5 ms·
As usual, Gladwell is cherrypicking data to display something unrelated to reality. Let's look at the first QB picked since 1999. 2000: Chad Pennington, this y
by mattmaroon 18y ago
As usual, Gladwell is cherrypicking data to display something unrelated to reality. Let's look at the first QB picked since 1999.
2000: Chad Pennington, this year starting qb for the Jets, doing well.
2001: Michael Vick, who was one of the top few QBs in the league. Of course talent scouts can't predict animal cruelty.
2002: David Carr: Playing backup to Eli Manning. Started for 6 years until an injury sidelined him. Not a McNabb, but far from a Tim Couch
2003: Carson Palmer: 2 pro bowls with the Bungles.
2004: Eli Manning: Superbowl MVP
(here's where players are still too new to tell much about)
2005: Alex Smith: that one hasn't worked out yet and may never.
2006: Vince Young: Promising backup on the Titans.
2007: JaMarcus Russell: Starting for the Raiders
2008: Starting for the Falcons.
Either way, in any non-Gladwellian universe, I'd say college QB scouts are doing pretty well.
- twampss 18y agoBungles. I see what you did there... ;)
- mattmaroon 18y agoI'm from Browns territory, sorry.
- twampss 18y agoOh I'm not a Bengals fan - just never heard that clever team name before. Well played!
- dpapathanasiou 18y ago"just never heard that clever team name before" You obviously haven't been watching ESPN for, oh, the past decade.
- twampss 18y agoHa! I'm a programmer, what can I say? ;)
- mattmaroon 18y agoYeah I don't think ESPN.com is getting many pageviews from this crowd.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- utnick 18y agoA better test of if QB scouts are doing well is if the #1 QB pick turns out to be the best QB in the draft. In most of those years you listed, there was a better qb left on the table after the first qb pick.
- breily 18y agoOut of the 9 years listed it really only happened 3 times that a better QB was left - 2000 (Tom Brady), 2002 (David Garrard - debatable, but he's starting and Carr isn't), and 2005 (Aaron Rodgers). So 6 times out of 9 the best one was taken first - that seems pretty good. If you go back even further I'd imagine this trend would continue - even Gladwell's main example (Ryan Leaf) was taken second to the best QB playing today (Manning).
- mattmaroon 18y agoYeah, Garrard/Carr is debatable. Garrard wouldn't be starting over Eli Manning either. So it may be 7/9.
- utnick 18y agonot to turn this into sports news but: 2003: romo 2004: roethlisburger 2006: cutler 2007/2008: way too early Historically speaking: steve young, montana, marino, and I could go on were not thought of highly by scouts I thought it was commonly accepted that scouting QBs is a guessing game.
- mattmaroon 18y agoI'll give you 2003, not 2004, and I'd lump 2006 into too early to say for sure though you're probably right.
- breily 18y agoYea, I don't want to get into a huge debate about this either, and the names you mentioned are definitely in the same class as the first picks. My main thought was that while its not a science, the scouts are definitely not just randomly picking players like Gladwell makes it out to be (saying that "there is no way to know who will succeed at it and who won’t" and that "college performance doesn’t tell us anything").
- robg 18y agoHmmm, who's cherrypicking data? ;) 2000: Chad Pennington, Pick 18, Career Rating: 89.7; Marc Bulger, pick 168, Career Rating: 85.7, Tom Brady, Pick 199, Career Rating: 92.9 2001: Mike Vick, Pick 1, Career Rating: 75.7; Drew Brees, Pick 32, Career Rating: 89.1 2002: David Carr, Pick 1, Career Rating: 74.6; David Garrard, Pick 108, Career Rating: 85.4 2003: Carson Palmer, Pick 1, Career Rating: 88.9; Tony Romo, undrafted, Career Rating: 96.6 2004: Eli Manning, Pick 1, Career Rating: 76.4; Big Ben, Pick 11, Career Rating: 89.9; JP Losman, Pick 22, Career Rating: 76.9 2005: Alex Smith - Noted; Aaron Rodgers, Pick 24, Career Rating, 89.8; Jason Campbell, Pick 25, Career Rating: 80.5; Matt Cassell, Pick 230, Career Rating 84.2 2006: Vince Young, Pick 3, Career Rating: 68.6; Jay Cutler, Pick 11, Career Rating: 88.6 2007: JaMarcus Russell, Pick 1, Career Rating: 67.5 - uhhh, "top" QB 2008: Matt Ryan, Pick 3, Career Rating: 92.0 - very good - so far So, of the last nine years, the top QB taken has turned out to be the best QB of that year, maybe once. Russell just isn't good. He won't be starting for long. And Ryan, it's too soon to really tell. Meanwhile, QBs taken, sometimes very, later have often been as good, if not better, than the top QB's in 6 of the last nine drafts you cite. There are just as many guys like Brady, Bulger, Garrard, Romo, and Cassell (picked well behind "names") as there are top picks that have panned out. EDIT: Forgot Romo.
- lief79 18y agoYou might as well add Flacco to 2008 too. He's doing fairly well starting with the Ravens. -- Delaware alumni
- mattmaroon 18y agoI didn't cherrypick, I simply pointed out that the QBs scouts rate the best generally perform very well. Every now and then a Tom Brady or Kurt Warner sneaks up out of nowhere, but for the most part almost every starting QB was first round drafted and often first overall. Also, don't confuse best passer rating for best quarterback. All sorts of things factor into the QB's passer rating, such as the quality of his receivers and offensive line, his team's style, etc. Those numbers aren't very meaningful. Nobody would ever suggest that scouts could get it perfectly, or near perfectly, in order, but they do a pretty fantastic job. You can cherrypick data to show a few black swans, but for the most part they're highly accurate.
- thomasmallen 18y agoGotta correct you on Young. He was a promising starter who many, including myself, thought could make the Pro Bowl very soon (especially if he played with wide receivers). Then he became a head case and lost his job to a mediocre Kerry Collins. Also, I think you should include the second and third quarterbacks taken to round out your stats...that might be interesting, with stars like Ryan Leaf :^)
- fallentimes 18y agoWhat's also interesting is how having the top pick cripples the drafting team due to the ridiculous salaries given to unproven talent. If I had the top pick, I'd trade it every time. 50/50 chance isn't good enough for allocating 8 figure salaries. The NFL needs a rookie scale like basketball.