3 ms·
> To notice that people can't use a natural language interface because they're bad at organizing and expressing their thoughts, then claim this is a failing of
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> To notice that people can't use a natural language interface because they're bad at organizing and expressing their thoughts, then claim this is a failing of the interface is for the poor craftsmen to blame their tools.
No, its not.
The UI is the output of the craft, not the tool of the craftsman. And the blame isn't coming from the craftsman, anyway.
It is just as true as the one about craftsmen, if not as popular a saying, that it is a poor toolmaker who blames the people who the tools are made for the tools' unsuitability for their purpose. If a user interface doesn't work for the actual users, it is a poor UI.
- bloaf 3y agoMy three points are meant to be taken together. You might say that the toolmaker's job is to make a foolproof tool that does its job completely independently of the user's skill. But my third line denies this possibility in the context of language models.
- anon373839 3y agoIf an application is for the general population, it seems there is some empirical evidence that open-ended text interfaces won’t meet those users’ capabilities. So exposing a language model directly to the end user is probably not a good design direction to go in.