5 ms·
Following lawsuit, rep admits "AI" George Carlin was human-written
- jpalawaga 3y agoThe "no, actually, a human did it" is an interesting defense. How are you to prove one way or another short of finding system logs of an AI outputting the material? Further, does copyright law really care what generate the material? Either the material is copyrighted or it isn't, and people aren't signing licenses about reproducing what they hear/interpret/etc (which, imo, would be a flagrant misapplication of copyright law). That being said, I haven't researched how likeness laws extend beyond the person's life.
- PeterisP 3y agoCopyright law cares about what generated the material, because it protects certain rights of the creator of the work, and if you can't point to a human creator whose rights were violated (a machine or program has no legal rights) then no one has any exclusive rights to that work, it's outside the scope of copyright law, it's effectively "uncopyrightable". These rights can be transferred from the author to a corporation, for example, in employment contract or law; but a corporation can't simply claim them if they never existed in the first place.
- ertian 3y agoThis is kind of an interesting twist on a Turing test. If you can't tell by examining the work whether it was created by a human or an AI, then how can we say that a human is creative an an AI is not?
- kelseyfrog 3y agoIs this rhetorical? Authorial essentialism. This would be the belief that the text/words are imbued with a metaphysical attribute while the text is created that depends on the properties of the author. This is sort of the same umbrella belief that underpins the "words in the Bible are written by God" conclusion that some people have. I'm guessing that you and I both aren't authorial essentialists, but as for a way people could believe this, it's not a stretch of the imagination.
- cmcaleer 3y agoAs it relates to computers though this seems incredibly messy and a bad interpretation. Is my python script copyrighted, but the bytecode (generated by a computer) not? How do compiled programs have any copyright protection? Am I only violating a computer's copyright (so no copyright) if I crack DRM on a generated executable file[1]? Does the DMCA anti-circumvention protection only apply to hand-applied protection? When is a computer doing too much of the work? What about a Blender render? I think it would take me a hot minute to do those raytracing computations by hand. Do I only get the copyright to the output if I do that? The most straightforward way to look at it is that computers and their programs are a tool, and their output as used by a person or person on behalf of a company. I think this current definition as I (NAL) understand it is unworkable and probably won't last long-term. [1] Say for the sake of argument that there's no images or models or things that are obviously copyrighted, it's just a CLI calculator
- PeterisP 3y agoThe bytecode is not a novel creative work and does not have a separate copyright, this affects, for example, copyright terms (not that they are already relevant for code with the terms being so long) - the effective copyright date is when you wrote the source code, not when it was compiled; and of course the authorship - it does not matter who owns the machine or who initiated the compiling, only the writing of the original source code. But it is protected effectively as a "copy in a different format" of the original work - just as for a book, perhaps the author originally wrote as a manuscript with a quill on parchment or on a computer, and for the physical printed book it matters when and how the book was originally written (first 'fixed on a durable medium'), not what machines or tools were used in typesetting and printing the copy that you have - and the printed copy is still protected as a copy of that original creative work fixed in a manuscript. In essence, as far as copyright law is concerned, the bytecode isn't generated by a tool, it's transformed by a tool.
- kmeisthax 3y agoProcesses that transform creative work do not add creativity, but also do not erase it. So both your Python files and anything in the __pycache__ dir are copyrighted. More specifically, the __pycache__ is the same work in a different form, so it's the same copyright. You couldn't, say, dedicate the source to the public domain and then claim copyright over the binaries. DMCA anti-circumention has to do with computer programs that enforce copyright. The work being protected has to be under copyright, but not the protection itself. The only reason why AI art is completely uncopyrightable is because the only human contribution is a text prompt which is too short and functional to be copyrighted. Even if you're getting creative with your prompt writing, none of that creativity translates over into the final art - you're just keyword stuffing a small language model.
- kmeisthax 3y agoThis argument is backwards. George Carlin is a human, and he's the one whose rights were presumably violated. It's the creator of the fake George Carlin stand-up special's job to prove their behavior was legal. Saying that the AI George Carlin was human-written only means that, if creating your own George Carlin special is fair-use for some reason, then the human gets to claim copyright over that special. If it's AI then there's no copyright - at least, over the parts created by AI. Just to make things even more confusing, this also has nothing to do with the copyright on the training set data. If the AI you used had a 100% licensed training set, you still have to worry about how the AI's legally uncreative[0] contribution to the work dilutes your ownership of it. [0] As in, whether or not AI is creative, as a matter of law, it's not creative.
- latency-guy2 3y ago> How are you to prove one way or another short of finding system logs of an AI outputting the material? I imagine the defense is the same as any other defense of "no, it was not me, it was someone other than me", you must establish your presence or activity at the time, or if they're the defendant, establish enough doubt to the prosecution's position. Not a lawyer at all though.
- dotancohen 3y agoBut saying "the tool did it" is ridiculous. AI is still a tool, not a separate responsible entity. "I did not shoot the sheriff, Your Honour. The Colt did it."
- Lerc 3y agoIn this case I don't think it is terribly pertinent whether or not the content was AI generated. The issue here is someone is trying to capitalize on the legacy of George Carlin. Admitting that it is human-written does not change that aspect. I'm not an expert in the entire IP landscape, but I suspect this might not be a copyright issue at all. The problem is the brand (how George would hate that phrasing) is being appropriated. If you paid an artist to draw a picture of Keanu eating donuts for an advertising campaign there would be the same issue. If anything this ends up being a partial defense of AI, given that the issues raised are neither specific to AI nor require additional laws to seek redress. It is hard to determine how much of the article text >That training would, by definition, involve making "unauthorized copies" of "Carlin's original, copyrighted routines" ...is a quote from the lawsuit. It is certainly not clear in a moral or legal sense whether training constitutes making an unauthorized copy. That is the big issue to be decided. Having an opinion and declaring it does not make it true. People are doing that on both sides already. It should be noted that in addition to the legal issues, comedians have their own culture which is separate from the legal definitions of acceptable behaviour. The tolerance for reusing ideas is considerably lower within that community. Many things that are perfectly legal might render you a pariah to that community.
- notfed 3y ago> The issue here is someone is trying to capitalize on the legacy of George Carlin. Personally, if someone creates an entertaining video that successfully captures the spirit of George Carlin, or any deceased speaker or artist, that sounds awesome. I'm all for it. I'd also love to have another Led Zeppelin album. How would you suggest someone creates this ethically?
- quatrefoil 3y agoThat was the whole gimmick here, though. They pitched it as "AI-generated George Carlin". They used his likeness for the thumbnail. They faked his voice. Nothing is stopping you from writing a novel in the style of Harry Potter, but if you put "Harry Potter" in the title and use the same typeface, you're probably gonna get a call from a lawyer, because you're clearly trying to capitalize on existing IP instead of letting your work stand on its own merits. Is that wrong? There's plenty of people bashing the concept of intellectual property here because Disney or whatever, but most artists aren't fat cats, and copyright protects their livelihoods without forcing them to rely on state sponsorship or private patronage - both of which are pretty problematic for artistic expression.
- askonomm 3y agoI saw that video on YouTube, and I thought it was also written in the description of the video that it was human written, and even human voiced, but then made sound like Carlin with AI.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- unsane 3y agoYeah, at the time it was pretty widely known that this was the case (I don't recall whether it was in the description specifically). There's no revelation or admission that suddenly occurred this week.
- JieJie 3y agoI guess I figured it was written by Kultgen with the help from ChatGPT? It would have been a noteworthy feat for a built-from-scratch-by-training-on-MADtv-episodes foundation model was capable of generating the Carlin video at the click of a button. That’s still obvious to the average person, isn’t it? Maybe not? (And is that officially the world we live in now?) Anyhoo. Still fair use, and even more so. A joke doesn’t have to rise to a certain level of hilarity to deserve 1st A. protection. Even when, especially when, the joke is on us.^0 0: https://www.npr.org/2022/10/04/1126773469/onion-supreme-court-brief-author-interview https://www.npr.org/2022/10/04/1126773469/onion-supreme-cour...
- drewcoo 3y agoGreat. Can we all just Mencia this Chad Kultgen dude and be done with it?
- WrockBro 3y ago> Anticipating potential free speech defenses, the lawsuit argues that the special "has no comedic or creative value absent its self-proclaimed connection with George Carlin” and that it doesn't “satirize him as a performer or offer an independent critique of society.” How is commenting on current events not "an independent critique of society"?
- labrador 3y agoGeorge Carlin always credited his older brother Patrick for being the genius of the family, so if I were them I would have presented "George Carlin's Genius Brother For the First Time!" or something like that, but of course that would be wrong and disrespectful as well. Maybe more legally defensible. https://variety.com/2022/film/news/patrick-carlin-dead-90-george-carlin-brother-1235234338/ https://variety.com/2022/film/news/patrick-carlin-dead-90-ge...