2 ms·
Of course nobody needs convincing of the idea that Hitler was a fucking idiot, but also, designing a philosophy of racial purity so aggressive that it scares aw
by bee_rider 3y ago
Of course nobody needs convincing of the idea that Hitler was a fucking idiot, but also, designing a philosophy of racial purity so aggressive that it scares away like half of your physicists, including probably the best physicist in generations, was a pretty boneheaded move. I guess he didn’t know that they were on the verge of a wild and completely war-changing discovery, but physicists are always up to something.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe Germans were also disastrously behind with radar, but were way ahead with rocket engines and turbojets. Their faith in Enigma also arguably cost them the war.
- defrost 3y agoTheir faith in the Lorenz cipher aka Fish cipher codenamed Tunny also arguably cost them the war. The Germnans were suspicious of Enigma security given Polish cryptanalysts had an attack in the late(?) 1920s and further attacks in the 1930s. The German High Command used Lorenz for significant traffic .. this was cracked by the Britsh, by Bill Tutte and others, in house at Bletchley during WWII.
- dmichulke 3y agoFrom what I'm reading, it wasn't as decisive as "costing Germany the war". Instead if would have delayed D-day and other operations by a year or more but the benefit is arguably on the side of Germany because both the Soviet Union (making Germany "pay") and the US (first use of the atomic bomb there?) had more sinister intentions. https://www.historynet.com/what-if-the-allies-had-not-broken-the-german-naval-code/ https://www.historynet.com/what-if-the-allies-had-not-broken...
- WalterBright 3y agoEnigma caused the U-boot campaign to fail. Many U-boot commanders were convinced that Enigma was compromised, as the circumstances of the losses were too coincidental. But Admiral Doenitz doggedly refused to believe that. All the Kriegsmarine needed to do was layer on a one-time pad - a simple and effective technique. But nope. The failure of Enigma also caused Rommel to lose the Afrika campaign. The Allies knew when and where his supply ships were coming, and sank them one after the other. Rommel knew that these losses were only explainable by espionage, but believed the Allied disinformation and misdirection as to the cause.
- dmichulke 3y agoInteresting points that I wasn't aware of. Still, in my understanding this doesn't seem to make a German victory more likely in retrospect because it wouldn't have sufficiently impacted the campaign in the East. At best I see more fuel, stronger Italy, and weaker GB in it.