2 ms·
The one exception is probably if you want to screw bolts straight in without any kind of prep work (tapping) on the hole. Then accuracy matters, too much slop a
by jacquesm 3y ago
The one exception is probably if you want to screw bolts straight in without any kind of prep work (tapping) on the hole. Then accuracy matters, too much slop and your bolt won't hold or it will strip the material, too little and you may well end up snapping the bolt, especially a thin one.
Apropos machining pistons: the bigger issue with anything that needs a reliable 'Z' dimension on any kind of cutter like this (essentially a two-dimensional device) is that that third dimension is really only well specified at the point of focus. Outside of that it is more or less conical depending on the kind of cutter and the optics in case of a laser. Waterjet, plasma and laser all have different characteristics depending on what you cut with and in case of a laser the construction of the head and the kind of optics installed. Plasma also has work hardening effects that can not be ignored.
The only economical way to accurately cut large pieces of thick material is by using a heavy gantry mill or an EDM machine. Both will still be very costly and this sort of use is probably outside of the hobby arena anyway. If you need that kind of work piece I would suggest outsourcing it.
- kragen 3y agoyeah, those inkjets always seem to use metal machine screws to hold everything together. i don't know how to tell how the screws (and, in many cases, nuts) are made but they do seem pretty precise but i didn't mean to say that cheap inkjets contain no tight tolerances; they contain lots of tight tolerances. (the ones on the nozzles and on the traces on the integrated circuits are a lot smaller than the ones on the screws.) i meant to say that the in-operation movements of most of the parts of the printer don't have to be precise because negative feedback compensates for any errors they introduce the printer doesn't make any screws or any holes in anything or screw in any screws, it just squirts ink onto paper, so there isn't a question of how precise the holes it makes are
- ComputerGuru 3y agoI read your response until near the very end and was itching to replying "but EDM!" before I got to your last paragraph! I actually was lucky enough to be able to use EDM for my initial prototype and I remain absolutely confounded as to what degree of accuracy, precision, and repeatability we're able to get out of this fairly old machining technique (and one that also avoids the z-depth issues you pointed out), but it has its drawbacks. It's insanely slow (though I don't know if machines made this side of 1990 are appreciably any faster) and it's too expensive for anything other than prototyping or one-off bespoke designs, and of course there are limitations to what materials you can cut. > The only economical way to accurately cut large pieces of thick material [..] Fortunately for most real-world applications the old maxim about size and required precision being inversely correlated tends to hold. I was a die-hard subtractive machining zealot but I've slowly come around to appreciating 3D printers and they've made incredible strides in terms of capabilities and accuracy over the past decade. The hobbyist stuff still has some ways to go, but the exponential improvements are hard to ignore and I think it's become a viable suggestion for a lot of things were 2D machining used to reign king, at least where the end goal is to make something and not specifically to machine something.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe pairing of 3D printers and small lasercutters is like a fabbing super power. It's absolutely amazing what I can cook up in a matter of hours here on effectively 3 square meters. But I still miss my machine shop :) EDM is as slow as it was in the past, there have been incremental improvements but nothing that would make you go 'oh' and of course the waste in the wire is still as much a factor (and one that makes me dislike EDM but the capabilities are off the scale in terms of precision, cut depth and consistency, in machining everything has its price). One thing that I've noticed the last couple of months is that you need to change your way of thinking about this stuff. If you 'can't make it' you need to think of what you can make and then adapt your design to that. This is far more productive than to stick to the 'proper' way of doing things. Suddenly two - admittedly - fairly crappy machines outperform my old shop in many ways. I really miss the ability that my 12 KW plasmacutter gave me in terms of cutting metal with accuracy and speed. But material hardening was a drawback as was the metal vapor and the conical kerf. By re-working some of the designs to use wood instead of metal and 3D printed parts where the 2D process isn't enough I find I can make almost anything that I could make before as long as it is for indoors use and strength isn't the main factor. Nothing beats metal and welding in that department. Before getting a 3D printer and the laser cutter I would still cut metal, grind and weld pretty much regularly. But now it's a rarity, and I suspect that once I get the hang of high tech plastics that it will become even more so.