4 ms·
i wonder if further progress in physics will require abandoning the maxwellian paradigm in the same way that maxwell had to abandon the newtonian paradigm? pres
by kragen 3y ago
i wonder if further progress in physics will require abandoning the maxwellian paradigm in the same way that maxwell had to abandon the newtonian paradigm? presumably for something even further removed from everyday experience. dyson must have thought about that possibility, but evidently at least at the time of this paper he rejected it. i'd like to read his reasoning
unrelatedly, i feel like i kind of understand maxwell's theory in terms of vector analysis, but the clifford algebra formulation is still beyond me. it sure looks a lot simpler
- eru 3y agoKeep in mind that we for all the talk of 'abandoning' the Newtonion paradigm, it's predictions are still valid for a large space of conditions. Eg NASA uses Newtonian mechanics to fly all their spacecraft. Special relativity includes classical mechanics when speeds are low. In the same way, any replacement for Maxwell's paradigm must reproduce the predictions of Maxwell's equations under the large swathe of conditions where they agree with reality.
- kragen 3y agoyes, i thought that was too obvious to be worth saying, but i'm glad you've said it so the knuckle-dragging contingent don't think i'm endorsing their untutored 'theories' for that matter i use the aristotelian paradigm of physics when i expect my bed to stop moving when i stop pushing it across the floor; i don't bother with calculating the deceleration due to the friction coefficient with the floor
- eru 3y agoSorry, I think the first part of your original comment was a bit confusing. Upon rereading: the second part already made it clear that this is what you meant.
- kragen 3y agoi don't think there's a non-confusing way to discuss questions like this, so plausibly this is not the right forum for it
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoMaxwell's Equations have already been superseded by Quantum Electrodynamics, in the same way that Newtonian gravity has been superseded by General Relativity. Both Newtonian gravity and Maxwell's Equations are still very good approximations in their regimes of validity.
- kragen 3y ago[dead]
- kragen 3y agowe are commenting on an article which describes in depth how quantum mechanics, including qed, falls squarely within the paradigm maxwell pioneered. that's why my comment specifically talks about the 'maxwellian paradigm' and not 'maxwell's equations', which is, by the way, not a brand name i thought it was too obvious to be worth saying that classical physics is still an excellent approximation to reality, but hopefully you've enlightened someone reading this thread
- denton-scratch 3y ago> 'maxwell's equations', which is, by the way, not a brand name Are you commenting on the capitalization of "Maxwell"? It is a proper name, and it should be capitalized.