4 ms·
Looks like an astroturf campaign, with essentially the same story popping up around the country. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39159783 https://news.yco
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Looks like an astroturf campaign, with essentially the same story popping up around the country.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39159783 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39159783
- jmuguy 3y agoYep, the couple quoted at the start of the article "started noticing wear on the tires" at 5k. And then the 7k quote is also from them - note that it doesn't say they actually had to replace at 7k.
- toxik 3y agoI would not be surprised if tires wear faster on a vehicle that weighs ~40% more. Another thing to consider is road damage, which is famously proportional to the weight to the power of four. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_power_law
- jmuguy 3y agoThey do wear faster on EVs but sub 10k miles is definitely not typical. This article is definitely written to grab attention with that 7k figure in the headline and then immediately starts walking that back.
- toxik 3y agoSure, clickbaiting is just the world we live in. On the other hand, dismissing this as astroturfing is also a bit un-nuanced.
- infecto 3y agoNo, EVs do not damage roads. Its not famously proportional, there is a cut off and consumer vehicles, including EVs, do not damage roadways. Large semi trucks do. Not sure how you calculate 40% but that sounds wildly off, unless you are cherry picking and comparing a Rav 4 to that wildly heavy Hummer. Lets take a real comparison though, Model Y at the top end is 4400lbs, a Rav4 at the top end is 3600lbs. Thats a 22% increase, heavier yes but not 40%. Edit: Here is one source to show why EVs are not tearing up the road. https://twitter.com/ajisuzu1/status/1681123111364620294?s=46 https://twitter.com/ajisuzu1/status/1681123111364620294?s=46 My TLDR is there is essentially a cutoff where the weight matters. Going from 3800lbs to 4400lbs is not whats causing damage, its the 60,000lb loaded semi (and I think 80k is actually the max weight cutoff.
- toxik 3y agoThe car I drive weighs about 1300 kg, the Tesla Model X is about 2400 kg. I was being conservative with 40%. Edit: turns out my car weighs even less. Edit2: asked Google for most common, seems Tesla Model S at around 2100 kg.
- infecto 3y agoThats my point, you created an example to match your narrative. Same if you were to compare your car against a Ford F-150, its not a like for like comparison. Rav 4 - Model Y is a good comparison to capture the extremes. Lexus Rx 350 is 4200lbs for their base trims.
- toxik 3y agoPeople aren't picking between a Ford F-150 or a Tesla where I live, they pick between a normal ICE 5-seater or a Tesla. It's not cherry-picked, it is me-picked, a sample of 1 but a sample nonetheless. You OTOH have fabricated a choice that makes it seem reasonable. A truck is a work vehicle, a Tesla is personal transportation. The cyber truck is the like-for-like with a F-150, or at least it is designed to be.
- infecto 3y agoSorry you are, I am the one providing real world examples, you are the one saying they weight 40% more. Perhaps there is an equivalent car in your market where you could say its a like for like comparison and it is indeed 40% more but from what I can tell its usually around 20-25%. Toyota Camry, 3300lbs. Model 3, 4000lbs. 20% If you want to provide a like for like example go for it. But it has to be a like for like, not a Toyota Yaris hatchback vs a Model Y. Not sure why you are clarifying what a like for like comparison is. I am making the point that you have a cherry picked 40% example, without backing up the models and I am giving you like for like comparisons where its 20%.
- infecto 3y agoSo many edits. Tell us what your car is then? You keep picking different cars. Model x 5400lbs, BMW x5 4800lbs. 12%
- bryanlarsen 3y agoA Tesla Model 3 is 0-15% heavier than a BMW 3 Series. A Ford Lightning is 10-20% heavier than a gasoline SuperCrew. EV's are not 40% heavier.
- r00fus 3y agoWhere did you get 40%? The EV version of my car (Ford Focus) is 10-20% more than a typical Ford Focus (depending on trim).
- stavros 3y agoI've been seeing a lot of anti-electric stories recently, even here. A lot about how Hertz has been selling their electric cars (mostly unrelated to them being electric, but because they see a lot of scrapes and scrapes are costlier for them to fix on the electrics they have), about how the market is cooling down, etc. Seems like some interests are threatened by the prevalence of electric cars.
- thefz 3y agoYou can't engine-brake with an electric engine (with a combustion car, downshifting will force your car to be slower when going downhill, basically) so in mountain regions with ups and downs there's way more braking leading to massively increased tyre wear.
- RichardHesketh 3y agoYou clearly haven’t owned or driven one. Most have a configurable setting for regenerative braking, where the rotation of the wheels turns the motors to put energy back into the battery, and this has a very similar effect on speed. Less flexible, perhaps, than engine braking, as most EVs have a single forward gear, but I’ve now driven 86,000 miles in mine and am still on the factory discs and pads.
- thefz 3y agoRegenerative or not, while braking you are still inflicting the whole weight of your car onto the tyre threads.
- dgacmu 3y agoFirst, you can: many electrics have a regenerative braking mode that you can engage that will provide some amount of "engine braking"-equivalent slowing down. And on some of them you can select how much slowing is applied. It's very similar to manually selecting a gear. Second, huh? How does engine braking reduce tire wear at the same speeds? Brakes do not contact the tire. It reduces brake wear... Gentle braking reduces tire wear but that's possible with either mode.
- mrcartmeneses 3y agoBased on the quotes near the end of the article I’d guess it was a tire retailer’s PR department. Either that or the oil lobby, naturally
- fergie 3y agoGlad to see more awareness of this type of thing