topic of debate between union leaders who say that there's no shortage and airlines who say that there is, I think the amount of investment in slow and costly supply increase programs is a good sign that there's at least some amount of supply constraint/bottleneck affecting the industry. It's hard for there not to be when safety and training requirements make the supply pool so slow to respond to changes in demand).
- sokoloff 3y ago> there are only 132,740 computer programmers across the entire US Source? That feels extremely low, maybe even by an order of magnitude.
- medvezhenok 3y agoYeah, that's either out of date or only counts people that report their title as "Computer Programmer" rather than "Software Engineer" or one of the myriad of other ways to describe people who develop/maintain software. The recent estimates are closer to 4.4 million software engineers in the U.S. (~2.75% of the working population)
- 3y ago